|Environmental risk for application of ammonia-soda white mud in soils in China
|WANG Xiao-bin, YAN Xiang, LI Xiu-ying
|Institute of Agricultural Resources and Regional Planning, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Beijing 100081, P.R.China
Abstract In recent years, some reports, mainly from Chinese research, show that there has been an increasing trend in the use of ammonia-soda residue (ASR) (or called ammonia-soda white mud) as a soil conditioner in farmlands. Up to now, the studies on ASR have focused on its utilization for acid soil amendment in agriculture, but few studies have assessed its environmental risk. ASR contains pollutant elements such as mercury (Hg), cadmium (Cd), copper (Cu) and fluorine (F) and the purpose of this study was to review research on the environmental impacts of ASR application in agriculture. Observations obtained from 23 research reports indicate that the concentrations of Hg, Cd, Cu, F and Cl (0–170, 0.01–2.8, 4.5–200, 2000–24700 and 1 600–188 000 mg kg–1, respectively) in ASR may exceed the limits (≤0.5, ≤0.3 and ≤50 mg kg–1 for Hg, Cd and Cu, respectively) of Chinese Risk Screening Values for Soil Contamination of Agricultural Land (GB 15618-2018 2018) or the refereed critical value (≤800 and ≤200 mg kg–1 for F and Cl, respectively) based on Chinese research. The concentrations of the elements Hg, Cd, Cu, F and Cl in the leachate of ASR detected by the extraction tests also exceed the limits (Class IV–V) of the Chinese Standard for Groundwater Quality (GB/T 14848-2017 2017). Based on the above results, it is suggested that ASR without any pretreatment for reducing harmful pollutants should not be used for soil remediation or conditioning of farmlands, to ensure soil health, food safety and environmental quality.
Received: 30 December 2018
|Fund: The study was supported by the Special Program for Fertilizer Registration of Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs of China (2130112).
Correspondence YAN Xiang, Tel: +86-10-82106382, E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org; LI Xiu-ying, E-mail: email@example.com
WANG Xiao-bin, E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org;
Cite this article:
WANG Xiao-bin, YAN Xiang, LI Xiu-ying.
Environmental risk for application of ammonia-soda white mud in soils in China. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 19(3): 601-611.
| Cui J X, Chen W, Ou Y J. 2009. The effect of calcium on different species of fluorine in soil. Guangzhou Chemistry, 34, 13–18, 30. (in Chinese)
Ding Y, Mao X Y. 2017. 2011–2016 global soda ash market analysis report. Shandong Chemical Industry, 46, 128–130. (in Chinese)
Duan Z K. 1983. Summary on fertilizer effect of calcium-magnesium fertilizer on peanut and other crops in Dalian area. Soda Industry, 4, 20–29. (in Chinese)
Escrig I, Morell I. 1998. Effect of calcium on soil adsorption of cadmium and zinc in some Spanish sandy soils. Water, Air and Soil Pollution, 105, 507–520.
Effler S W, Matthews D A. 2003. Impacts of a soda ash facility on Onondaga Lake and the Seneca River, NY. Lake and Reservoir Management, 19, 285–306.
Fan Z Y. 2008. Experimental study on wet desulfurization of industrial wastes. MSc thesis, Shandong University, China. (in Chinese)
Fu M J. 1998. Situation and suggestions on treatment and comprehensive utilization of waste liquid and residue in ammonia soda plant. Soda Industry, 1, 7–13. (in Chinese)
GB/T 14848-2017. 2017. Standards for Groundwater Quality. General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine of of China, and Standardization Administration of China. p. 14. (in Chinese)
GB 15618-2018. 2018. Soil Environmental Quality Risk Control Standard for Soil Contamination of Agricultural Land. Ministry of Ecology and Environment of China, and State Administration for Market Regulation of China, China.
p. 4. (in Chinese)
GB 18599-2001. 2001. Standard for Pollution Control on the Storage and Disposal Site for General Industrial Solid Wastes. State Environmental Protection Administration of China, and General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine of China. p. 4. (in Chinese)
GB 34330-2017. 2017. Identification Standards for Solid Wastes General Rules. State Environmental Protection Administration of China, and General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine of China. p. 5. (in Chinese)
GB 3838-2002. 2002. Environmental Quality Standards for Surface Water. State Environmental Protection Administration of China, and General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine of China. p. 9. (in Chinese)
GB 5085.1-2007. 2007. Identification Standards for Hazardous Wastes Identification for Corrosivity. State Environmental Protection Administration of China, and General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine of China. pp. 5–6. (in Chinese)
GB 5085.3-2007. 2007. Identification Standards for Hazardous Wastes Identification for Extraction Toxicity. State Environmental Protection Administration of China, and General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine of China. p. 1. (in Chinese)
GB 8978-1996. 1996. Integrated Wastewater Discharge Standards. State Environmental Protection Administration of China, and General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine of China. p. 23. (in Chinese)
Guo L M, Ai S Y, Tang M D, Li M J, Yao J W, Wang Y H, Zeng Z B. 2011. Effect of alkali slag on cadmium bioavailability in the contaminated soil. Environmental Science &Technology, 34, 100–103. (in Chinese)
Han K H, Zhao J L, Zheng B, Lu C M, Zhao G J. 2009. Sulfur retention performance and modification of alkaline wastes used in coal combustion. Journal of China Coal Society, 34, 1697–1702. (in Chinese)
Hou G H. 2002. Study on optimum burning temperature of white cement by soda residue. Industrial Minerals & Processing, 6, 17–19. (in Chinese)
Huang L F, Li J Y, Chen Z H, Wang L Q. 2014. Preliminary study on the effects of the application of alkaline slag combined with biomass ash on acidic soil. South China Fruits, 43, 65–67. (in Chinese)
Jin C X, Zhou Q X. 2006. Characteristics of cadmium transfer between soil-water interface affected by pH. Journal of Shenyang Jianzhu University (Natural Science), 22, 626–628. (in Chinese)
Kabata-Pendias A. 2001. Trace Elements in Soil and Plants. 3rd ed. CRC Press, USA.
Kuang S P, Zhang C J, Jiang Z G, Shi Z J. 2006. Review on comprehensive utilization techniques of alkaline slag in soda ash factory. China Resources Comprehensive Utilization, 3, 20–24. (in Chinese)
Lan L, Tu S H. 2018. Effects of secondary, micro- and beneficial elements on soil pH and Cd availability. Sichuan Agricultural Science and Technology, 3, 43–47. (in Chinese)
Li J, Xie Z M, Xu J M, Wu W H. 2005. Preliminary study on guideline on soil health quality index of fluorine and method of its evaluation in China. Journal of Zhejiang University (Agriculture and Life Science), 31, 593–597. (in Chinese)
Li J, Xie Z M, Xu J M. 2006. Research progress in the relationship between soil environmental quality index of fluorine and human health in China. Chinese Journal of Soil Science, 37, 194–199. (in Chinese)
Li J Y, Wang N, Xu R K, Tiwari D. 2010. Potential of industrial byproducts in ameliorating acidity and aluminum toxicity of soils under tea plantation. Pedosphere, 20, 645–654. (in Chinese)
Li L. 2004. Study on deformation properties and microcosmic mechanism of the soda residue. MSc thesis, Tianjin University, China (in Chinese)
Li R B, Wang L Z. 1992. A study on the leaching of fluorioe in soil. Acta Geographica Sinica, 47, 376–381. (in Chinese)
Li X. 2010. Removal of anionic dyes from aqueous solution by leaching solution of white mud. MSc thesis, Shandong University, China. (in Chinese)
Li Y Q, Ni W, Xu D, Gao W. 2017. Application of orthogonal test method in low alkaline solid waste concrete. Fly Ash Comprehensive Utilization, 1, 29–32. (in Chinese)
Liu J J, Zha F S, Wang L B, Zhang X Q. 2016. Leaching properties of lead contaminated soils treated by soda residue. Journal of Southeast University (Natural Science Edition), 43(Suppl.), 94–98. (in Chinese)
Liu P, Xu M G, Song Z G. 2007. Effects of accompanying anions on adsorption-desorption of Pb and Cd by two typical soils of China. Journal of Agro-environment Science, 26, 252–256. (in Chinese)
Liu R. 2011. Study on feasibility of alkali waste utilization. MSc thesis, Qingdao Technological University, China. (in Chinese)
Liu X W, Liu X B, Liu Z G, Li G F. 2011. Leaching toxicity experiment and treatment of alkaline slag. Journal of Salt and Chemical Industry, 40, 51–54. (in Chinese)
Liu X Z, Yao D, Dong F Z, Ren C C. 2001. Comprehensive utilization of alkaline slag. Industrial Minerals and Porocessing, 3, 1–4. (in Chinese)
Lou X Y, Zhang H Y, Yan S J. 1999. Study on the comprehensive utilization of the waste of soda-production. Journal of Qingdao Institute of Architecture and Engineering, 20, 59–60. (in Chinese)
Ma F B. 2014. Modification and adsorption properties of alkaline sludge from soda plant. MSc thesis, Nanjing University of Science & Technology, China. (in Chinese)
Maas E V. 1990. Crop salt tolerance. In: Tanji K K, ed., Agricultural Salinity Assessment and Management. Manuals and Reports on Engineering Practice No. 71. American Society of Civil Engineering, New York. pp. 262–304.
Pan D W. 2017. Comprehensive utilization of ammonia-soda waste liquid by salt-alkali circulation. Soda Industry, 3, 10–12. (in Chinese)
Pan D W, Xu R K. 2017. Study on the application of ammonia-alkali waste slag in soil conditioner. Soda Industry, 4, 16–19. (in Chinese)
Qian C X, Hu X M, Wang H B, Chen C, Wang X T. 2006. Research on application of soda residue as filler in asphalt concrete. Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development, 23, 14–18. (in Chinese)
Shu J H. 1981. Fluorine Pollution in soil near some phosphorus fertilizer plants in China. Environmental Science Series, 1, 12–18. (in Chinese)
Smolders E, Mclaughlin M J. 1996. Chloride increases cadmium uptake in Swiss chard in a resin-buffered nutrient solution. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 60, 1443–1447.
Song X X. 2013. Effects of chlorides on the adsorption and migration of cadmium in soil vadose zone. MSc thesis, Tianjin Normal University, China. (in Chinese)
Song Z G, Xu M G, Liu P, Li J M. 2006. Effects of co-existing cations, Ca, K and Zn on adsorption of cadmium in lateritic red soil. Ecology and Environment, 15, 993–996. (in Chinese)
Steinhauser G. 2008. Cleaner production in the Solvay process: General strategies and recent developments. Journal of Cleaner Production, 16, 833–841.
Sun G D, Yu L X, Zhao Y P, Zhang Y F. 1991. Building cementing materials made by ammonia-soda waste residue. Soda Industry, 6, 1–4. (in Chinese)
Sutkowska K, Teper L, Stania M. 2015. Tracing potential soil contamination in the historical Solvay soda ash plant area, Jaworzno, Southern Poland. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 187, 704.
Sun S L, Zheng Q H, Tang J, Zhang G Y, Zhou L G, Shang W T. 2012. Experimental research on expansive soil improved by soda residue. Rock & Soil Mechanics, 33, 1608–1612. (in Chinese)
Sun J F, Wang G X, Liu H F, Bao W K, Hou X N. 2017. Study on current situation of harmful elements in soil conditioners of China and the agricultural resource utilization of relevant raw materials. Soil and Fertilizer Sciences in China, 6, 149–154. (in Chinese)
USGS (U.S. Geological Survey). 2005. Soda Ash, Minerals Information. U.S. Department of the Interior, U.S. Geological Survey, USA.
USGS. 2017. Soda Ash, Minerals Information. U.S. Department of the Interior, U.S. Geological Survey, USA.
USGS. 2018. Minerals Yearbook-2016: Soda Ash, Minerals Information. U.S. Department of the Interior, U.S. Geological Survey, USA.
Wang B J, Geng X R, Yu E. 2015. Preparation of liquid desulfurizer by comprehensive utilization of caustic sludge. Soda Industry, 6, 12–15. (in Chinese)
Wang C C, Wang P. 2009. Effect of pH on release amount of Pb and Cd in soil. Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences, 37, 2170–2171. (in Chinese)
Wang D Q, Guo P C, Dong X Y. 1990. Study on the toxicity of chlorine to crops. Chinese Journal of Soil Science, 6, 258–261. (in Chinese)
Wang H, Xu R K, Li X H. 2011. Effect of alkaline slag application on acidity of tea garden soils and tea quality. Journal of Ecology and Rural Environment, 27, 75–78. (in Chinese)
Wang J N, Chen D F. 2000. Experiments on the utilization of discards from the chemical industry as substitutes for the conventionalabsorbents of desulfurization. Energy Research and Information, 16, 29–34. (in Chinese)
Wang M K, Yang F Q, Zhu Q, Ma W. 2014. Effect of caustic sludge on the surrounding environment in Shahe estuary of Fengnan region, Tangshan City. Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences, 42, 2696–2697. (in Chinese)
Wang X N, Zhang Y J, Wang Y F, Liu Y J, Li Y, Liu D C. 2014. Comprehensive utilization for alkaline slag in the soda production by ammonia-soda process. Chemical Engineer, 2, 32–34. (in Chinese)
Wang Y Y, Liang Y H, Rui Y L. 2005. Studies on the development of comprehensive utilization for alkaline slag. Industrial Safety and Environmental Protection, 31, 29–31. (in Chinese)
Wang Z W, Ji W X, Zhang H. 2012a. Impact of inorganic cations on cadmium fractions in the alkaline saline soils. Ecology and Environmental Sciences, 21, 1121–1124. (in Chinese)
Wang Z W, Yi L P, Gao W Y, Zeng X F, Wang Z L. 2012b. Impact of inorganic anions on the cadmium effective fraction in soil and its phytoavailability during salinization in alkaline soils. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 32, 7512–7518. (in Chinese)
Weggler K, Mclaughlin M J, Graham R D. 2004. Effect of chloride in soil solution on the plant availability of biosolid-borne cadmium. Journal of Environmental Quality, 33, 496–504.
Wei F S, Chen J S, Wu Y Y, Zheng C J. 1991. Research on China’s soil environmental background value. Environmental Science, 12, 12–19. (in Chinese)
Yan C. 2008. Research on method of synthesis environment estimation and mechanism of strength for pure alkali residue. Ph D thesis, Tianjin University, China. (in Chinese)
Yang C Y. 2004. Preliminary discussion on the pollution and control of chloride in surface water. Environmental Science Trends, 1, 25–26. (in Chinese)
Yang L Z, Li Y D, Zhang L H. 2008. The treatment and utilization of soda slag. Environmental Protection Science, 34, 70–73. (in Chinese)
Yang Y B, Pu Y Q, Yan W J, Guo W Y, Wang H C. 2017. Microstructure and chloride ion dissolution characteristics of soda residue. Journal of South China University of Technology (Natural Science Edition), 45, 82–89. (in Chinese)
Yao W C, Meng Y H. 1997. Discussion on wet production of building cementitious material (Alinite) cement from soda residue produced by ammonia-soda process. Soda Industry, 1, 27–31. (in Chinese)
Yu S J, Song X Y. 2006. Research on recycling technology of industrial solid waste. Low Temperature Architecture Technology, 3, 18–19. (in Chinese)
Yuan X M, Zhang H, Liu X M, Xiong F. 2010. Influence of alkaline residue site on carst groundwater. The Administration and Technique of Environmental Monitoring, 22, 36–39. (in Chinese)
Zhao L B, Xu B, Li G F, Zhang J R. 2017. Development status in comprehensive utilization of alkaline residues. Industrial Minerals and Porocessing, 6, 73–76. (in Chinese)
Zhang B W, Song W F, Xie W M, Mo Y T. 2009. Research progress in the production of calcium carbonate with white mud from soda plant. Guangxi Journal of Light Industry, 2, 91–93. (in Chinese)
Zhang D W. 1994. The environmental quality standards of selenium in soils of China. Research of Soil and Water Conservation, S1, 112. (in Chinese)
Zhang Y, Cao J, Dong Y, Chen B H, Zhang Y, Zong R. 2013. Experimental investigation of influence of temperature on microstructure of alkaline residue. Journal of Lanzhou University of Technology, 39, 126–129. (in Chinese)
Zhu C L, Liu S Q. 2018. Comprehensive utilization of waste liquid and caustic residue in soda production based on ammonia-soda process. Chemical Enterprise Management, 5, 144–145. (in Chinese)
Zou S P, Jiang Y H. 1994. Study on making new cement from alkali residue and coal gangue. Environmental Protection of Chemical Industry, 14, 358–365. (in Chinese)
|No Suggested Reading articles found!