中国农业科学 ›› 2025, Vol. 58 ›› Issue (16): 3280-3292.doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2025.16.011

• 专题:稻油轮作周年养分管理 • 上一篇    下一篇

秸秆直接还田与炭化还田对稻油轮作作物产量和氮素利用的影响

王安心1(), 方娅婷1, 顿谦2, 伍永清3, 廖世鹏1, 李小坤1, 任涛1, 陆志峰1, 丛日环1,*(), 鲁剑巍1   

  1. 1 华中农业大学资源与环境学院/农业农村部长江中下游耕地保育重点实验室/华中农业大学微量元素研究中心,武汉 430070
    2 湖北省荆门市土壤肥料工作站,湖北荆门 448000
    3 湖北省荆门市沙洋县土壤肥料工作站,湖北荆门 448000
  • 收稿日期:2025-04-14 接受日期:2025-06-09 出版日期:2025-08-11 发布日期:2025-08-11
  • 通信作者:
    丛日环,E-mail:
  • 联系方式: 王安心,E-mail:wanganxin@webmail.hzau.edu.cn。
  • 基金资助:
    国家重点研发计划(2023YFD1901100); 国家油菜产业技术体系(CARS-12); 湖北省现代农业产业技术体系水稻产业技术体系(2023HBSTX4-01); 中央高校基本科研业务费(2662024PY017)

Effects of Direct and Biochar-Based Straw Incorporation on Crop Yield and Nitrogen Uptake and Utilization in a Rice-Rapeseed Rotation System

WANG AnXin1(), FANG YaTing1, DUN Qian2, WU YongQing3, LIAO ShiPeng1, LI XiaoKun1, REN Tao1, LU ZhiFeng1, CONG RiHuan1,*(), LU JianWei1   

  1. 1 College of Resources and Environment, Huazhong Agricultural University/Key Laboratory of Arable Land Conservation (Middle and Lower Reaches of Yangtze River), Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs/Microelement Research Center, Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan 430070
    2 Jingmen City Soil and Fertilizer Station, Jingmen 448000, Hubei
    3 Shayang County Soil and Fertilizer Station, Jingmen 448000, Hubei
  • Received:2025-04-14 Accepted:2025-06-09 Published:2025-08-11 Online:2025-08-11

摘要:

【目的】探讨稻油轮作系统中秸秆的肥料化利用方式,为轮作系统产能提升与资源高效利用提供理论支撑。【方法】基于2017—2023年开展的连续6年的稻油轮作田间定位试验,选取秸秆不还田(NPK)、两季秸秆直接还田(NPK+S/S)、两季秸秆炭化还田(NPK+B/B)和水稻季秸秆炭化还田/油菜季秸秆直接还田(NPK+B/S)4个处理,分析作物产量及其稳定性与可持续性、作物氮素吸收利用、土壤氮素表观平衡和土壤全氮含量。【结果】秸秆直接还田与炭化还田显著提高了作物产量和产量稳定性。与NPK处理相比,NPK+S/S、NPK+B/B和NPK+B/S处理的油菜产量分别平均提高了13.9%、14.8%和17.3%,水稻产量分别提高8.5%、7.2%和3.7%,周年能值产量分别提高10.5%、9.9%和8.5%。相较于NPK处理,NPK+S/S、NPK+B/B和NPK+B/S处理均提高了油菜产量可持续性指数(8.1%—10.2%)。与NPK+S/S处理相比,NPK+B/B和NPK+B/S处理更有利于提高水稻产量的稳定性(24.2%和1.4%)与可持续性指数(5.3%和2.3%)。秸秆直接还田与炭化还田增加了作物氮素吸收量,但降低了氮素收获指数。与NPK处理相比,NPK+S/S、NPK+B/B和NPK+B/S处理均能提高油菜(7.4%—20.7%)、水稻(3.3%—15.0%)和轮作周年(6.5%—17.6%)氮素吸收量;与NPK处理相比,NPK+S/S、NPK+B/B和NPK+B/S处理油菜和水稻的氮收获指数分别降低了0.2%—3.0%和1.9%—3.8%。相较于NPK+S/S处理,NPK+B/B处理显著降低了油菜地上部氮素吸收量,降幅11.0%,对于油菜籽粒、水稻籽粒和水稻地上部氮素吸收量的影响不显著;相较于NPK+S/S处理,NPK+B/B处理能增加油菜和水稻的氮收获指数,提升幅度分别为1.8%和1.9%。秸秆直接还田在促进作物氮素吸收具有优势,而秸秆炭化还田在改善作物氮素分配具有优势。与NPK处理相比,NPK+S/S、NPK+B/B和NPK+B/S处理均能提高油菜(13.9%—17.2%)和水稻(2.2%—7.7%)的氮肥偏生产力。所有处理氮素表观平衡均呈现为盈余,其中NPK+B/S处理氮素盈余量最高。与NPK处理相比,NPK+S/S、NPK+B/B和NPK+B/S处理均能提高土壤全氮含量(20.6%—22.7%),秸秆炭化还田土壤全氮含量最高,秸秆炭化还田更能将盈余的氮转化为土壤氮,减少氮素损失。【结论】在稻油轮作系统中,综合考虑,相较于两季秸秆直接还田或两季秸秆炭化还田,水稻季秸秆炭化还田结合油菜季秸秆直接还田能在保证水稻和油菜高产稳产的同时,提高氮肥利用率,增加土壤全氮含量,有利于稻油轮作系统的可持续发展。

关键词: 稻油轮作, 秸秆还田, 生物炭, 产量稳定性, 周年能值产量, 氮素吸收量, 氮收获指数

Abstract:

【Objective】Rice-rapeseed rotation is a major cropping system in the Yangtze River basin of China. Straw utilization is a crucial issue concerning agricultural sustainable development and environmental protection. This study aimed to explore the fertilizer-based utilization methods of straw in rice-rapeseed rotation systems, so as to provide the theoretical support for enhancing productivity and achieving efficient resource utilization in such systems.【Method】This study utilized a six-year (2017-2023) field experiment under rice-rapeseed rotation. Four treatments were chosen: no straw incorporation (NPK), direct incorporation of straw in both seasons (NPK+S/S), straw biochar incorporation in both seasons (NPK+B/B), and straw biochar incorporation in the rice season combined with direct straw incorporation in the rapeseed season (NPK+B/S). Crop yield and its stability, plant N absorption and utilization efficiency as well as the apparent N balance in soil were systematically analyzed.【Result】Direct and straw biochar incorporation significantly increased crop yields and yield stability. Compared with NPK, the rapeseed yields under NPK+S/S, NPK+B/B, and NPK+B/S increased by 13.9%, 14.8%, and 17.3% on average, respectively; rice yields increased by 8.5%, 7.2%, and 3.7%, respectively; annual energy yields improved by 10.5%, 9.9%, and 8.5%, respectively. Compared with NPK, the rapeseed yield sustainability index under NPK+S/S, NPK+B/B, and NPK+B/S was enhanced by 8.1% to 10.2%. Compared with NPK+S/S, NPK+B/B and NPK+B/S were more beneficial for enhancing rice yield stability (24.2% and 1.4%, respectively) and sustainability index (5.3% and 2.3%, respectively). Both straw management practices increased crop N uptake but decreased the N harvest index. Compared with NPK, aboveground N uptake in rapeseed increased by 7.4% to 20.7%, in rice by 3.3% to 15.0%, and in the annual rotation by 6.5% to 17.6% under NPK+S/S, NPK+B/B, and NPK+B/S treatments. However, the N harvest index in rapeseed and rice decreased by 0.2%-3.0% and 1.9%-3.8%, respectively. Compared with NPK+S/S treatment, NPK+B/B treatment significantly reduced N uptake in the above-ground part of rapeseed by 11.0%. The reduction in N uptake in rapeseed grains, rice grains, and the above-ground part of rice was not significant, while the N harvest index of rapeseed and rice was increased by 1.8% and 1.9%, respectively. Direct straw incorporation had an advantage in promoting crop N uptake, while straw biochar incorporation had an advantage in improving crop N distribution. Compared with NPK, NPK+S/S, NPK+B/B, and NPK+B/S significantly increased the partial factor productivity of applied N in rapeseed (13.9% to 17.2%) and rice (2.2% to 7.7%). All treatments showed N surplus, with the NPK+B/S treatment having the highest N surplus. Compared with the NPK treatment, the NPK+S/S, NPK+B/B and NPK+B/S treatments all increased the soil total N content (20.6%-22.7%). Soil total N content was the highest under straw biochar incorporation, which was more effective in converting surplus N into soil N and reducing N loss.【Conclusion】In rice-rapeseed rotation system, considering economic effects, compared with direct straw incorporation or straw biochar incorporation in both seasons, the strategy of applying straw biochar during the rice season and directly incorporating straw during the rapeseed season could not only ensure stable high crop yields but also enhance N fertilizer utilization and increase soil total N content, providing important support for the sustainable development of rice-rapeseed rotation systems.

Key words: rice-rapeseed rotation, straw incorporation, biochar, yield stability, annual energy yield, nitrogen absorption, nitrogen harvest index