中国农业科学 ›› 2026, Vol. 59 ›› Issue (11): 2420-2433.doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2026.11.009

• 土壤肥料·节水灌溉·农业生态环境 • 上一篇    下一篇

不同类型粪肥替减氮肥对稻油轮作系统作物产量和养分吸收的影响

罗欣欣1(), 余秋华2, 张淑贞2, 张千1, 周志华3, 李小坤1, 陆志峰1, 丛日环1(), 鲁剑巍1   

  1. 1 华中农业大学资源与环境学院/华中农业大学微量元素研究中心, 武汉 430070
    2 湖北省耕地质量与肥料工作总站, 武汉 430070
    3 湖北省武穴市农业农村局, 湖北武穴 435400
  • 收稿日期:2025-07-17 接受日期:2025-09-15 出版日期:2026-06-01 发布日期:2026-06-03
  • 通信作者:
    丛日环,E-mail:
  • 联系方式: 罗欣欣,E-mail:luoxx@webmail.hzau.edu.cn。
  • 基金资助:
    国家重点研发计划(2022YFD1901600); 中央高校基本科研业务费(2662024PY017); 湖北省绿色种养循环农业试点项目

Effects of Replacing Nitrogen Fertilizer with Different Types of Manure on Crop Yield and Nutrient Uptake Under Rice-Oilseed Rape Rotation

LUO XinXin1(), YU QiuHua2, ZHANG ShuZhen2, ZHANG Qian1, ZHOU ZhiHua3, LI XiaoKun1, LU ZhiFeng1, CONG RiHuan1(), LU JianWei1   

  1. 1 College of Resources and Environment, Huazhong Agricultural University/Microelement Research Center, Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan 430070
    2 Hubei Provincial Cultivated Land Quality and Fertilizer Station, Wuhan 430070
    3 Agriculture and Rural Bureau of Wuxue City, Wuxue 435400, Hubei
  • Received:2025-07-17 Accepted:2025-09-15 Published:2026-06-01 Online:2026-06-03

摘要:

【目的】施用畜禽粪肥是消纳养殖废弃物、实现化肥减量和农业绿色可持续发展的有效措施。本研究通过两年田间定位试验,探究稻油轮作体系氮肥减量条件下,不同类型粪肥对作物产量和养分吸收的影响,以期为粪肥在稻油轮作系统中应用提供科学依据。【方法】田间试验于2022—2024年在湖北省武穴市大法寺镇开展。在秸秆还田的条件下,设置7个处理:常规施肥(Con)、Con基础上减施15%的氮肥(85%N)、Con基础上施用猪沼液肥替代15%化学氮肥(85%N+PS)、Con基础上施用鸡粪源固体粪肥替代15%化学氮肥(85%N+CM)、Con基础上减施30%的氮肥(70%N)、Con基础上施用猪沼液肥替代30%化学氮肥(70%N+PS)、Con基础上施用鸡粪源固体粪肥替代30%化学氮肥(70%N+CM),基于作物产量、产量构成因子和养分积累量,结合养分收获指数、养分表观平衡和粪肥贡献率进行综合分析。【结果】两年四季的试验结果表明,在氮肥减量的条件下施用不同类型粪肥可提高稻油轮作系统作物产量和养分吸收,与Con处理相比,85%N+CM和85%N+PS处理下油菜和水稻的产量、氮钾积累量和收获指数均无显著差异。然而,不同类型粪肥在促进作物养分吸收以及影响轮作周年养分平衡表现出显著差异,85%N+CM处理显著提高油菜和水稻磷积累量(增幅分别为22.1%—24.8%和16.6%—16.9%),但因鸡粪源固体粪肥带入大量磷,周年磷盈余量和盈亏率分别增加155.9%和60.3%。与之相反,85%N+PS处理在维持作物养分吸收的同时,周年氮磷盈余量分别减少23.5%和5.9%,对应的盈亏率分别降低17.9%和6.7%。与85%N+CM处理相比,85%N+PS处理对油菜和水稻产量的贡献率分别提高17.4%—27.0%和24.1%—35.5%,在高效替代化学氮肥的同时,也大幅缓解了土壤养分盈余压力:氮、磷和钾盈余量分别降低28.6%、63.2%和35.5%,盈亏率分别降低19.3%、41.8%和20.5%。当减氮比例达30%时(70%N+CM/PS),相较于85%N+CM/PS处理油菜和水稻分别减产7.2%—18.5%和6.9%—15.7%,地上部氮、磷、钾积累量同步显著降低,周年养分盈余量和盈亏率增加。【结论】与常规施肥相比,施用不同类型粪肥替代15%的化学氮肥不仅可保证稻油轮作系统作物产量,还可以有效促进作物对养分的吸收。其中,配施猪沼液肥(85%N+PS)在维持作物产量的同时,进一步提高了粪肥对作物产量的贡献率,并降低轮作周年养分的盈余。因此,推荐其作为稻油轮作系统的施肥方案。

关键词: 鸡粪源固体粪肥, 猪沼液肥, 水稻-油菜轮作, 产量, 养分吸收

Abstract:

【Objective】Livestock manure recycling in farmland is an effective measure to dispose of livestock waste, reduce chemical fertilizer usage, and achieve green sustainable development in agriculture. Based on a two-year field experiment, this study explored the impacts of applying different types of manure under reduced chemical fertilization on crop yield, nutrient uptake, and utilization efficiency in a rice-rapeseed rotation system, which aimed to provide scientific guidance for the rational application of manure in rice-oilseed rape rotation production systems.【Method】The field trial was conducted in Dafasi Town, Wuxue City, Hubei Province, from 2022 to 2024. Under the condition of straw return to the field, the trial was set up with seven treatments: conventional fertilization (Con), 15% nitrogen fertilizer reduction on the basis of Con (85%N), pig biogas slurry fertilizer application on the basis of Con replacing 15% chemical nitrogen fertilizer (85%N+PS), Con application on the basis of chicken manure-based solid fertilizer to replace 15% chemical nitrogen fertilizer (85%N+CM), 30% nitrogen fertilizer reduction on Con basis (70%N), pig biogas slurry fertilizer to replace 30% chemical nitrogen fertilizer on Con basis (70%N+PS), and chicken manure-based solid fertilizer to replace 30% chemical nitrogen fertilizer on Con basis (70%N+CM). Based on the crop yield, yield constituting factors, and nutrient accumulation in conjunction with the nutrient harvest index, nutrient apparent balance and fertilizer contribution rate were analyzed comprehensively. 【Result】The results of the two-season experiment showed that the application of different types of manure under the condition of nitrogen fertilizer reduction could improve the crop yield and nutrient uptake of the rice-oilseed rape rotation system. There was no significant difference in yield, nitrogen and potassium accumulation and harvest index of oilseed rape and rice under 85%N+CM and 85%N+PS treatments compared with Con treatment. However, different types of manure showed significant effects on enhancing crop nutrient uptake and regulating the annual nutrient balance across the rotation cycles, and the 85%N+CM treatment significantly increased the phosphorus accumulation in oilseed rape and rice (the increases were 22.1%-24.8% and 16.6%-16.9%, respectively), but the annual phosphorus surplus and profit and loss ratio increased by 155.9% and 60.3%, respectively, due to the large amount of phosphorus input brought by chicken manure-based solid fertilizer. In contrast, the 85%N+PS treatment reduced the annual nitrogen and phosphorus surplus by 23.5% and 5.9%, respectively, and the corresponding profit and loss ratios decreased by 17.9% and 6.7%, respectively, while maintaining crop nutrient uptake. Compared with 85%N+CM treatment, the FCR of 85%N+PS treatment in oilseed rape and rice increased by 17.4%-27.0% and 24.1%-35.5%, respectively, this not only achieved an efficient substitution of chemical N fertilizer but also substantially alleviated the pressure of soil nutrient surplus : the surplus of nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium was reduced by 28.6%, 63.2% and 35.5%, respectively, and the profit and loss ratio was reduced by 19.3%, 41.8% and 20.5%, respectively. When the nitrogen reduction ratio reached 30% (70%N+CM/PS), compared with the 85%N+CM/PS treatment, the yield of oilseed rape and rice decreased by 7.2%-18.5% and 6.9%-15.7%, respectively, and the accumulation of nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium in the shoots decreased significantly, the annual nutrient surplus and profit and loss ratio increased. 【Conclusion】In conclusion, compared with conventional fertilization, the application of different types of manure under the condition of a 15% reduction in nitrogen could not only ensure the crop yield of the rice-oilseed rape rotation system, but also effectively promote the absorption of nutrients by crops, among them, combined with pig biogas liquid fertilizer (85%N+PS) treatment to further improve nutrient uptake and FCR while maintaining yield, and reduce the annual nutrient surplus of rotation, and achieve the level of conventional fertilization. Therefore, it was recommended as the best manure return model for the rice-oilseed rape rotation system.

Key words: chicken manure-based solid fertilizer, pig biogas slurry fertilizer, rice-oilseed rape rotation, yield, nutrient uptake