中国农业科学 ›› 2020, Vol. 53 ›› Issue (18): 3752-3763.doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2020.18.011

• 土壤肥料·节水灌溉·农业生态环境 • 上一篇    下一篇

海南岛1988—2018年畜禽粪尿氮磷负荷量及环境效应

丁尚1(),付阳2,郭浩浩1,宋晨阳1,李博玲3,赵洪伟1()   

  1. 1海南大学生态与环境学院/海南省农林环境过程与生态调控重点实验室/海南省热带生态环境修复工程研究中心,海口570228
    2海南大学动物科技学院,海口570228
    3海南省畜牧技术推广站,海口570100
  • 收稿日期:2019-12-13 接受日期:2019-12-30 出版日期:2020-09-16 发布日期:2020-09-25
  • 通讯作者: 赵洪伟
  • 作者简介:丁尚,E-mail: Dshainu@163.com
  • 基金资助:
    海南省重大科技项目(ZDKJ2017002)

Nitrogen and Phosphorus Loads and Their Environmental Effects of Animal Manure in Hainan Island from 1988 to 2018

DING Shang1(),FU Yang2,GUO HaoHao1,SONG ChenYang1,LI BoLing3,ZHAO HongWei1()   

  1. 1College of Ecology and Environment, Hainan University/Key Laboratory of A&F Environmental Processes and Ecological Regulation of Hainan Province/Center for Eco-Environmental Restoration Engineering of Hainan Province, Haikou 570228
    2College of Animal Science and Technology, Hainan University, Haikou 570228
    3Animal Husbandry Technology Station of Hainan Province, Haikou 570100
  • Received:2019-12-13 Accepted:2019-12-30 Online:2020-09-16 Published:2020-09-25
  • Contact: HongWei ZHAO

摘要:

【目的】揭示海南畜禽养殖业发展过程中粪尿氮磷养分流动情况及其对环境的影响,为区域农业发展规划和畜禽养殖结构调整提供参考。【方法】基于统计资料和文献数据,定量估算1988—2018年海南岛畜禽粪尿养分产生量、单位耕地面积养分承载量,并利用畜禽粪尿耕地负荷预警值和环境风险指数深入分析其对环境的影响,当畜禽粪尿耕地负荷预警值<0.4时,可认为对环境无威胁,而当环境风险指数在1.00以下时,对环境的风险可忽略,在安全数值以上即会对环境产生不同程度的影响。【结果】1988—2018年间,海南岛畜禽粪尿产生量变化经历了3个阶段,1988—2005年整体上升,2006—2008年下降较多,此后缓慢发展并趋于稳定,到2018年畜禽粪尿产生量为10.50×106t,就养分产生量来看,粪尿氮磷年际间变化趋势相似,2005年产生量最多,2006年出现较大幅度下降,到2018年粪尿氮产生量为7.41×104 t,粪尿磷产生量为1.01×104t。单位耕地面积氮磷负荷量也经历了先增加后稳定的过程,到2018年耕地氮负荷168.80 kg·hm-2,耕地磷负荷为23.05 kg·hm-2。2018年区域间差异较大,东部和北部地区单位耕地面积氮磷负荷量较高,西部和中部地区偏低,其中氮和磷负荷最高的是定安(分别为288.50和40.35 kg·hm-2),最低的是东方(分别为61.66和8.83 kg·hm-2)。就环境效应来看,1988—2018年海南岛畜禽粪尿耕地负荷预警值始终处于较高水平,大多数年份在1.0—1.5,分级标准中达到Ⅳ级,对环境有较严重的威胁。2018年,定安和澄迈等地预警值分别为2.66和4.59,预警分级达Ⅵ级,对环境有很严重的威胁,仅东方处于安全水平,数值为0.36,为Ⅰ级。就环境风险评价结果来看,海南岛耕地上畜禽粪污环境风险较高,近年随着养殖总量的控制有所降低,2018年环境风险指数下降到1.99(以氮计)和1.32(以磷计)。在区域水平上,就氮素的环境污染风险,2018年定安环境风险指数最高,为3.39,东方最低,为0.73;对于磷素的环境污染风险,东方环境风险指数最低,为0.50,可认为磷素对环境潜在威胁较低,对环境有严重影响的是定安,风险值高达2.31。总的来说,畜禽粪尿耕地负荷预警值和环境风险指数均表明海南岛畜禽粪污潜在环境风险大,从空间分布看,定安、万宁等东部市(县)环境风险要高于临高、东方等西部地区,并且大多数市(县)对环境均有较高程度的威胁。【结论】受养殖规模和耕地面积影响,海南岛单位耕地面积氮负荷较高,区域潜在环境风险不容忽视。因此,未来海南岛畜禽养殖发展规划更应着眼于污染物的控制以及区域优化布局和管理上,并通过减少畜禽粪尿环境排放和循环利用模式以实现海南岛畜禽粪污的资源化利用和绿色发展。

关键词: 海南岛, 畜禽粪尿, 氮磷负荷量, 环境效应

Abstract:

【Objective】The objective of this study is to reveal the flow characteristics of nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) in manure and their effects to the environment during the development of livestock and poultry breeding in Hainan, and to provide references for regional agricultural development planning and adjustment of livestock and poultry breeding structure. 【Method】Based on the statistical data and literature data, the nutrient yield of animal manure and nutrient carrying capacity per unit cultivated area in Hainan Island from 1988 to 2018 were estimated, and their effects to the environment were deeply analyzed by using alarm value and environmental risk index. When the alarm value is less than 0.4, it can be considered as no threat to the environment, and when the environmental risk index is below 1.00, the risk to the environment can be ignored, above these safety values will have different degrees of impacts on the environment. 【Result】From 1988 to 2018, the changes of the animal manure amount in Hainan Island experienced three stages. The total amount of animal manure increased from 1988 to 2005, and decreased a lot from 2006 to 2008. Since then it developed slowly and stabilized, and the amount of animal manure produced in 2018 was 10.50×106t. In terms of nutrient yield, the annual variation trends of nitrogen and phosphorus were similar, with the largest yield in 2005 and a relatively large decline in 2006. To 2018, the yields of nitrogen and phosphorus in manure were 7.41×104 and 1.01×104 t, respectively. The nitrogen and phosphorus loads per unit cultivated land area also experienced a stable trend after continuous increasing. To 2018, cultivated land nitrogen load was 168.80 kg·hm-2, and cultivated land phosphorus load was 23.05 kg·hm-2. In 2018, regional variations were relatively large. The nitrogen and phosphorus loads per unit cultivated area were higher in eastern and northern regions, while lower in western and central regions. The highest nitrogen and phosphorus loads were Dingan (288.50 and 40.35 kg·hm-2, respectively), and the lowest were Dongfang (61.66 and 8.83 kg·hm-2, respectively). In terms of environmental effects, the alarm values of animal manure per cultivated land from 1988 to 2018 were always at high levels, most years between 1.0 to 1.5, which belonged to the classification standard of IV level and had a serious threat to the environment. In 2018, the alarm values in Dingan and Chengmai were 2.66 and 4.59 (reached the VI level), which had a serious threat to the environment, while only Dongfang was at a safe level with the alarm value of 0.36, which reached the I level. According to the environmental risk assessment results, the environmental risk of animal manure in cultivated land in Hainan Island was relatively high. In recent years, with the total amount of animal breeding reduction, the environmental risk indexes in 2018 dropped to 1.99 (N) and 1.32 (P), respectively. At the regional level, for nitrogen pollution, the environmental risk index of Dingan was the highest (3.39), while the lowest (0.73) was Dongfang; for phosphorus pollution, the environmental risk index in Dongfang (0.50) was the lowest in 2018, which can be considered that phosphorus in Dongfang had a low potential threat to the environment, while Dingan had a serious impact on the environment, with a value as high as 2.31. In general, both the alarm value and the environmental risk index indicated that the potential environmental risk of animal manure pollution in Hainan Island was serious, from the perspective of spatial distribution, environmental risks in eastern cities and counties such as Dingan and Wanning were higher than those in western regions such as Lingao and Dongfang, and most cities and counties posed a higher degree of threat to the environment. 【Conclusion】Due to the influence of animal breeding scale and cultivated land area, the nitrogen load per cultivated land area in Hainan Island is relatively high, and the potential environmental risks of the region scales cannot be ignored. Therefore, the future development plan of livestock and poultry breeding in Hainan Island should focus on the control of pollutants, regional distribution and management, meanwhile, realize the utilization of animal manure resources and the green development of Hainan Island by reducing the animal manure discharge to the environment and adopting resource recycling modes.

Key words: Hainan Island, animal manure, loads of nitrogen and phosphorus, environmental effect