不同生态条件对小米黄色素含量的影响

doi:10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2019.18.015

Abstract

Abstract:

【Objective】 Grains of Setaria italica (L.) are known as millet after dehulling. Yellow pigment content in grains is one of the crucial factors affecting the value of commodity as well as nutritional quality of foxtail millet. Investigating variations of yellow pigment content across ecological conditions would contribute to breeding and utilization of new foxtail millet varieties featured by superior qualities.【Method】 Eight newly released superior and distinctive foxtail millet cultivars from the summer- sowing region in North China were planted at five locations in two consecutive years (2016 and 2017). Yellow pigment contents of the foxtail millet cultivars were determined for each location. Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) was adopted to determine the significant levels of differences for yellow pigment contents of foxtail millet cultivars under ecological conditions. Correlation analysis was performed on between yellow pigment content, and air temperature, rainfall and sunshine duration.【Result】Growing years, cultivar genotypes, growing locations × growing years, cultivar genotypes × growing years, and growing years × cultivar genotypes × growing years showed highly significant effects on yellow pigment content (P<0.01). Growing locations and growing locations×cultivar genotypes showed significant influences on yellow pigment content (P<0.05). Cultivar genotypes, growing locations, and their interactions had high contribution rate (57.12%, 27.57% and 6.12%, respectively) to the variation of yellow pigment content. Generally, yellow pigment contents of cultivars planted in 2017 were higher than those in 2016. In terms of growing locations, yellow pigment contents of cultivars planted at Jinan, Dezhou and Jining were significantly higher than those at Taian and Linyi both 2016 and 2017 (P<0.05). Yellow pigment content of the eight cultivars was averaged at 23.42 mg·kg ^-1 and ranged from 18.56 mg·kg ^-1 to 26.14 mg·kg ^-1. Among the cultivars, Zhonggu 2 had the highest yellow pigment content, while Jilügu 1 had the lowest. Moreover, there were no significant differences between Zhonggu 2, Jinuogu 2, Jigu 21, and Jigu19. However, yellow pigment contents of the above mentioned cultivars were higher than those of Yugu 18, Jigu 22, Jigu 20, and Jilügu 1. Furthermore, yellow pigment content was positively correlated with average temperature at seedling stage in June (r=0.908, P<0.01), average temperature at the middle and late grain filling stage (r=0.798, P<0.01), average temperature during growth period (r=0.808, P<0.01), sunshine hour in middle and later growth stages in September (r=0.771, P<0.01), and total sunshine hour of during growth period (r = 0.769, P<0.01).【Conclusion】Cultivar genotypes, growing years, locations and their interactions significantly affected yellow pigment content in foxtail millet. Among these factors, cultivar genotype played a key role. Moreover, variations and spatial-temporal distribution differences in meteorological factors such as temperature, rainfall and sunshine hour in different years and locations were important for yellow pigment accumulation. The higher average temperature and more sunshine hours in the middle and late stages of grain filling were beneficial to the accumulation of yellow pigment. Cultivar genotypes are the most significant element influencing yellow pigment contents.

Key words: foxtail millet, yellow pigment content, ecological conditions, air temperature, rainfall, sunshine hour

YANG YanBing, CHEN ErYing, WANG RunFeng, QIN Ling, YIN XiuBo, ZHANG HuiDi, LI FeiFei, GUAN YanAn. Yellow Pigment Contents in Foxtail Millet (Setaria italica) Under Diverse Ecological Conditions[J].Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2019, 52(18): 3232-3241.

Figures/Tables 8

Table 1

Table 2

Table 3

Table 4

Table 5

Table 6

Table 7

Table 8

References 30

[1]	YANG X Y, WAN Z W, PERRY L, LU H Y, WANG Q, ZHAO C H, LI J, XIE F, YU J C, CUI T X, WANG T, LI M Q, GE Q S . Early millet use in northern China. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2012,109(10):3726-3730.
[2]	BETTINGER R L, BARTON L, MORGAN C . The origins of food production in north China: A different kind of agricultural revolution. Evolutionary Anthropology, Issues, News, and Reviews,2010, 19(1):9-21.
[3]	LU H Y, ZHANG J P, LIU K B, WU N Q, LI Y M, ZHOU K S, YE M L, ZHANG T Y, ZHANG H J, YANG X L, SHEN L C, XU D K, LI Q . Earliest domestication of common millet (Panicum miliaceum) in East Asia extended to 10,000 years ago. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2009,106(18):7367-7372.
[4]	王海棠, 尹卫平, 阳勇, 陈海涛 . 小米黄色素的初步研究——化学成分及应用研究. 中国粮油学报, 2004,19(3):26-30.
	WANG H T, YIN W P, YANG Y, CHEN H T . Primary study on millet yellow pigment-study on chemical constituents and application of millet yellow pigment. Journal of the Chinese Cereals and Oils Association, 2004,19(3):26-30. (in Chinese)
[5]	SHEN R, YANG S P, ZHAO G H, SHEN Q, DIAO X M . Identification of carotenoids in foxtail millet (Setaria italica) and the effects of cooking methods on carotenoid content. Journal of Cereal Science, 2015,61:86-93.
[6]	ZHANG L Z, LIU R H . Phenolic and carotenoid profiles and antiproliferative activity of foxtail millet. Food Chemesitry, 2015,174:495-501.
[7]	ROBEERTS R L, GREEN J, LEWIS B . Lutein and zeaxanthin in eye and skin health. Clinics in Dermatology, 2009,27:195-201.
[8]	杨延兵, 管延安, 秦岭, 石慧, 王海莲, 张华文 . 不同地区谷子小米黄色素含量与外观品质研究. 中国粮油学报, 2012,27(1):14-19.
	YANG Y B, GUAN Y A, QIN L, SHI H, WANG H L, ZHANG H W . The studies on yellow pigment content and appearance quality of millet from different regions. Journal of the Chinese Cereals and Oils Association, 2012,27(1):14-19. (in Chinese)
[9]	RAVEL C, DARDEVET M, LEENHADT F, BORDES J, JOSEPH J L, PERRETANT M R, EXBRAYAT F, PONCET C, BALFOURIER F, CHANLIAUD E, CHARMET G . Improving the yellow pigment content of bread wheat flour by selecting the three homoeologous copies of PSY1. Molecular Breeding, 2013,31:87-99.
[10]	WURTZWL E T, CUTTRISS A, VALLABHANENI R . Maize provitamin a carotenoids, current resources, and future metabolic engineering challenges. Frontiers in Plant Science, 2012,3:29.
[11]	Fu Z, YAN J, ZHENG Y, WARBURTON M L, CROUCH J H, LI J S . Nucleotide diversity and molecular evolution of the PSY1 gene in Zea mays compared to some other grass species. Theoretical and Applied Genetics, 2010,120(4):709-720.
[12]	KUHNEN S, LEMOS P M, CAMPESTRINI L H, OGLIARI J B, DIAS P F, MARASCHIN M . Carotenoid and anthocyanin contents of grains of Brazilian maize landraces. Journal Scencei Food Agriculture, 2011,91:1548-1553.
[13]	KEAN E G, BORDENAVE N, EJETA G, HAMAKER B R, FERRUZZI M G . Carotenoid bioaccessibility from whole grain and decorticated yellow endosperm sorghum porridge. Journal of Cereal Science, 2011,54:450-459.
[14]	MOROS E E, DARNOKO D, CHERYAN M, PERKINS E G, JERRELL J . Analysis of xanthophylls in corn by HPLC. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 2002,50(21):5787-5790.
[15]	DIGESÙ A M, PLATANI C, CATTIVELLI L, MANGINI G, BLANCO A . Genetic variability in yellow pigment components in cultivated and wild tetraploid wheats. Journal of Cereal Science, 2009,50:210-218.
[16]	HARJES C E, ROCHEFORD T R, BAI L, BRUTNELL T P, KANDIANIS C B, SOWINSKI S G, STAPLETON A E, VALLABHANENI R, WILLIAMS M, WURTZEL E T, YAN J, BUCKLER E S . Natural genetic variation in lycopene epsilon cyclase tapped for maize biofortification. Science, 2008,319:330-333.
[17]	YAN J, KANDIANIS C B, HARJES C E, BAI L, KIM E H, YANG X, SKINNER D J, FU Z, MITCHELL S, LI Q, FERNANDEZ M G, ZAHARIEVA M, BABU R, FU Y, PALACIOS N, LI J, DELLAPENNA D, BRUTNELL T, BUCKLER E S, WARBURTON M L, ROCHEFORD T . Rare genetic variation at Zea mays crtRB1 increases beta-carotene in maize grain. Nature Genetics, 2010,42(4):322-327.
[18]	张耀元, 路阳, 张彬, 禾璐, 刘龙龙, 王兴春, 李红英, 韩渊怀 . 谷子类胡萝卜素生物合成途径SiLCYB基因与米色形成的关系, 分子植物育种, 2016,14(6):1341-1351.
	ZHANG Y Y, LU Y, ZHANG BIN, HE L, LIU L L, WANG X C, LI H Y, HAN Y H . The relationship between the gene SiLCYB related to carotenoid synthesis and the colored formation of foxtail millet. Molecular Plant Breeding, 2016,14(6):1341-1351. (in Chinese)
[19]	YANG Y B, JIA G Q, DENG L G, QIN L, CHEN E Y, CONG X J, ZOU R F; WANG H L; ZHANG H W, LIU B, GUAN Y A, DIAO X M. YIN Y P. Genetic variation of yellow pigment and its components in foxtail millet (Setaria italica( L.) P. Beauv.) from different eco-regions in China. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2017,16:2459-2469.
[20]	LIU M X, ZHANG Z W, REN G X, ZHANG Q, WANG Y Y, PING L U. Evaluation of selenium and carotenoid concentrations of 200 foxtail millet accessions from China and their correlations with agronomic performance. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2016, 15(7):1449-1457.
[21]	董倩楠, 刘艳芳, 程丽萍, 郭二虎, 陕永杰, 张美萍 . 不同施肥条件对谷子β-胡萝卜素和叶黄素含量的影响, 核农学报, 2018,32(5):1003-1008.
	DONG Q N, LIU Y F, CHENG L P, GUO E H, SHAN Y J, ZHANG M P . Effect of different fertilization conditions on the content ofβ-carotene and lutein in foxtail millet. Journal of Nuclear Agricultural Sciences, 2018,32(5):1003-1008. (in Chinese)
[22]	YANO A, TAKAKUSAGI M, OIKAWA K, NAKAJO S, SUGAWARA T . Xanthophyll levels in foxtail millet grains according to variety and harvesting time. Plant Production Science, 2016,20:136-143.
[23]	NING N, YUAN X Y, DONG S Q, WEN Y Y, GAO Z P, GUO M J, GUO P Y . Increasing selenium and yellow pigment concentrations in foxtail millet (Setaria italica L.) Grain with foliar application of selenite. Biological Trace Element Research, 2016,170(1):245-252.
[24]	杨延兵, 张涵, 王润丰, 邓立刚, 秦岭, 陈二影, 管延安 . 谷子籽粒小米黄色素含量的测定. 中国粮油学报, 2019,34(3):121-125.
	YANG Y B, ZHANG H, WANG R F, DENG L G, QIN L, CHEN E Y, GUAN Y A . Determination of yellow pigment content in foxtail millet. Journal of the Chinese Cereals and Oils Association, 2019,34(3):121-125. (in Chinese)
[25]	BENNETZEN J L, SCHMUTZ J, WANG H, PERCIFIELD R, HAWKINS J, PONTAROLI A C, ESTEP M, FENG L, VAUGHN J N, GRIMWOOD J, JENKINS J, BARRY K, LINDQUIST E, HELLSTEN U, DESHPANDE S, WANG X, WU X, MITROS T, TRIPLETT J, YANG X, YE C Y, MAURO-HERRERA M, WANG L, LI P, SHARMA M, SHARMA R, RONALD P C, PANAUD O, KELLOGG E A, BRUTNELL T P, DOUST A N, TUSKAN G A, ROKHSAR D, DEVOS K M . Reference genome sequence of the model plant Setaria. Nature Biotechnology, 2012,30:555-561.
[26]	ZHANG G Y, LIU X, QUAN Z W, CHENG S F, XU X, PAN S K, XIE M, ZENG P, YUE Z, WANG W L, TAO Y, BIAN C, HAN C L, XIA Q J, PENG X H, CAO R, YANG X H, ZHAN D L, HU J C, ZHANG Y X, LI H N, LI H, LI N, WANG J Y, WANG C C, WANG R Y, GUO T, CAI Y J, LIU C Z, XIANG H T, SHI Q X, HUANG P, CHEN Q C, LI Y R, WANG J, ZHAO Z H . Genome sequence of foxtail millet (Setaria italica) provides insights into grass evolution and biofuel potential. Nature Biotechnology, 2012,30:549-554.
[27]	JIA G Q, HUANG X H, ZHI H, ZHAO Y, ZHAO Q, LI W J, CHAI Y, YANG L F, LIU K Y, LU H Y, ZHU C R, LU Y Q, ZHOU C C, FAN D L, WENG Q J, GUO Y L, HUANG T, ZHANG L, LU T T, FENG Q, HAO H F, LIU H K, LU P, ZHANG N, LI Y H, GUO E H, WANG S J, WANG S Y, LIU J R, ZHANG W F, CHEN G Q, ZHANG B J, LI W, WANG Y F, LI H Q, ZHAO B H, LI J Y, DIAO X M, HAN B . A haplotype map of genomic variations and genome-wide association studies of agronomic traits in foxtail millet (Setaria italica). Nature Genetics, 2013,45:957-961.
[28]	杨延兵 . 谷子黄色素及主要组分全基因组关联分析[D]. 泰安: 山东农业大学, 2017.
	YANG Y B . Genome-wide association studies of yellow pigment and its components in foxtail millet (Setaria italica (L.) P. Beauv.)[D]. Taian: Shandong Agricultural University, 2017. (in Chinese)
[29]	NDOLO V U, BETA T . Distribution of carotenoids in endosperm, germ, and aleurone fractions of cereal grain kernels. Food Chemistry, 2013,139:663-671.
[30]	HOWITT C A, POGSON B J . Carotenoid accumulation and function in seeds and non-green tissues. Plant Cell and Environment, 2006,29(3):435-445.

Related Articles 15

[1]	ZHANG YiRu, HAN Xue, YAO XinJie, FENG Jun, WEI AiLi, LI WenChao, ZHANG Bin, HAN YuanHuai, LI HongYing. Integrated Multi-Omics Elucidates the Pigmentation Dynamics During Post-Harvest Maturation in Foxtail Millet (Setaria italica) [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2025, 58(9): 1702-1718.
[2]	LIANG Xue, JIANG Yan, WEI ChangZhou, XUE Bing, LI FangFang, CUI YiRui, ZHANG XiaRan. Research on Soil Moisture Diagnosis Model of Maize Farmland Based on Remote Sensing of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2025, 58(23): 4979-4992.
[3]	ZHOU HaoLu, SHEN ZhaoYang, LUO XinYu, HUANG YingHui, WANG KeXin, WANG YunHao, GAO XiaoLi. The Effect of Nitrogen Fertilizer on Nitrogen Use Efficiency and Yield of Foxtail Millet in Ridge-Furrow Rainwater Harvesting Planting Model [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2024, 57(5): 885-899.
[4]	DU YanWei, YAN XiaoGuang, ZHAO JinFeng, JIA SuQing, WANG GaoHong, YU AiLi, ZHANG Peng. Cloning and Functional Verification of SiCIPK21 Gene in Foxtail Millet [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2024, 57(22): 4416-4430.
[5]	DONG ErWei, WANG Yuan, WANG JinSong, LIU QiuXia, HUANG XiaoLei, JIAO XiaoYan. Effects of Nitrogen Fertilization Levels on Grain Yield, Plant Nitrogen Utilization Characteristics and Grain Quality of Foxtail Millet [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2024, 57(2): 306-318.
[6]	LIU DeLong, LI ShiRu, WANG ChuanXing, GUO ShuQing, MA ZhiXiu, WU YongJiang, HAN HuiBing, LI YuJie, ZHANG PanPan, YANG Pu. Phenotypical Variation and Dynamic QTL Mapping of Plant Height in Foxtail Millet at Different Developmental Stages [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2024, 57(18): 3533-3550.
[7]	QIN Feng, WANG XiaoFei, WU Zhen, HU YiBo, WANG XiaoQin, ZHANG JiaWei, CAI Tie. Effects of Planting Density and Row Spacing Configuration on Sugar Accumulation and Lodging Performance of Wheat Stem Under Rainfall Harvesting Planting Mode [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2024, 57(1): 65-79.
[8]	QIN Na, FU SenJie, ZHU CanCan, DAI ShuTao, SONG YingHui, WEI Xin, WANG ChunYi, YE ZhenYan, LI JunXia. QTL Analysis for Seeding Traits Related to Low Nitrogen Tolerance in Foxtail Millet [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2023, 56(20): 3931-3945.
[9]	LIU Meng, ZHANG Yao, GE JunZhu, YANG YongAn, WU XiDong, HOU HaiPeng. Effects of Nitrogen Application on Delayed Harvest Summer Maize Grain Yield, Superior and Inferior Grains Morphology and Weight Under Different Rainfall Years [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2023, 56(20): 3975-3995.
[10]	LI ShaoHui, ZHAO Wei, LIU SongYan, LI PengLiang, ZHANG AiXia, LIU JingKe. Aroma Characteristics of Foxtail Millet Varieties from Different Ecological Regions by Analysis of SDE-GC-MS Combined with OPLS-DA [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2023, 56(13): 2586-2596.
[11]	JIA GuanQing, DIAO XianMin. Current Status and Perspectives of Innovation Studies Related to Foxtail Millet Seed Industry in China [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2022, 55(4): 653-665.
[12]	GUO ShuQing,SONG Hui,CHAI ShaoHua,GUO Yan,SHI Xing,DU LiHong,XING Lu,XIE HuiFang,ZHANG Yang,LI Long,FENG BaiLi,LIU JinRong,YANG Pu. QTL Analysis for Growth Period and Panicle-Related Traits in Foxtail Millet [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2022, 55(15): 2883-2898.
[13]	DENG AiXing,LIU YouHong,MENG Ying,CHEN ChangQing,DONG WenJun,LI GeXing,ZHANG Jun,ZHANG WeiJian. Effects of 1.5℃ Field Warming on Rice Yield and Quality in High Latitude Planting Area [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2022, 55(1): 51-60.
[14]	Ting ZHANG,GenPing WANG,YanJie LUO,Lin LI,Xiang GAO,RuHong CHENG,ZhiGang SHI,Li DONG,XiRui ZHANG,WeiHong YANG,LiShan XU. Color Difference Analysis in the Application of High Quality Foxtail Millet Breeding [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2021, 54(5): 901-908.
[15]	LI ShunGuo, LIU Fei, LIU Meng, CHENG RuHong, XIA EnJun, DIAO XianMin. Current Status and Future Prospective of Foxtail Millet Production and Seed Industry in China [J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2021, 54(3): 459-470.

Metrics

Viewed

Full text

Abstract

Cited

Shared

Discussed

Comments

Recommended 0

No Suggested Reading articles found!

序号 No.	品种 Cultivar	选育单位 Breeding organization	米质特性 Character of millet quality
1	济谷19 Jigu19	山东省农业科学院作物研究所 Institute of Crop, Shandong Academy of Agricultural Sciences	一级优质米 First-grade quality millet
2	济谷20 Jigu20	山东省农业科学院作物研究所 Institute of Crop, Shandong Academy of Agricultural Sciences	一级优质米 First-grade quality millet
3	济谷21 Jigu21	山东省农业科学院作物研究所 Institute of Crop, Shandong Academy of Agricultural Sciences	一级优质米 First-grade quality millet
4	济糯谷2号 Jinuogu 2	山东省农业科学院作物研究所 Institute of Crop, Shandong Academy of Agricultural Sciences	糯质米 Waxy millet
5	中谷2号 Zhonggu 2	中国农业科学院作物科学研究所 Institute of Crop Sciences, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences	一级优质米 First-grade quality millet
6	济绿谷1号 Jilügu 1	山东省农业科学院作物研究所 Institute of Crop, Shandong Academy of Agricultural Sciences	米色黄绿 Yellow green millet
7	济谷22 Jigu 22	山东省农业科学院作物研究所 Institute of Crop, Shandong Academy of Agricultural Sciences	二级优质米 Second-grade quality millet
8	豫谷18 Yugu 18	安阳市农业科学院 Anyang Academy of Agricultural Sciences	一级优质米 First-grade quality millet

地点 Location	年份 Year	月份 Month	平均温度 Average temperature (℃)	降雨量 Rainfall (mm)	日照时数 Sunshine hour (h)	年份 Year	月份 Month	平均温度 Average temperature (℃)	降雨量 Rainfall (mm)	日照时数 Sunshine hour (h)
泰安 Taian	2016	6	25.1	167.8	213.8	2017	6	24.9	62.4	222.7
泰安 Taian		7	27.1	219.7	162.4		7	28.7	271.3	166.8
		8	26.2	228.9	186.5		8	26.7	81.7	180.9
		9	22.0	16.7	193.5		9	21.7	11.5	196.5
	均值/和Mean or Sum		25.1	633.1	756.2			25.5	426.9	766.9
济宁 Jining	2016	6	25.8	174.2	222.0	2017	6	26.5	110.9	224.2
济宁 Jining		7	28.4	289.2	157.0		7	29.1	351.8	206.6
		8	27.3	110.3	138.1		8	27.7	126.3	208.7
		9	23.5	66.4	221.2		9	23.0	40.0	185.0
	均值/和Mean or Sum		26.3	640.1	738.3			26.6	629.0	824.5
德州 Dezhou	2016	6	25.4	76.5	264.7	2017	6	26.1	77.4	261.4
德州 Dezhou		7	27.8	130.9	167.4		7	28.3	69.4	165.7
		8	26.7	190.8	174.1		8	26.7	215.6	197.4
		9	23.1	4.0	225.1		9	23.8	12.1	238.3
	均值/和Mean or Sum		25.8	402.2	831.3			26.2	374.5	862.8
临沂 Linyi	2016	6	24.5	178.9	193.9	2017	6	24.3	40.8	177.6
临沂 Linyi		7	26.0	47.5	153.9		7	28.5	385.1	159.3
		8	27.5	123.0	190.7		8	26.4	183.5	157.4
		9	23.2	106.8	165.0		9	22.3	53.6	177.8
	均值/和Mean or Sum		25.3	456.2	703.5			25.4	663.0	672.1
济南 Jinan	2016	6	26.0	160.3	234.0	2017	6	25.9	93.6	221.4
济南 Jinan		7	27.7	237.6	158.5		7	29.6	176.8	157.4
		8	26.2	421.1	154.0		8	26.8	155.1	183.6
		9	23.3	2.7	193.8		9	24.1	5.6	210.9
	均值/和Mean or Sum		25.8	821.7	740.3			26.6	431.1	773.3

试验地点 Location	2016 年			2017年
试验地点 Location	播种时间 Sowing date	收获时间 Harvest date	总天数 Total days (d)	播种时间 Sowing date	收获时间 Harvest date	总天数 Total days (d)
泰安Taian	6/18	9/30	104	6/19	9/29	102
济宁Jining	6/09	9/22	103	6/17	9/23	98
德州Dezhou	6/17	9/22	97	6/25	9/20	97
临沂Linyi	6/12	9/23	102	6/10	9/23	105
济南Jinan	6/18	9/22	96	6/18	9/21	95

变因 Factor	平方和 SS	自由度 df	均方 Mean square	F	P	贡献率 Contribution rate (%)
区组Block	2.39	20	0.12
年份Year	47.84	1	47.84	327.58	0.0001	1.80
地点Location	732.25	4	183.06	9.65	0.0248	27.57
品种Cultivar	1517.05	7	216.72	40.68	0.0001	57.12
地点×年份Location×Year	75.85	4	18.96	129.85	0.0001	2.86
品种×年份Cultivar×Year	37.29	7	5.33	36.48	0.0001	1.40
地点×品种Location×Cultivar	162.59	28	5.81	39.76	0.0401	6.12
地点×品种×年份Location×Cultivar×Year	82.93	28	2.96	20.28	0.0001	3.12
误差Error	20.44	140	0.15
总和Total	2678.63	239

试验地点 Location	黄色素含量 Yellow pigment content (mg·kg^-1)
试验地点 Location	2016	2017	地点均值Mean
泰安Taian	21.67c	21.94d	21.81b
济宁Jining	24.29a	24.67c	24.48a
德州Dezhou	23.80b	26.87a	25.34a
临沂Linyi	20.92d	20.84e	20.88b
济南Jinan	24.20a	25.02b	24.61a
年份平均Mean	22.98	23.87	23.42

Yellow Pigment Contents in Foxtail Millet (Setaria italica) Under Diverse Ecological Conditions

RichHTML

PDF