中国农业科学 ›› 2021, Vol. 54 ›› Issue (12): 2581-2594.doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2021.12.009

• 土壤肥料·节水灌溉·农业生态环境 • 上一篇    下一篇

不同磷肥品种在石灰性土壤中的磷形态差异

吉冰洁(),李文海,徐梦洋,牛金璨,张树兰,杨学云()   

  1. 西北农林科技大学资源环境学院,陕西杨凌 712100
  • 收稿日期:2020-08-11 接受日期:2020-09-10 出版日期:2021-06-16 发布日期:2021-06-24
  • 通讯作者: 杨学云
  • 作者简介:吉冰洁,E-mail:ji.bj@nwafu.edu.cn
  • 基金资助:
    国家重点研发计划(2017YFD0200205)

Varying Synthetic Phosphorus Varieties Lead to Different Fractions in Calcareous Soil

JI BingJie(),LI WenHai,XU MengYang,NIU JinCan,ZHANG ShuLan,YANG XueYun()   

  1. College of Natural Resources and Environment, Northwest A & F University, Yangling 712100, Shaanxi
  • Received:2020-08-11 Accepted:2020-09-10 Online:2021-06-16 Published:2021-06-24
  • Contact: XueYun YANG

摘要:

【目的】研究不同磷肥品种在塿土中磷形态转化及有效性差异,有助于选择合适的磷肥品种从而减少土壤磷素累积和提高磷素有效性,为该区磷肥-作物-土壤匹配提供理论依据。【方法】以塿土长期定位试验有效磷含量较低的耕层(0—20 cm)土壤为供试土壤,玉米(郑单958)为供试作物进行盆栽试验。试验共设8个处理:不施磷肥(Control);过磷酸钙(SSP);钙镁磷肥(CaMg P);磷酸一铵(MAP);磷酸二铵(DAP);聚磷酸铵(Poly P);磷酸脲(Urea P);过磷酸钙加硫酸铵(SSP+ASA)。用蒋柏藩-顾益初无机磷分级法测定土壤无机磷组分,并分析其与玉米植株吸磷量、土壤有效磷之间的关系。【结果】不同磷肥品种均可显著影响土壤有效磷含量,但随时间变化其动态特点有所不同。在玉米种植期间,施不同磷肥品种土壤有效磷平均含量大小为:DAP>Urea P≥Poly P>MAP>SSP+ASA>SSP>CaMg P>Control。不同磷肥品种均可显著提高玉米植株干物质量、吸磷量及肥料利用率,较Control处理分别提高了64.8%—221.3%、114.1%—593.0%、2.1%—11.0%,其中DAP和Poly P处理相似且增幅最大。土壤有效磷含量与玉米植株吸磷量和干物质量均呈极显著的正相关关系。不同施磷处理均可显著增加土壤Ca2-P、Ca8-P、Al-P和Fe-P含量,增幅分别为36.9%—610.0%、21.7%—85.5%、57.2%—83.0%和28.5%—77.8%,O-P和Ca10-P增加不明显。其中,MAP、DAP、Poly P和Urea P可显著提高石灰性土壤中Ca2-P和Ca8-P的含量;Al-P和Fe-P增加较大的是SSP+ASA和SSP处理;CaMg P处理显著提高了O-P和Ca10-P含量。Poly P处理土壤Ca2-P含量显著高于MAP和Urea P,仅次于DAP处理,但土壤Ca8-P含量显著低于DAP、MAP和Urea P。与SSP相比,SSP+ASA显著增加了Ca2-P和Al-P含量,分别增加了24.9%和11.9%,有效磷含量提高了11.4%。土壤无机磷组分中Ca2-P、Ca8-P和Al-P与土壤有效磷和植株吸磷量呈显著正相关关系。【结论】供试土壤条件下,磷酸二铵(DAP)的磷素固定较低、有效磷含量高,聚磷酸铵(Poly P)降低了土壤Ca2-P向Ca8-P的转化,可减少磷在石灰性土壤中的沉淀,磷素有效性与施磷酸二铵的相当,这两种肥料是适合该区施用的磷肥品种;在石灰性土壤中施用酸性肥料硫酸铵不仅可以提高土壤有效磷含量,而且减少了磷素的累积。

关键词: 磷肥品种, 塿土, 玉米, 无机磷组分, 土壤有效磷

Abstract:

【Objective】Synthetic phosphorus fertilizers may vary in their behavior when applied to soil because of their inherent differences in nature. In order that the phosphate fertilizers could well match the crops’ P requirement, the selection of appropriate types of P sources are of paramount importance in practice. To achieve this, it is necessary to make a thorough investigation on phosphorus distribution among different soil P fractions and their bioavailability when P applied to soil in various varieties of synthetic phosphate fertilizers. 【Method】We conducted a pot experiment on a calcareous tier soil with a lower Olsen P level, which was collected from a plot without P addition for 20 years. Eight treatments were established: (1) no phosphate fertilizer (Control); (2) superphosphate (SSP); (3) calcium magnesium phosphate (CaMg P); (4) mono-ammonium phosphate (MAP); (5) di-ammonium phosphate (DAP); (6) ammonium poly-phosphate (Poly P); (7) Urea phosphate (Urea P); (8) superphosphate plus ammonium sulfate (SSP+ASA). A maize variety ‘Zhengdan 958’ was used as a test crop. We analyzed the correlations between P uptake in above-ground biomass of maize, soil Olsen P and the content of soil P fractions, which were determined with a P fractionation method modified by Jiang & Gu. 【Result】Results showed that the contents of soil available P (Olsen P) and its dynamics varying with treatments. The average Olsen P contents followed an order of DAP>Urea P≥Poly P>MAP>SSP+ASA>SSP>CaMg P>Control based on their statistical significance during the experimental period of two months. Compared with the control treatment, all treatments receiving P significantly increased the above-ground biomass, phosphorus uptake and phosphorus use efficiency of maize by 64.8%-221.3%, 114.1%-593.0% and 2.1%-11.0%, respectively. The largest increase was observed in treatments receiving DAP and poly P. Both the phosphorus uptake and above-ground biomass of maize were positively and significantly correlated with soil Olsen P. Phosphorus fractions of Ca2-P, Ca8-P, Al-P and Fe-P were enhanced by 36.9%-610.0%, 21.7%-85.5%, 57.2%-83.0%, 28.5%-77.8% in all phosphorus application treatments except O-P and Ca10-P, which remained unchanged except in CaMg P treatment. Of which, the greatest increases in Ca2-P and Ca8-P were observed in treatments given MAP, DAP, poly P and Urea P; the largest increases in Al-P and Fe-P were found in SSP+ASA and SSP treatments; significant increases in O-P and Ca10-P were only obtained in CaMg P treatment. The Poly P treatment had the significantly greater Ca2-P than MAP and Urea P treatments, only lower that DAP treatment, but it contained a significantly lower Ca8-P relative to DAP, MAP and Urea P treatments. Compared with SSP, SSP+ASA significantly increased the contents of Ca2-P and Al-P by 24.9% and 11.9%, respectively, and the available phosphorus content increased by 11.4%. The inorganic P fractions of Ca2-P, Ca8-P and Al-P showed a significant and positive correlations with soil available phosphorus and phosphorus uptake by plants. 【Conclusion】Under the tested soil conditions, DAP had a lower phosphorus fixation and thus a greater available phosphorus pool. Poly P inhibited the transformation of Ca2-P to Ca8-P and therefore reduced the precipitation of phosphorus. The results suggested that Poly P is equivalent to DAP in bioavailability, and these two varieties of phosphate fertilizers could be used where there is an urgent need to improve and maintain soil Olsen P. The application of physiological acidic fertilizer ammonium sulfate combined with SSP in calcareous soil not only increased the content of available phosphorus, but also reduced the fixation of phosphorus.

Key words: variety of synthetic phosphate fertilizer, tier soil, maize, inorganic phosphorus fractions, soil available phosphorus