中国农业科学 ›› 2014, Vol. 47 ›› Issue (11): 2135-2141.doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2014.11.007

• 耕作栽培·生理生化·农业信息技术 • 上一篇    下一篇

基于边界域修正粗糙熵模型的遥感影像分类不确定性评价

 竞霞1, 2, 魏曼3, 王纪华1, 宋晓宇1, 胡荣明2   

  1. 1、国家农业信息化工程技术研究中心,北京 100097;
    2、西安科技大学测绘学院,西安 710054;
    3、国家测绘地理信息局第四航测遥感院,海口 570203
  • 收稿日期:2013-11-24 出版日期:2014-06-06 发布日期:2014-04-03
  • 通讯作者: 宋晓宇,Tel:010-51503647;E-mail:songxy@nercita.org.cn
  • 作者简介:竞霞,Tel:029-85583176;E-mail:jingxia1001@163.com
  • 基金资助:

    国家农业信息化工程技术研究中心开放基金项目(KFKT001)、国家自然科学基金项目(41201326)、西安科技大学博士启动基金项目(2012QDJ022)

Uncertainty Research of Remote Sensing Image Classification Using the Boundary Region-Based Modified Rough Entropy Model

 JING  Xia-1, 2 , WEI  Man-3, WANG  Ji-Hua-1, SONG  Xiao-Yu-1, HU  Rong-Ming-2   

  1. 1、National Engineering Research Center for Information Technology in Agriculture, Beijing 100097;
    2、College of Geomantic, Xi’an University of Science and Technology, Xi’an 710054;
    3、The Forth Institute of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, National Administration of Surveying, Mapping and Geoinformation, Haikou 570203
  • Received:2013-11-24 Online:2014-06-06 Published:2014-04-03

摘要: 【目的】遥感影像分类是获取地表覆盖信息的有效技术手段,客观合理地评价遥感影像分类的不确定性对农业资源调查、作物估产等方面的遥感应用具有重要的意义。论文针对修正粗糙熵模型在评价遥感影像分类不确定性时存在的问题,构建基于边界域修正粗糙熵模型的遥感影像分类不确定性评价指标,以期更好地度量地物类别尺度上的遥感影像分类的不确定性。【方法】考虑边界域对遥感影像分类结果不确定性的影响,对修正粗糙熵模型进行改进,以类别的边界域被分类知识划分的结果取代所有像元被分类知识划分的结果作为衡量分类知识不确定性的依据,建立基于边界域的修正粗糙熵模型。首先依据粗集理论对所建模型的合理性进行数学推导,然后以北京市的Landsat TM影像和新疆石河子地区的IKONOS影像为例,分别应用修正粗糙熵模型和基于边界域的修正粗糙熵模型对分类结果在地物类别尺度上的不确定性进行评价,用不同空间分辨率和不同研究区域的试验数据的不确定性评价结果印证理论推导结论。【结果】与修正粗糙熵模型相比,基于边界域的修正粗糙熵模型在评价遥感影像分类的不确定性时能够更好地刻画分类知识所引起的不确定性,使遥感影像分类结果的评价更加客观和合理。通过对两种模型下试验数据的分析表明,当所研究的地表覆盖类型在研究区域内的分布比较零碎,成片区域不多,类别与类别之间的边界部分所占比重较大,混合像元现象比较严重的时候,采用修正粗糙熵模型计算遥感影像分类结果的不合理性还不是非常明显,还能够比较客观地反映遥感影像分类的不确定性问题。但是如果评价分布比较集中,面积比较大的地物类型的分类精度时,修正粗糙熵模型则难以客观地反映遥感影像分类的不确定性问题,其评价结果的不合理性也更为明显。【结论】采用修正粗糙熵模型进行遥感影像分类的不确定性评价时,放大了由于边界域存在所产生的不确定性,而基于边界域的修正粗糙熵模型则可以较好地避免这一情况的发生,更合理地度量地物类别尺度上的遥感影像分类的不确定性。

关键词: 遥感图像 , 分类 , 不确定性 , 修正粗糙熵 , 边界域

Abstract: 【Objective】It is an effective technical method to obtain land cover information by remote sensing classification. Objective and reasonable evaluation of the uncertainty in remote sensing classification maps is significant to agricultural resources survey, crop yield assessment and other remote sensing applications. This study focuses on the problem of uncertainty evaluation for remote sensing image classification at the land cover scale. A new uncertainty evaluation criteria, boundary region-based modified rough entropy model (BMREM) is proposed based on the improvement of modified rough entropy model (MREM). 【Method】 The traditional MREM model measures the overall average uncertainty of the same class feature. But the classification uncertainty is mainly caused by the boundary between different feature classes in RS image. So, in this study, all pixels value range for class feature is replaced by the boundary range of one feature class in image. The rationality of the BMREM model is proved based on rough set theory. And then the BMREM model was established under the impact of boundary region on the uncertainty assessment in remote sensing image classification. Afterwards, the MREM model and the BMREM model are applied to evaluate the uncertainty of remote sensing classification results for one Landsat TM image and one IKONOS image, respectively. The theoretical conclusion was confirmed by uncertainty evaluation result using experimental data of different spatial resolution and different research areas.【Result】 Compared with the MREM model,the uncertainty caused by the classification knowledge can be better described using the BMREM model. So the uncertainty of remote sensing image classification is more reasonable and objective. The empirical results reveal that the irrationality of uncertainty assessment is not obvious using MREM model. It also can objectively measure the uncertainty problem of remote sensing image classification if the mixed pixel is more serious. But it is difficult to objectively evaluate the uncertainty of remote sensing image classification by MREM model if the ground objects distribution is more concentrated in study area and the area is relatively large.【Conclusion】This study proved that MREM model magnified the value of uncertainty caused by existence of boundary region from the theory analysis and model application. Yet the uncertainty generated by classification knowledge can be better depicted using the BMREM model. So the BMREM model measured the classification uncertainty at the scale of land cover classes more reasonably and accurately.

Key words: remote sensing image , classification , uncertainty , modified rough entropy , boundary region