Scientia Agricultura Sinica ›› 2014, Vol. 47 ›› Issue (17): 3414-3423.doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2014.17.009

• SOIL & FERTILIZER·WATER-SAVING IRRIGATION • Previous Articles     Next Articles

Response of Rice Yield and Nitrogen Uptake to Enhanced Efficiency Nitrogen Fertilizer in China: A Meta-Analysis

YUAN Jun-li, LIANG Xin-qiang, LI Liang, YE Yu-shi, FU Chao-dong, SONG Qing-chuan   

  1. College of Environmental & Resource Sciences, Zhejiang University/Key Laboratory for Water Pollution Control and Environmental Safety, Zhejiang Province, Hangzhou 310058
  • Received:2014-04-08 Online:2014-09-01 Published:2014-06-22

Abstract: 【Objective】This study is the first to make a large-scale assessment of the effect of the application of enhanced efficiency nitrogen fertilizers (EENF) on rice yield and plant N uptake quantitatively to provide a scientific basis for evaluating the economic benefits of EENF and promoting the use of EENF in China.【Method】A total of 48 peer-reviewed studies were collected in Chinese and English books and journals to establish a field experimental database, and a meta-analysis was conducted to quantitatively evaluate the response of rice yield and N uptake to EENF in China and to determine under what conditions EENF are the most effective. 【Result】 The results suggested that, on average, the application of EENF made rice yield and N uptake increase by 7.5% (95% CI: 6.7%-8.4%) and 10.5%(95% CI: 9.5%-11.4%) , respectively. In terms of factors, it was found that soil pH had a significant effect on rice yield and N uptake, which was increased by 10.5% and 18.8% in alkaline soils(pH≥7.5) which are more than that in acidic (pH≤6.5) and neutral soils (pH: 6.5-7.5). Coated slow/controlled release nitrogen fertilizer (CRF) was better than nitrification inhibitors, especially for N uptake, nitrification inhibitor had no effect on it, but CRF made it increase by 17.9% than conventional fertilization; EENF applied as basal fertilization was better than split fertilization, which increased rice yield and N uptake by 4.2% and 7.5% and they were less than as basal fertilization. Besides, mixing EENF with control fertilizer had equal effect, and it was labor-saving; the best practice for N rate was 120-180 kg•hm-2, which increased rice production and N uptake by 6.5% and 12.1%, respectively. At last, the application of EENF in northern China was better than in southern China, because it increased rice yield and N uptake by 3.4% and 3.0% more than in southern China.【Conclusion】The best practice in this study to increase rice yield and plant N uptake is to use EENF, especially the coated slow/controlled release fertilizers (applied into alkaline soil as basal fertilizer) when the total N rate is 120-180 kg•hm-2.Application of nitrification inhibitors, especially 3,4-dimethylpyrazole phosphate (DMPP) is not suitable for paddy fields to increase N uptake in China. It seems that rice planting way (transplant or direct sowing) and fertilization methods of EENF (EENF only or mixed with conventional nitrogen fertilizers) have little difference in improving rice yield and N uptake. It may be better to apply EENF in northern China than southern China.

Key words: enhanced efficiency nitrogen fertilizers (EENF) , rice , yield , nitrogen uptake , meta-analysis

[1]Fageria N K, Baligar V C. Enhancing nitrogen use efficiency in crop plants. Advances in Agronomy, 2005(88): 97-185.
[2]廖千家骅, 颜晓元. 施用高效氮肥对农田N2O的减排效果及经济效益分析. 中国环境科学, 2010, 30(12): 1695-1701.
Liao Q J H, Yan X Y. N2O mitigation effects and economic impacts from enhanced-efficiency N fertilizers from fields in China. China Environmental Science, 2010, 30(12): 1695-1701. (in Chinese)
[3]朱德峰, 陈惠哲, 徐一成, 张玉屏. 我国双季稻生产机械化制约因子与发展对策. 中国稻米, 2013, 19(4): 1-4.
Zhu D F, Chen H Z, Xu Y C, Zhang Y P. Constraints and countermeasures of the mechanization of double rice production in China. China Rice, 2013, 19(4): 1-4. (in Chinese)
[4]杨春蕾, 袁玲, 李英才, 梁新强, 吴良欢, 陈宏坤. 南太湖流域控释包膜尿素对水稻产量及稻田氮素流失的影响. 土壤通报, 2013, 44(1): 184-190.
Yang C L, Yuan L, Li Y C, Liang X Q, Wu L H, Chen H K. Effects of controlled-release coated urea on nitrogen loss of rice fields and rice grain yield in the southern region of Taihu Lake. Chinese Journal of Soil Science, 2013, 44(1): 184-190. (in Chinese)
[5]Xu M G, Li D C, Li J M, Qin D Z, Hosen Y, Shen H P, Cong R H, He X H. Polyolefin-coated urea decreases ammonia volatilization in a double rice system of Southern China. Agronomy Journal, 2013, 105(1): 277-284.
[6]宋付朋, 张民, 史衍玺, 胡莹莹. 控释氮肥的氮素释放特征及其对水稻的增产效应. 土壤学报, 2005, 42(4): 619-627.
Song F P, Zhang M, Shi Y X, Hu Y Y. Releasing characteristics of controlled-release nitrogen fertilizer and its effects on rice yield. Acta Pedologica Sinica, 2005, 42(4): 619-627. (in Chinese)
[7]刘忠新, 孙磊, 吴英, 刘玉林. 包膜控释尿素对寒地水稻产量与氮肥利用率的影响. 北方水稻, 2009, 5(5): 10-12.
Liu Z X, Sun L, Wu Y, Liu Y L. Effect of coated controlled released urea in yield and nitrogen utilization efficiency of rice in cold region. North Rice, 2009, 5(5): 10-12. (in Chinese)
[8]吕玉虎. 豫南稻区水稻缓/控释肥应用效果研究. 中国农学通报, 2012, 28(9): 97-101.
Lü Y H. Study on application efficiency of slow/controlled release fertilizer in paddy field in south Henan. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2012, 28(9): 97-101. (in Chinese)
[9]温贤芳, 王宝忠, 王福钧, 彭根元, 麦鸿逵. 应用同位素15N研究硝化抑制剂对水稻的增产作用. 土壤学报, 1979, 4(4): 380-386.
Wen X F, Wang B Z, Wang F J, Peng G Y, Mai H K. Study of the effect of nitrification inhibitors on the rice yield applied with isotope 15N. Acta Pedologica Sinica, 1979, 4(4): 380-386. (in Chinese)
[10]郑凤英, 彭少麟. 几种数量综述方法的介绍与比较. 生态科学, 2001, 20(4): 73-77.
Zheng F Y, Peng S L. Introduction to several quantitative review methods. Ecologic Science, 2001, 20(4): 73-77. (in Chinese)
[11]Arnqvist G, Wooster D. Meta-analysis: synthesizing research findings in ecology and evolution. Trends in Ecology &Evolution, 1995, 10(6): 236-240.
[12]Glass G V. Primary, secondary, and meta-analysis of research. Educational Researcher, 1976, 5(10): 3-8.
[13]郑凤英, 彭少麟. 整合分析中两种假设模型的介绍及实例分析. 生态科学, 2004, 23(4): 292-294.
Zheng F Y, Peng S L. Comparison of two hypotheses models in meta-analysis and its sample using. Ecologic Science, 2004, 23(4): 292-294. (in Chinese)
[14]Linquist B A, Liu L, van Kessel C, van Groenigen K J. Enhanced efficiency nitrogen fertilizers for rice systems: Meta-analysis of yield and nitrogen uptake. Field Crops Research, 2013, 154: 246-254.
[15]Ainsworth E A, Davey P A, Bernacchi C J, Dermody O C, Heaton E A, Moore D J, Morgan P B, Naidu S L, Ra H S Y, Zhu X G, Curtis P S, Long S P. A meta-analysis of elevated [CO2] effects on soybean (Glycine max) physiology, growth and yield. Global Change Biology, 2002, 8 (8): 695-709.
[16]黄昌勇. 土壤学. 北京: 中国农业出版社, 2000: 175.
Huang C Y. Soil Science. Beijing: China Agriculture Press, 2000: 175. (in Chinese)
[17]Moya T B, Ziska L H, Namuco O S, Olszyk D. Growth dynamics and genotypic variation in tropical, field-grown paddy rice (Oryza sativa L.) in response to increasing carbon dioxide and temperature. Global Change Biology, 1998, 4(6): 645-656.
[18]Ziska L H, Namuco O, Moya T, Quilang J. Growth and yield response of field-grown tropical rice to increasing carbon dioxide and air temperature. Agronomy Journal, 1997, 89(1): 45-53.
[19]石生伟, 李玉娥, 刘运通, 万运帆, 高清竹, 张仲新. 中国稻田CH4和 N2O排放及减排整合分析. 中国农业科学, 2010, 43(14): 2923-2936.
Shi S W, Li Y E, Liu Y T, Wan Y F, Gao Q Z, Zhang Z X. CH4 and N2O emission from rice field and mitigation options based on field measurements in China: an integration analysis. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2010, 43(14): 2923-2936. (in Chinese)
[20]Hedges L V, Gurevitch J, Curtis P S. The meta-analysis of response ratios in experimental ecology. Ecology, 1999, 80(4): 1150-1156.
[21]Linquist B A, Adviento-Borbe M A, Pittelkow C M, van Kessel C,van Groenigen K J. Fertilizer management practices and greenhouse gas emissions from rice systems: A quantitative review and analysis. Field Crops Research, 2012, 135: 10-21.
[22]Morgan P B, Ainsworth E A, Long S P. How does elevated ozone impact soybean? A meta-analysis of photosynthesis, growth and yield. Plant Cell and Environment, 2003, 26 (8): 1317-1328.
[23]Curtis P S, Wang X. A meta-analysis of elevated CO2 effects on woody plant mass, form, and physiology. Oecologia, 1998, 113(3): 299-313.
[24]Adams D C, Gurevitch J, Rosenberg M S. Resampling tests for meta-analysis of ecological data. Ecology, 1997, 78(4): 1277-1283.
[25]Bax L, Yu L M, Ikeda N, Moons K G. A systematic comparison of software dedicated to meta-analysis of causal studies. BMC Medical Research Methodology, 2007, 7(1): 40.
[26]郑凤英, 彭少麟. 植物生理生态指标对大气CO2浓度倍增响应的整合分析. 植物学报, 2001, 43(11): 1101-1109.
Zheng F Y, Peng S L. Meta-analysis of the response of plant ecophysiological variables to doubled atmospheric CO2 concentrations. Acta Botanica Sinica, 2001, 43(11): 1101-1109. (in Chinese)
[27]彭少兵, 黄见良, 钟旭华, 杨建昌, 王光火, 邹应斌, 张福锁, 朱庆森, Buresh R, Witt C. 提高中国稻田氮肥利用率的研究策略. 中国农业科学, 2002, 35(9): 1095-1103.
Peng S B, Huang J L, Zhong X H, Yang J C, Wang G H, Zou Y B, Zhang F S, Zhu Q S, Buresh R, Witt C. Research strategy in improving fertilizer-nitrogen use efficiency of irrigated rice in China. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2002, 35(9): 1095-1103. (in Chinese)
[28]Mikkelsen D, De Datta S, Obcemea W. Ammonia volatilization losses from flooded rice soils. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 1978, 42(5): 725-730.
[29]Fillery I, Simpson J, De Datta S. Influence of field environment and fertilizer management on ammonia loss from flooded rice. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 1984, 48(4): 914-920.
[30]Chen D, Suter H, Islam A, Edis R, Freney J, Walker C. Prospects of improving efficiency of fertilizer nitrogen in Australian agriculture: a review of enhanced efficiency fertilizers. Soil Research, 2008, 46(4): 289-301.
[31]Norton J M. Nitrification in agricultural soils. Agronomy, 2008, 49: 173.
[32]Fillery I R P, Vlek P L G. Reappraisal of the significance of ammonia volatilization as an N loss mechanism in flooded rice fields. Fertilizer Research, 1986, 9: 79-98.
[33]宋勇生, 范晓晖. 稻田氨挥发研究进展. 生态环境, 2003, 12(2): 240-244.
Song Y S, Fan X H. Summary of research on ammonia volatilization in paddy soil. Ecology and Environment, 2003, 12(2): 240-244. (in Chinese)
[34]Zerulla W, Barth T, Dressel J, Erhardt K, von Locquenghien K H, Pasda G, Radle M, Wissemeier A H. 3,4-Dimethylpyrazole phosphate (DMPP)-a new nitrification inhibitor for agriculture and horticulture-an introduction. Biology and Fertility of Soils, 2001, 34(2): 79-84.
[35]黄益宗, 冯宗炜, 张福珠. 硝化抑制剂硝基吡啶在农业和环境保护中的应用. 土壤与环境, 2001, 10(4): 323-326.
Huang Y Z, Feng Z W, Zhang F Z. Application of nitrapyrin in agriculture and environmental protection. Soil and Environmental Science, 2001, 10(4): 323-326. (in Chinese)
[36]Slangen J, Kerkhoff P. Nitrification inhibitors in agriculture and horticulture: A literature review. Fertilizer Research, 1984, 5(1): 1-76.
[37]Guiraud G, Marol C. Influence of temperature on mineralization kinetics with a nitrification inhibitor (mixture of dicyandiamide and ammonium thiosulphate). Biology and Fertility of Soils, 1992, 13(1): 1-5.
[38]朱兆良. 农田中氮肥的损失与对策. 土壤与环境, 2000, 9(1): 1-6.
Zhu Z L. Loss of fertilizer N from plants-soil system and the strategies and techniques for its reduction. Soil and Environmental Sciences, 2000, 9(1): 1-6. (in Chinese)
[39]De Datta S K, Buresh R J. Integrated nitrogen management in irrigated rice. Advances in Soil Sciences, 1989(10): 143-169.
[40]陈贤友, 吴良欢, 李金先, 应金耀. 新型包膜控释尿素对水稻产量与氮肥利用率的影响. 浙江农业学报, 2010, 22(6): 829-833.
Chen X Y, Wu L H, Li J X, Ying J Y. Effects of new controlled-release coated urea on rice grain yield and nitrogen use efficiency. Acta Agriculturae Zhejiangensis, 2010, 22(6): 829-833. (in Chinese)
[41]Pasda G, Hahndel R, Zerulla W. Effect of fertilizers with the new nitrification inhibitor DMPP (3,4-dimethylpyrazole phosphate) on yield and quality of agricultural and horticultural crops. Biology and Fertility of Soils, 2001, 34(2): 85-97.
[42]Barth G, Von Tucher S, Schmidhalter U. Influence of soil parameters on the effect of 3,4-dimethylpyrazole-phosphate as a nitrification inhibitor. Biology and Fertility of Soils, 2001, 34(2): 98-102.
[43]Prasad M, Prasad R. Yield and nitrogen uptake by rice as affected by variety, method of planting and new nitrogen fertilizers. Fertilizer Research, 1980, 1(4): 207-213.
[44]Bhatnagar O, Sharma S. Comparative study of different methods of seeding on the yield of rice with and without weeding. Indian Journal of Agronomy, 1975, 20: 58-59.
[45]陈建生, 徐培智, 唐拴虎, 张发宝, 谢春生. 一次基施水稻控释肥技术的养分利用率及增产效果. 应用生态学报, 2005, 16(10): 1868-1871.
Chen J S, Xu P Z, Tang S H, Zhang F B, Xie C S. Nutrient use efficiency and yield-increasing effect of single basal application of rice-specific controlled release fertilizer. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2005, 16(10): 1868-1871. (in Chinese)
[46]刘秀梅, 冯兆滨, 侯红乾, 黄永兰, 冀建华, 杨成春, 刘光荣, 邹绍文, 李祖章, 张夫道. 包膜控释掺混尿素对双季稻生长及氮素利用率的影响. 农业环境科学学报, 2010, 29(9): 1737-1743.
Liu X M, Feng Z L, Hou H Q, Huang Y L, Ji J H, Yang C C, Liu G R, Zou S W, Li Z Z, Zhang F D. Effects of the controlled-release compound urea on the growth of rice and the utilizing rate of nitrogen. Journal of Agro-Environment Science, 2010, 29(9): 1737-1743. (in Chinese)
[47]纪洋, 张晓艳, 马静, 李小平, 徐华, 蔡祖聪. 控释肥及其与尿素配合施用对水稻生长期N2O排放的影响. 应用生态学报, 2011, 22(8): 2031-2037.
Ji Y, Zhang X Y, Ma J, Li X P, Xu H, Cai Z C. Effect of applying controlled-release fertilizer and its combination with urea on nitrous oxide emission during rice growth period. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 2011, 22(8): 2031-2037. (in Chinese)
[48]Wang J Y, Wang S J, Chen Y. Study on leaching loss of nitrogen in rice fields by using large Undisturbed Monolith Lysimeters. Pedosphere, 1994, 4(1):87-92.
[49]郑圣先, 肖剑, 易国英. 控释肥料养分释放动力学及其机理研究-第1报. 温度对包膜型控释肥料养分释放的影响. 磷肥与复肥, 2002, 4(4): 14-17.
Zheng S X, Xiao J, Yi G Y. Nutrient-releasing kinetics of controlled release fertilizer and its mechanism-Part 1. Effect of temperature on nutrients release of film-coated controlled release fertilizer. Phosphate & Compound Fertilizer, 2002, 4(4): 14-17. (in Chinese)
[50]杜建军, 廖宗文, 毛小云, 刘可星, 冯新. 控/缓释肥在不同介质中的氮素释放特性及其肥效评价. 植物营养与肥料学报, 2003, 9(2): 165-169.
Du J J, Liao Z W, Mao X Y, Liu K X, Feng X. N release characteristics of controlled/slowed-release fertilizer in different media and its effects evaluation. Plant Nutrition and Fertilizer Science, 2003, 9(2): 165-169. (in Chinese)
[1] XIAO DeShun, XU ChunMei, WANG DanYing, ZHANG XiuFu, CHEN Song, CHU Guang, LIU YuanHui. Effects of Rhizosphere Oxygen Environment on Phosphorus Uptake of Rice Seedlings and Its Physiological Mechanisms in Hydroponic Condition [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2023, 56(2): 236-248.
[2] ZHANG XiaoLi, TAO Wei, GAO GuoQing, CHEN Lei, GUO Hui, ZHANG Hua, TANG MaoYan, LIANG TianFeng. Effects of Direct Seeding Cultivation Method on Growth Stage, Lodging Resistance and Yield Benefit of Double-Cropping Early Rice [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2023, 56(2): 249-263.
[3] YAN YanGe, ZHANG ShuiQin, LI YanTing, ZHAO BingQiang, YUAN Liang. Effects of Dextran Modified Urea on Winter Wheat Yield and Fate of Nitrogen Fertilizer [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2023, 56(2): 287-299.
[4] XU JiuKai, YUAN Liang, WEN YanChen, ZHANG ShuiQin, LI YanTing, LI HaiYan, ZHAO BingQiang. Nitrogen Fertilizer Replacement Value of Livestock Manure in the Winter Wheat Growing Season [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2023, 56(2): 300-313.
[5] WANG CaiXiang,YUAN WenMin,LIU JuanJuan,XIE XiaoYu,MA Qi,JU JiSheng,CHEN Da,WANG Ning,FENG KeYun,SU JunJi. Comprehensive Evaluation and Breeding Evolution of Early Maturing Upland Cotton Varieties in the Northwest Inland of China [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2023, 56(1): 1-16.
[6] ZHAO ZhengXin,WANG XiaoYun,TIAN YaJie,WANG Rui,PENG Qing,CAI HuanJie. Effects of Straw Returning and Nitrogen Fertilizer Types on Summer Maize Yield and Soil Ammonia Volatilization Under Future Climate Change [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2023, 56(1): 104-117.
[7] ZHANG Wei,YAN LingLing,FU ZhiQiang,XU Ying,GUO HuiJuan,ZHOU MengYao,LONG Pan. Effects of Sowing Date on Yield of Double Cropping Rice and Utilization Efficiency of Light and Heat Energy in Hunan Province [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2023, 56(1): 31-45.
[8] FENG XiangQian,YIN Min,WANG MengJia,MA HengYu,CHU Guang,LIU YuanHui,XU ChunMei,ZHANG XiuFu,ZHANG YunBo,WANG DanYing,CHEN Song. Effects of Meteorological Factors on Quality of Late Japonica Rice During Late Season Grain Filling Stage Under ‘Early Indica and Late Japonica’ Cultivation Pattern in Southern China [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2023, 56(1): 46-63.
[9] XIONG WeiYi,XU KaiWei,LIU MingPeng,XIAO Hua,PEI LiZhen,PENG DanDan,CHEN YuanXue. Effects of Different Nitrogen Application Levels on Photosynthetic Characteristics, Nitrogen Use Efficiency and Yield of Spring Maize in Sichuan Province [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2022, 55(9): 1735-1748.
[10] LI YiLing,PENG XiHong,CHEN Ping,DU Qing,REN JunBo,YANG XueLi,LEI Lu,YONG TaiWen,YANG WenYu. Effects of Reducing Nitrogen Application on Leaf Stay-Green, Photosynthetic Characteristics and System Yield in Maize-Soybean Relay Strip Intercropping [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2022, 55(9): 1749-1762.
[11] GUO ShiBo,ZHANG FangLiang,ZHANG ZhenTao,ZHOU LiTao,ZHAO Jin,YANG XiaoGuang. The Possible Effects of Global Warming on Cropping Systems in China XIV. Distribution of High-Stable-Yield Zones and Agro-Meteorological Disasters of Soybean in Northeast China [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2022, 55(9): 1763-1780.
[12] WANG HaoLin,MA Yue,LI YongHua,LI Chao,ZHAO MingQin,YUAN AiJing,QIU WeiHong,HE Gang,SHI Mei,WANG ZhaoHui. Optimal Management of Phosphorus Fertilization Based on the Yield and Grain Manganese Concentration of Wheat [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2022, 55(9): 1800-1810.
[13] SANG ShiFei,CAO MengYu,WANG YaNan,WANG JunYi,SUN XiaoHan,ZHANG WenLing,JI ShengDong. Research Progress of Nitrogen Efficiency Related Genes in Rice [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2022, 55(8): 1479-1491.
[14] GUI RunFei,WANG ZaiMan,PAN ShengGang,ZHANG MingHua,TANG XiangRu,MO ZhaoWen. Effects of Nitrogen-Reducing Side Deep Application of Liquid Fertilizer at Tillering Stage on Yield and Nitrogen Utilization of Fragrant Rice [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2022, 55(8): 1529-1545.
[15] LIAO Ping,MENG Yi,WENG WenAn,HUANG Shan,ZENG YongJun,ZHANG HongCheng. Effects of Hybrid Rice on Grain Yield and Nitrogen Use Efficiency: A Meta-Analysis [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2022, 55(8): 1546-1556.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited

  Shared   
  Discussed   
No Suggested Reading articles found!