中国农业科学 ›› 2014, Vol. 47 ›› Issue (3): 514-527.doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2014.03.011

• 土壤肥料·节水灌溉·农业生态环境 • 上一篇    下一篇

江西省双季稻田多作复合种植系统的能值分析

 孙卫民1, 黄国勤1, 程建峰2, 刘彬彬1   

  1. 1、江西农业大学生态科学研究中心,南昌330045;
    2、江西农业大学环境生物学实验室,南昌330045
  • 收稿日期:2013-05-15 出版日期:2014-02-01 发布日期:2013-07-22
  • 通讯作者: 黄国勤,E-mail:hgqjxnc@sina.com
  • 作者简介:孙卫民,E-mail:swm6412@163.com
  • 基金资助:

    国家科技支撑计划项目(2007BAD89B18)

Analyses on the Emergies of Multiple Compound Cropping Systems from Double-Cropping Paddy Fields in Jiangxi Province

 SUN  Wei-Min-1, HUANG  Guo-Qin-1, CHENG  Jian-Feng-2, LIU  Bin-Bin-1   

  1. 1、Research Centre of Ecological Sciences, Jiangxi Agricultural University, Nanchang 330045;
    2、Laboratory of Environmental Biology, Jiangxi Agricultural University, Nanchang 330045
  • Received:2013-05-15 Online:2014-02-01 Published:2013-07-22

摘要: 【目的】粮食问题一直都是国际社会关注的热点问题,探寻高效的种植模式,提高土地利用率和粮食产量是目前最为迫切的研究内容。从国内外相关领域的研究成果来看,实行多熟种植模式是充分利用自然资源和提高产量的重要途径,世界各国的农业都在朝着多熟种植的方向发展。1987年,美国著名生态学家H.T. Odum提出能值分析理论来探讨陆地复杂生态系统的功能原理和模拟技术,并将其扩展到人类所参与的生态、环境乃至社会经济系统。20世纪80年代以来,应用能量投入产出来衡量不同熟制或不同复种方式优劣已为国内外农业工作者重视并广泛应用,有助于调整生态环境与经济发展的关系,对自然资源的科学评估与合理利用具有重要的实践价值。论文将阐明双季稻田冬季复种模式系统中的资源利用和投入与产出效益,为南方双季稻田冬季复种模式的耕作制度改革、农田系统的可持续发展提供理论基础,为全面推进区域现代农业发展和农业现代化建设提供科技支撑,为国家和地区粮食增产、农民增收与农村繁荣提供参考依据。【方法】以大田定位试验的原始数据和相关统计年鉴资料为基础,采用能值分析理论和方法,对江西省余江县双季稻田7种复种模式系统中的经济产量折能、光合生产力、光能利用率、投入产出、运行效率和环境负荷等进行综合分析。【结果】冬季复种模式下的作物经济产量折能为217.5×106-229.7×106 kJ•hm-2,均大于冬季休闲模式(T1)的213.5×106 kJ•hm-2,其中T4、T6和T7显著高于其他处理,以T6的增幅最大(8.5%)。T6处理在2008—2010年间均表现出最高的能量增幅,具有很好的优势和稳定性。冬季复种模式的光合生产力(11.99—14.03 g•m-2•d-1)和光能利用率(1.46%—1.70%)极显著高于T1(10.55 g•m-2•d-1和1.28%),平均增幅为14.4%—34.8%,以T3为最高(34.8%)。光合生产力和光能利用率的变化趋势高度一致。冬季复种轮作模式下的经济产量折能为220.9×106—229.7×106 kJ•hm-2,均高于冬季复种连作(T2)的217.5×106 kJ•hm-2,以T6的增幅最大(6.1%)。除T3有所增加外,冬季复种轮作模式的光合生产力(11.99—13.10 g•m-2•d-1)都低于T2(13.67 g•m-2•d-1),平均降幅为4.2%—12.4%,以T4下降最多。T3(1.70%)和T6(1.67%)的光能利用率显著高于其他处理(1.46%—1.58%),且其他处理均低于T1,以T4和T5降幅最大。能值分析显示,不同处理的能值投入产出存在明显差异;表土净损失能最少为T1(2.98×1016sej),最多是T5(3.83×1016sej);工业辅助能最少投入为T1 (1.62×1017sej),最多是T4(2.98×1017sej,近T1的2倍);有机能投入最少为T1(6.55×1015sej),最多是T7(1.19×1016sej,近T1的2倍);T1的产出能最低(1.39×1016sej),T6的产出能最高(5.42×1016sej,近T1的4倍)。除T3(2.81)略低外,冬季复种模式的能值投入率(3.12—4.57)均大于T1(2.84),T4和T5增幅分别达61.1%和50.4%;但冬季复种模式下的能值产出率只有T4(0.13)高于T1(0.08),其他处理(0.06—0.07)均低于T1。冬季复种模式的环境资源能值占总投入能值的比例为0.17—0.26,一定程度上说明稻田冬季复种模式更有利于保护农田环境资源。冬季复种模式的不可更新环境资源能值/总投入的能值的比值在本研究中为0.10—0.15,意味着稻田农产品的产出很大程度上依赖于不可更新环境资源的消耗,将增大稻田水土流失的风险。所有处理的工业辅助能值/总投入能值的比值均超过了0.8,但处理间差异不明显,即工业投入所占比重较大,不利于稻田系统的可持续发展。【结论】双季稻田冬季作物的种植有利于提高稻田的光合生产力和光能利用率。除双季稻田冬季种植混播绿肥轮作模式外的稻田冬季种植经济作物的轮作模式的光合生产力和光能利用率均低于双季稻田冬季复种连作模式。双季稻田冬季种植蚕豆和豌豆的种植模式比稻田冬季休闲模式具有优势,但双季稻田冬季种植油菜是一个高投入高产出的种植模式,利于可持续发展。因此,在试验区双季稻田冬季种植油菜为最佳复种模式。

关键词: 双季稻田 , 复种 , 轮作 , 能值 , 江西省

Abstract: 【Objective】 Grain problem is always a hot issue concerned by the world. Seeking efficient cropping patterns, improving land utilization efficiency and enhancing grain production are the most urgent researches at present. From the results of related researches fields at home and abroad, multiple cropping patterns are the important approaches of utilizing natural resources and increasing crop production, so agriculture all over the world is developing toward the direction of multiple cropping patterns. In 1987, H T Odum, the famous ecologist in American, proposed the theory of emery analysis to explore the function principles and simulation technology of the complicated terrestrial ecosystems, and extended it to the ecological, environmental, social and economic systems involved in human. Since 1980’s, applying energy inputs and outputs to measure the good or bad of different ripe cycles and cropping patterns were focused and applied widely, which were beneficial for regulating the relationship between ecological environments and economic developments and had important practical values of scientific estimation and reasonable utilizations of natural resources. In the experiment, the resource utilizations, input and output benefits of multiple compound cropping systems from double-cropping paddy fields were clarified, which provided a theoretical foundation for the farming system reforms of winter compound cropping patterns in double-cropping paddy fields of south China and sustainable development of farmland ecosystems, the scientific and technological supports of moving forward roundly regional modern agriculture development and agricultural modernization constructions, reference frames of increasing grain production, farmers income and rural prosperity in the nation and regions. 【Method】 Energies of crop economic yields, photosynthetic productivities, solar energy utilization efficiencies, inputs, outputs, operating efficiencies and environmental loads of seven multiple cropping systems in Yujiang country of Jiangxi province were analyzed comprehensively with the theories and methods of emery analyses on the basis of data from field location experiments and related statistic yearbooks. 【Result】 The results showed that the energies of crops economic yields in winter multiple cropping were 217.57×106-229.7×106 kJ•hm-2 and higher than 213.5×106 kJ•hm-2 in winter fallow (T1); and energies of crops economic yields in the T4, T6 and T7 were significantly higher than those in the other treatments, the increasing percent of energy in T6 was 8.5% and the highest. Energy increasing percent of T6 was the highest in 2008-2010, which indicated that T6 had a better superiority and stability. Photosynthetic productivities (11.99-14.03 g•m-2•d-1) and solar energy utilization efficiencies (1.46%-1.70%) in winter multiple cropping were markedly significantly higher than those (10.55 g•m-2•d-1 and 1.28%, respectively) in T1, the average increasing ranges were 14.4%-34.8% with the highest increasing percent (34.8%) of T3, and the changes of photosynthetic productivities and solar energy utilization efficiencies were exactly alike. Energies of crops economic yields in winter multiple cropping rotations were 220.9×106-229.7×106 kJ•hm-2 and higher than 217.5×106 kJ•hm-2 in winter multiple continuous cropping (T2), and the increasing percent of energy in T6 was 6.1% and was the highest, but no significant difference was found among all treatments. Winter multiple cropping rotations reduced crop photosynthetic productivity to a certain extent, photosynthetic productivities (11.99-13.10 g•m-2•d-1) in winter multiple crop rotations were lower than 13.67 g•m-2•d-1 in T2 except the higher in T3, the average decreasing ranges were 4.2%-12.4% with the highest reduction of T4. The solar energy utilization efficiencies in T3 (1.70%) and T6 (1.67%) were significantly higher than those in the other treatments (1.46%-1.58%) which decreased with the highest reduction of T4 and T5 in comparison with T1. Emergy analyses indicated that the emergy inputs and outputs of all treatments existed obvious differences; the least of net loss of topsoil was 2.98×1016 sej in T1, the most was 3.83×1016 sej in T5; the least of industrial supplement emergy was 1.62×1017 sej in T1, the most was 2.98×1017 sej in T4 and nearly two times in T1; the least of organic emergy was 6.55×1015 sej in T1, the most was 1.19×1016 sej in T7 and nearly two times in T1; the least of output emergy was 1.39×1016 sej in T1, the most was 5.42×1016 sej in T6 and nearly four times in T1. Emergy input ratios (3.12-4.57) in winter multiple cropping were higher than 2.84 in T1 except the lower of 2.81 in T3, the increasing percents in T4 and T5 were 61.1% and 50.4%, respectively; but only emergy input ratio (0.13) in T4 was higher than 0.08 in T1, those (0.06-0.07) in the other treatments were lower. Emergy ratios of environmental resources to total inputs in the most treatments were 0.17-0.26 with the maximum reduction of T4 and lower than that in winter fallow, which showed that winter compound cropping patterns were favorable to protecting farmland environmental resources. Emergy ratio of unrenewalbe to total environmental resources in all winter compound cropping patterns were 0.10-0.15 and higher than that in T1, which suggested that planting winter crops mostly depended on the unrenewalbe environmental resources and could increase soil loss. Emergy ratio of industrial supplement to total inputs in all treatments exceeded 0.8, but had no obvious differences, which indicated that the productions of all cropping patterns depended on the industrial inputs and counted against agricultural sustainable development. 【Conclusion】In conclusion, planting winter crops in double-cropping paddy fields were better for increasing photosynthetic productivities and solar energy utilization efficiencies of paddy fields. Photosynthetic productivities and solar energy utilization efficiencies of planting economic crops except mixed green manure in winter multiple cropping rotations were lower than those in winter multiple continuous cropping. Planting broad bean and pea in double-cropping paddy fields in winter were more superior to fallow-double cropping rice system; but planting rape in double cropping rice system in winter was one of the high input and output patterns for sustainable developments; thus, planting rape in double cropping rice system in winter was the optimum multiple cropping.

Key words: double-cropping paddy field , multiple cropping , crop rotation , emergy , Jiangxi province