Please wait a minute...
Journal of Integrative Agriculture  2022, Vol. 21 Issue (11): 3199-3215    DOI: 10.1016/j.jia.2022.08.096
Special Issue: 麦类耕作栽培合辑Triticeae Crops Physiology · Biochemistry · Cultivation · Tillage
Crop Science Advanced Online Publication | Current Issue | Archive | Adv Search |
Genotype×tillage interaction and the performance of winter bread wheat genotypes in temperate and cold dryland conditions

Ebrahim ROOHI1, Reza MOHAMMADI2, Abdoul Aziz NIANE3, Javad VAFABAKHSH4, Mozaffar ROUSTAEE5, Mohammad Reza JALAL KAMALI6, Shahriar SOHRABI7, Shahriar FATEHI7, Hossain TARIMORADI7

1 Horticulture and Crop Science Research Department, Kurdistan Agricultural and Natural Resources Research and Education Center, Agricultural Research, Education and Extension Organization (AREEO), Sanandaj 66169-36311, Iran

2 Dry Land Agricultural Research Institute (DARI), Sararood Campus, AREEO, Kermanshah 67441-61377, Iran

3 International Center for Agriculture Research in the Dry Area (ICARDA), Dubai 13979, United Arab Emirates

4 Seed and Plant Improvement Research Department, Khorasan Razavi Agricultural and Natural Resources Research and Education Center, AREEO, Mashhad 91859-86111, Iran

5 Cereal Research Department, DARI, AREEO, Maragheh 119, Iran

6 International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center (CIMMYT), Karaj 31585-4119, Iran

7 Kurdistan Jehade Agricultural Organization, Sanandaj 66169-35383, Iran

Download:  PDF in ScienceDirect  
Export:  BibTeX | EndNote (RIS)      

Growing concerns for food security and the alleviation of hunger necessitate knowledge-based crop management technologies for sustainable crop production.  In this study, 13 winter bread wheat genotypes (old, relatively old, modern, and breeding lines) were evaluated under three different tillage systems, i.e., conventional tillage (CT, full tillage with residue removed), reduced tillage (RT, chisel tillage with residue retained) and no-tillage (NT, no-tillage with residue retained on the soil surface) in farmer’s fields under rainfed conditions using strip-plot arrangements in a randomized complete block design with three replications in the west of Iran (Kamyaran and Hosseinabad locations) over two cropping seasons (2018–2019 and 2019–2020).  The main objectives were to investigate the effects of tillage systems and growing conditions on the agronomic characteristics, grain yield and stability performance of rainfed winter bread wheat genotypes.  Significant (P<0.01) genotype×tillage system interaction effects on grain yield and agronomic traits suggested that the genotypes responded differently to the different tillage systems.  The number of grains per spike and plant height were positively (P<0.0) associated with grain yield under the NT system, so they may be considered as targeted traits for future wheat breeding.  Using statistical models, the modern cultivars (“Sadra” and “Baran”) were identified as high yielding and showed yield stability across the different tillage systems.  As per each tillage system, genotype “Sadra” followed by “Zargana-6//Dari 1-7 Sabalan” exhibited higher adaption to CT; while cultivars “Jam” and “Azar2” showed better performance under the RT system; and cultivars “Varan” and “Baran” tended to have better performance expression in the NT condition.  The increased grain yields achieved in combination with lower costs and greater profits from conservation agriculture suggest that adapted cultivar and NT systems should be evaluated and promoted more widely to farmers in the west of Iran as an attractive package of crop management technologies.  In conclusion, variations in the performance of genotypes and the significant genotype×tillage system interaction effects on grain yield and some agronomic traits assessed in this study suggest that the development and selection of cultivars adapted to the NT system should be considered and included in the strategies and objectives of winter wheat breeding programs for the temperate and cold dryland conditions of Iran.

Keywords:  bread wheat        no-tillage        reduced tillage        grain yield        yield stability  
Received: 12 July 2021   Accepted: 10 November 2021
Fund: This work was supported by the IRAN-ICARDA Enhanced Food Security Project, Iran (24-53-15-064-971144).
About author:  Correspondence Ebrahim Roohi, E-mail:

Cite this article: 

Ebrahim ROOHI, Reza MOHAMMADI, Abdoul Aziz NIANE, Javad VAFABAKHSH, Mozaffar ROUSTAEE, Mohammad Reza JALAL KAMALI, Shahriar SOHRABI, Shahriar FATEHI, Hossain TARIMORADI. 2022. Genotype×tillage interaction and the performance of winter bread wheat genotypes in temperate and cold dryland conditions. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 21(11): 3199-3215.

Alvarado G, López M, Vargas M, Pacheco Á, Rodríguez F, Burgueño J, Crossa J. 2016. META-R (Multi Environment Trail Analysis with R for Windows). version 6.0, hdl:11529/10201. CIMMYT Research Data & Software Repository Network. Accessed 30 November, 2016.
Araya T, Cornelis W M, Nyssen J, Govaerts B, Getnet F, Bauer H. 2012. Medium-term effects of conservation agriculture based cropping systems for sustainable soil and water management and crop productivity in the Ethiopian highlands. Field Crops Research, 132, 53–62.
Barnabas B, Jager K, Fehér A. 2008. The effect of drought and heat stress on reproductive processes in cereals. Plant, Cell & Environment, 31, 11–38.
Bewick L, Young F, Alldredge J, Young D. 2008. Agronomics and economics of no-till facultative wheat in the Pacific Northwest, USA. Crop Protection, 27, 932–942.
Cann D J, Schillinger W F, Hunt J R, Porker K D, Harris F A J. 2020. Agroecological advantages of early-sown winter wheat in semi-arid environments: A comparative case study from southern Australia and Pacific Northwest United States. Frontiers in Plant Science, 11, 568.
Carena M J, Yang J, Caffarel J C, Mergoum M, Hallauer A R. 2009. Do different production environments justify separate maize breeding programs? Euphytica, 169, 141–150.
Carr P M, Horsley R D, Poland W W. 2003a. Tillage and seeding rate effects on wheat cultivars: I. Grain production. Crop Science, 43, 202–209. 
 Carr P M, Horsley R D, Poland W W. 2003b. Tillage and seeding rate effects on wheat cultivars: II. Yield components. Crop Science, 43, 210–218. 
Carranza-Gallego G, Guzmán G, Garcia-Ruiz R, González de Molina M, Aguilera E. 2018. Contribution of traditional wheat varieties to climate change mitigation under contrasting managements and rainfed Mediterranean conditions. Journal of Cleaner Production, 195, 111–121.
Cavalieri K M V, Silva A P, Tormena C A, Leão T P, Dexter A R, Hakansson I. 2009. Long-term effects of no-tillage on dynamic soil physical properties in a Rhodic Ferralsol in Paraná, Brazil. Soil and Tillage Research, 103, 158–164.
Ciha A J. 1982. Yield and yield components of four spring barley cultivars under three tillage systems. Agronomy Journal, 74, 597–600.
Chaghazardi H R, Jahansouz M R, Ahmadi A, Gorji M. 2016. Effects of tillage management on productivity of wheat and chickpea under cold, rainfed conditions in western Iran. Soil and Tillage Research, 162, 26–33.
Cox D J. 1991. Breeding for hard red winter wheat cultivars adapted to conventional-till and no-till systems in northern latitudes. Euphytica, 58, 57–63.
Cox D J, Shelton D R. 1992. Genotype-by-tillage interactions in hard red winter wheat quality evaluation. Agronomy Journal, 84, 627–630.
Devkota M, Devkota K P, Acharya S, McDonald A J. 2019. Increasing profitability, yields and yield stability through sustainable crop establishment practices in the rice–wheat systems of Nepal. Agricultural Systems, 173, 414–423. 
Fischer R A, Santiveri F, Vidal I R. 2002. Crop rotation, tillage and crop residue management for wheat and maize in the sub-humid tropical highlands. I. Wheat and legume performance. Field Crops Research, 79, 107–122. 
Fufa H, Baenziger P S, Beecher B S, Graybosch R A, Eskridge K M, Nelson L A. 2005. Genetic improvement trends in agronomic performances and end-use quality characteristics among hard red winter wheat cultivars in Nebraska. Euphytica, 144, 187–198.
Gathala M K, Laing A M, Tiwari T P, Timsina J, Islam S, Chowdhury A, Chattopadhyay C, Singh A K, Bhatt B P, Shrestha R, Barma N C D, Rana D S, Jackson T M, Gerard B. 2020. Enabling smallholder farmers to sustainably improve their food, energy and water nexus while achieving environmental and economic benefits. Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews, 120, 109645.
Gürsoy S, Sessiz A, Malhi S. 2010. Short-term effects of tillage and residue management following cotton on grain yield and quality of wheat. Field Crops Research, 119, 260–268.
Hemmat A, Eskandari I. 2004. Tillage system effects upon productivity of a dryland winter wheat–chickpea rotation in the northwest region of Iran. Soil and Tillage Research, 78, 69–81.
Hemmat A, Eskandari I. 2006. Dryland winter wheat response to conservation tillage in a continuous cropping system in northwestern Iran. Soil and Tillage Research, 86, 99–109.
Herrera J M, Verhulst N, Trethowan R M, Stamp P, Govaerts B. 2013. Insights into genotype×tillage interaction effects on the grain yield of wheat and maize. Crop Science, 53, 1845–1859.
Honsdorf N, Mulvaney M J, Singh R P, Ammar K, Burgueño J, Govaerts B, Verhulst N. 2018. Genotype by tillage interaction and performance progress for bread and durum wheat genotypes on irrigated raised beds. Field Crops Research, 216, 42–52.
Honsdorf N, Verhulst N, Crossa J, Vargas M, Govaerts B, Ammar K. 2019. Durum wheat selection under zero tillage increases early vigor and is neutral to yield. Field Crops Research, 248, 107675.
Hwu K K, Allan R E. 1992. Natural selection effects in wheat populations grown under contrasting tillage systems. Crop Science, 32, 605–611.
Jat M L, Chakraborty D, Ladha J K. 2020. Conservation agriculture for sustainable intensification in South Asia. Nature Sustainability, 3, 336–343.
Joshi A K, Chand R, Arun B, Singh R P, Ortiz R. 2007. Breeding crops for reduced-tillage management in the intensive, rice–wheat systems of South Asia. Euphytica, 153, 135–151. 
Juergens L A, Young D L, Schillinger W F, Hinman H R. 2004. Economics of alternative no-till spring crop rotations in Washington’s wheat–fallow region. Agronomy Journal, 96, 154–158.
Kharub A S, Chatrath R, Shoran J. 2008. Performance of wheat (Triticum aestivum) genotypes in alternate tillage environments. Indian Journal of Agricultural Science, 78, 884–886.
Khorami S S, Kazemeini S A, Afzalinia S, Gathala M K. 2018. Changes in soil properties and productivity under different tillage practices and wheat genotypes: A short-term study in Iran. Sustainability, 10, 3273.
Kumar V, Jat H S, Sharma P C, Balwinder S, Gathala M K, Malik R K. 2018. Can productivity and profitability be enhanced in intensively managed cereal systems while reducing the environmental footprint of production? Assessing sustainable intensification options in the breadbasket of India. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 252, 132–147. 
Kumudini S, Grabau L, Van Sanford D, Omielan J. 2008. Analysis of yield-formation processes under no-till and conventional tillage for soft red winter wheat in the south-central region. Agronomy Journal, 100, 1026–1032.
Liang Y L, Richards R A. 2012. Seedling vigor characteristics among Chinese and Australian wheats. Community Soil Science and Plant, 30, 159–165.
Maich R H, Di Rienzo J A. 2014. Genotype×tillage interaction in a recurrent selection program in wheat. Cereal Research Communications, 42, 525–533.
Mohammadi R, Sadeghzadeh B, Poursiahbidi M M, Ahmadi M M. 2021. Integrating univariate and multivariate statistical models to investigate genotype×environment interaction in durum wheat. Annals of Applied Biology, 178, 450–465. 
Monneveux P, Jing R, Misra S C. 2012. Phenotyping for drought adaptation in wheat using physiological traits. Frontiers in Physiology, 3, doi: 10.3389/fphys.2012.00429.
Nyagumbo I, Mkuhlani S, Pisa C, Kamalongo D, Dias D, Mekuria M. 2016. Maize yield effects of conservation agriculture based maize–legume cropping systems in contrasting agro-ecologies of Malawi and Mozambique. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems, 105, 275–290.
Page K L, Dang Y P, Dalal R C, Reeves S, Thomas G, Wang W, Thompson J P. 2019. Changes in soil water storage with no-tillage and crop residue retention on a Vertisol: Impact on productivity and profitability over a 50 year period. Soil and Tillage Research, 194, 104319. 
Piggin C, Haddad A, Khalil Y, Loss S, Pala M. 2015. Effects of tillage and time of sowing on bread wheat, chickpea, barley and lentil grown in rotation in rainfed systems in Syria. Field Crops Research, 173, 57–67.
Pittelkow C M, Linquist B A, Lundy M E, Liang X, van Groenigen K J, Lee J, van Gestel N, Six J, Venterea R T, van Kessel C. 2015. When does no-till yield more? A global meta-analysis. Field Crops Research, 183, 156–168.
Plaza-Bonilla D, Álvaro-Fuentes J, Hansen N C, Lampurlanés J, Cantero-Martínez C. 2014. Winter cereal root growth and aboveground–belowground biomass ratios as affected by site and tillage system in dryland Mediterranean conditions. Plant and Soil, 374, 925–939. 
Radford B J, Thornton C M. 2011. Effects of 27 years of reduced tillage practices on soil properties and crop performance in the semi-arid subtropics of Australia. International Journal of Energy, Environment, and Economics, 19, 565–588. 
Rana C, Sharma A, Sharma K C, Mittal P, Sinha B N, Sharma V K, Chandel A, Thakur H, Kaila V, Sharma P, Rana V. 2021. Stability analysis of garden pea (Pisum sativum L.) genotypes under North Western Himalayas using joint regression analysis and GGE biplots. Genetic Resources and Crop Evolution, 68, 999–1010.
Rebetzke G J, Richards R A, Fettell N A, Long M, Condon A G, Forrester R I, Botwright T L. 2007. Genotypic increases in coleoptile length improves stand establishment, vigour and grain yield of deep-sown wheat. Field Crops Research, 100, 10–23.
Rebetzke G J, Richards R A, Sirault X R R, Morrison A D. 2004. Genetic analysis of coleoptile length and diameter in wheat. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research, 55, 733–743.
Ruiz M, Zambrana E, Fite R, Sole A, Tenorio J L, Benavente E. 2019. Yield and quality performance of traditional and improved bread and durum wheat varieties under two conservation tillage systems. Sustainability, 11, 4522.
Santín-Montanyá M, Fernández-Getino A, Zambrana E, Tenorio J. 2017. Effects of tillage on winter wheat production in Mediterranean dryland fields. Arid Land Research and Management, 31, 269–282.
Schillinger W F, Kennedy A C, Young D L. 2007. Eight years of annual no-till cropping in Washington’s winter wheat–summer fallow region. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 120, 345–358. 
Soane B D, Ball B C, Arvidsson J, Basch G, Moreno F, Roger-Estrade J. 2012. No-till in northern, western and south-western Europe: A review of problems and opportunities for crop production and the environment. Soil and Tillage Research, 118, 66–87. 
Steward P R, Dougill A J, Thierfelder C, Pittelkow C M, Stringer L C, Kudzala M, Shackelford G E. 2018. The adaptive capacity of maize-based conservation agriculture systems to climate stress in tropical and subtropical environments: A meta-regression of yields. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 251, 194–202.
Subira J, Alvaro F, García del Moral L F, Royo C. 2015. Breeding effects on the cultivar× environment interaction of durum wheat yield. European Journal of Agronomy, 68, 78–88.
Taner A, Arisoy R Z, Kaya Y, Gultekin I, Partigoc F. 2015. The effects of various tillage systems on grain yield, quality parameters and energy indices in winter wheat production under the rainfed conditions. Fresenius Environmental Bulletin, 24, 1463–1473.
Thompson C R, Hoag B K, Red H, Wheat S. 1987. Variety performance under reduced tillage systems. North Dakota Farming Research, 44, 19–24.
Trethowan R M, Mahmood T, Ali Z, Oldach K, Garci A G. 2012. Breeding wheat cultivars better adapted to conservation agriculture. Field Crops Research, 132, 76–83.
Trethowan R M, Reynolds M, Sayre K, Ortiz-Monasterio I. 2005. Adapting wheat cultivars to resource conserving farming practices and human nutritional needs. Annals of Applied Biology, 146, 405–413. 
Wang X B, Cai D X, Hoogmoed W B, Oenema O, Perdok U D. 2007. Developments in conservation tillage in rainfed regions of North China. Soil and Tillage Research, 93, 239–250.
De Vita P, Di Paolo E, Fecondo G, Di Fonzo N, Pisante M. 2007. No-tillage and conventional tillage effects on durum wheat yield, grain quality and soil moisture content in southern Italy. Soil & Tillage Research, 92, 69–78.
Yan W. 2001. GGE biplot - A Windows application for graphical analysis of multi-environment trial data and other types of two-way data. Agronomy Journal, 93, 1111–1118.
Yan W, Kang M S, Ma B, Woods S, Cornelius P L. 2007. GGE biplot vs. AMMI analysis of genotype-by-environment data. Crop Science, 47, 643–653.
Yau S K, Sidahmed M, Haidar M. 2010. Conservation versus conventional tillage on performance of three different crops. Agronomy Journal, 102, 269–276.
Zhang H, Lal R, Zhao X, Xue J, Chen F. 2014. Opportunities and challenges of soil carbon sequestration by conservation agriculture in China. Advances in Agronomy, 124, doi: 10.1016/B978-0-12-800138-7.00001-2.

Executive Editor-in-Chief  LI Shao-kun
Managing Editor  WANG Ning
[1] ZHAO Xiao-dong, QIN Xiao-rui, LI Ting-liang, CAO Han-bing, XIE Ying-he. Effects of planting patterns plastic film mulching on soil temperature, moisture, functional bacteria and yield of winter wheat in the Loess Plateau of China[J]. >Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2023, 22(5): 1560-1573.
[2] ZHENG Chang, WANG Yue-chao, XU Wen-ba, YANG De-sheng, YANG Guo-dong, YANG Chen, HUANG Jian-liang, PENG Shao-bing. Border effects of the main and ratoon crops in rice ratooning system[J]. >Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2023, 22(1): 80-91.
[3] DENG Fei, HE Lian-hua, CHEN Duo, ZHANG Chi, TIAN Qing-lan, WU Zhen-yuan, LI Qiu-ping, ZENG Yu-ling, ZHONG Xiao-yuan, CHEN Hong, WANG Li, REN Wan-jun. Growth characteristics and grain yield of machine-transplanted medium indica hybrid rice with high daily yield[J]. >Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2022, 21(9): 2547-2558.
[4] LU Qi-qi, SONG Yuan-feng, PAN Ke-qing, LI Yun, TANG Ming-xin, ZHONG Guo-hua, LIU Jie. Improved crop protection and biodiversity of the agroecosystem by reduced tillage in rice paddy fields in southern China[J]. >Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2022, 21(8): 2345-2356.
[5] XU Chen-chen, ZHANG Ping, WANG Yuan-yuan, LUO Ning, TIAN Bei-jing, LIU Xi-wei, WANG Pu, HUANG Shou-bing. Grain yield and grain moisture associations with leaf, stem and root characteristics in maize[J]. >Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2022, 21(7): 1941-1951.
[6] HUANG Li-ying, Li Xiao-xiao, ZHANG Yun-bo, Shah FAHAD, WANG Fei. dep1 improves rice grain yield and nitrogen use efficiency simultaneously by enhancing nitrogen and dry matter translocation[J]. >Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2022, 21(11): 3185-3198.
[7] TU De-bao JIANG Yang, ZHANG Li-juan, CAI Ming-li, LI Cheng-fang, CAO Cou-gui. Effect of various combinations of temperature during different phenolgical stages on indica rice yield and quality in Yangtze River Basin in China[J]. >Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2022, 21(10): 2900-2909.
[8] TIAN Qing-lan, HE Lian-hua, LIAO Shuang, LI Wu, DENG Fei, ZHOU Wei, ZHONG Xiao-yuan, REN Wan-jun. Indica rice restorer lines with large sink potential exhibit improved nutrient transportation to the panicle, which enhances both yield and nitrogen-use efficiency[J]. >Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2021, 20(6): 1438-1456.
[9] WANG Yue-chao, LI Xiu-fen, Lee Tarpley, PENG Shao-bing, DOU Fu-gen. Effects of nitrogen management on the ratoon crop yield and head rice yield in South USA[J]. >Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2021, 20(6): 1457-1464.
[10] ZHAO Can, HUANG Heng, QIAN Zi-hui, JIANG Heng-xin, LIU Guang-ming, XU Ke, HU Ya-jie, DAI Qi-gen, HUO Zhong-yang. Effect of side deep placement of nitrogen on yield and nitrogen use efficiency of single season late japonica rice[J]. >Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2021, 20(6): 1487-1502.
[11] ZHAI Li-chao, Lü Li-hua, DONG Zhi-qiang, ZHANG Li-hua, ZHANG Jing-ting, JIA Xiu-ling, ZHANG Zheng-bin. The water-saving potential of using micro-sprinkling irrigation for winter wheat production on the North China Plain[J]. >Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2021, 20(6): 1687-1700.
[12] WANG Wen-xia, DU Jie, ZHOU Yan-zhi, ZENG Yong-jun, TAN Xue-ming, PAN Xiao-hua, SHI Qing-hua, WU Zi-ming, ZENG Yan-hua. Effects of different mechanical direct seeding methods on grain yield and lodging resistance of early indica rice in South China[J]. >Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2021, 20(5): 1204-1215.
[13] WANG Rui, WANG Ying, HU Ya-xian, DANG Ting-hui, GUO Sheng-li. Divergent responses of tiller and grain yield to fertilization and fallow precipitation: Insights from a 28-year long-term experiment in a semiarid winter wheat system[J]. >Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2021, 20(11): 3003-3011.
[14] LI Guang-hao, CHENG Qian, LI Long, LU Da-lei, LU Wei-ping. N, P and K use efficiency and maize yield responses to fertilization modes and densities[J]. >Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2021, 20(1): 78-86.
[15] LIU Kai-lou, HAN Tian-fu, HUANG Jing, ZHANG Shui-qing, GAO Hong-jun, ZHANG Lu, Asad SHAH, HUANG Shao-min, ZHU Ping, GAO Su-duan, MA Chang-bao, XUE Yan-dong, ZHANG Hui-min.
Change of soil productivity in three different soils after long-term field fertilization treatments
[J]. >Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2020, 19(3): 848-858.
No Suggested Reading articles found!