天然蜂粮对高脂血症大鼠血脂、抗氧化及免疫功能的影响

doi:10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2019.16.016

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

【目的】蜂粮是工蜂将采集的花粉团贮存在巢房中,然后将花粉团咬碎、吐蜜湿润,经过2—3周发酵酿制而成。蜂粮是蜂群中大幼虫和幼龄蜜蜂发育必需的全价营养。虽然传统观点认为天然蜂粮营养价值高于蜂花粉,但是没有科学依据。为了科学评价蜂粮营养功效,以蜂花粉为对照,系统研究天然蜂粮对大鼠血脂、抗氧化和免疫功能的影响。【方法】采用江西农业大学蜜蜂研究所设计生产的天然蜂粮生产器,利用西方蜜蜂(Apis mellifera)在白莲花期生产天然蜂粮和蜂花粉。以大鼠为实验动物,参照人每日推荐食用蜂花粉剂量,天然蜂粮和蜂花粉均分别设置低剂量组（80 mg·kg ^-1）、中剂量组（400 mg·kg ^-1）和高剂量组（800 mg·kg ^-1）,同时设置空白对照组和高脂模型对照组。按标准方法造大鼠高脂血症模型,再连续灌胃60 d天然蜂粮或蜂花粉后,测定血脂水平甘油三酯（TG）、总胆固醇（TC）、低密度脂蛋白（LDL）和高密度脂蛋白（HDL-C）,取血检测抗氧化指标超氧化物歧化酶（SOD）、谷胱甘肽过氧化酶（GSH-Px）、丙二醛（MDA）和总抗氧化能力(T-AOC)以及免疫因子白细胞介素-6（IL-6）和肿瘤坏死因子-α（TNF-α）。【结果】与高脂模型组相比,蜂粮低剂量组能显著降低高脂血症大鼠血液中TG、TC、LDL含量,蜂粮中剂量组能显著提高HDL-C含量,蜂花粉低剂量组能显著降低高脂血症大鼠血液中TG与TC含量,说明蜂粮和蜂花粉均有良好的降低高脂血症的功效;与高脂模型组相比,低剂量组蜂粮、中剂量组蜂粮、高剂量组蜂粮以及低剂量组蜂花粉、中剂量组蜂花粉均能显著升高TNF-α含量,说明蜂粮和蜂花粉均具有增强免疫的效果;与高脂模型组相比,蜂花粉高剂量组大鼠血液中SOD含量显著增加,3个蜂粮剂量组以及蜂花粉低剂量组和中剂量组SOD含量均差异不显著,说明蜂花粉高剂量组具有增强抗氧化能力的功效;与高脂模型组相比,6个试验组的GSH-Px、T-AOC以及MDA含量均差异不显著。与蜂花粉低剂量组和蜂花粉中剂量组相比,蜂粮中剂量组能显著提升HDL-C含量;与3个蜂花粉剂量组相比,蜂粮中剂量组能显著提高TNF-α含量。【结论】综合TG、TC、LDL、HDL-C以及TNF-α等指标,天然蜂粮的降血脂和增强免疫的功效要优于蜂花粉,天然蜂粮值得进一步开发利用。

关键词: 蜂粮, 大鼠, 血脂, 抗氧化, 免疫

Abstract:

【Objective】Bee bread is that the worker bee stores the collected pollen mass in the nest room, then bites the pollen mass, spits honey moist, and ferments it for 2 to 3 weeks. Bee bread provides essential nutritional supply for the development of old larvae and young bees. Although the traditional view is that the nutritional value of natural bee bread is higher than that of bee pollen, but there is no scientific basis. In order to evaluate the nutritional effect of bee bread scientifically, the effects of natural bee bread on blood lipid, antioxidation and immune function in rats were systematically studied with bee pollen as control.【Method】The natural bee bread producer designed by the Honeybee Research Institute of Jiangxi Agricultural University was used to produce natural bee bread and pollen by honey bee workers (Apis mellifera) at the flowering stage of white lotus. The hyperlipidemia rats used in this study were established by standard method. A blank control group and a high-fat model control group were prepared. Three doses of bee bread and pollen (low-dose group of 80 mg?kg ^-1, middle-dose group of 400 mg?kg ^-1, and high-dose group of 800 mg?kg ^-1) were fed to hyperlipidemia rats, respectively. After intragastric administration natural bee bread and bee pollen for 60 days, the levels of blood lipids including triglyceride (TG), total cholesterol (TC), low density lipoprotein (LDL) and high density lipoprotein (HDL-C) were measured. Additionally, antioxidant indexes superoxide dismutase (SOD), glutathione peroxidase (GSH-Px), malondialdehyde (MDA), total antioxidant capacity (T-AOC), immune factors interleukin 6 (IL-6) and tumor necrosis factor α (TNF-α) were detected in blood.【Result】Compared with the high-fat model group, low-dose bee bread treatment group significantly reduced the levels of TG, TC and LDL in the blood of hyperlipidemia rats. Middle-dose bee bread treatment group significantly increased the level of HDL-C. Low-dose bee pollen treatment group significantly reduced the levels of TG and TC, which indicated that both bee bread and bee pollen had a good effect on reducing hyperlipidemia. Additionally, low-, middle-, high-dose bee bread, as well as low- and middle-dose bee pollen significantly increased the content of TNF-α, which indicated that both bee bread and bee pollen enhanced immune responses compared with the high-fat model group. The SOD content in the blood of rats with high-dose bee pollen group increased significantly, but the differences among the three doses of bee bread groups, the low- and the middle-dose groups of bee pollen were not statistically significant compared with the high-fat model group. It suggested that the high-dose bee pollen enhanced antioxidant capacity. Compared with the high-fat model group, the contents of GSH-Px, T-AOC and MDA among the six experimental groups were not significantly different. Compared with the low- and middle-dose bee pollen groups, the middle-dose bee bread group significantly increased the content of HDL-C. Compared with the three groups of bee pollen, middle-dose bee bread group significantly increased the TNF-α content.【Conclusion】Combined with TG, TC, LDL, HDL-C and TNF-α, the effects of natural bee bread on reducing blood lipid and enhancing immunity were stronger than those of bee pollen. Natural bee bread is worthy of further development and utilization.

Key words: honeybee bread, rat, blood lipid, antioxidation, immunity

李震,刘志勇,江武军,何旭江,颜伟玉,张丽珍,曾志将. 天然蜂粮对高脂血症大鼠血脂、抗氧化及免疫功能的影响[J]. 中国农业科学, 2019, 52(16): 2912-2920.

LI Zhen,LIU ZhiYong,JIANG WuJun,HE XuJiang,YAN WeiYu,ZHANG LiZhen,ZENG ZhiJiang. Effects of Natural Bee Bread on Blood Lipid, Antioxidation and Immune Function in Rats with Hyperlipidemia[J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2019, 52(16): 2912-2920.

图/表 5

表1

表2

表3

表4

图1

参考文献 47

[1]	江武军, 曾志将 . 蜂粮研究进展. 黑龙江畜牧兽医, 2015(1):118-119.
	JIANG W J, ZENG Z J . Advances on the bee bread research. Heilongjiang Animal Science and Veterinary Medicine, 2015(1):118-119. (in Chinese)
[2]	ANĐELKOVIĆ B, JEVTIĆ G, MLADENOVIĆ M, MARKOVIĆ J, PETROVIĆ M, NEDIĆ N . Quality of pollen and honey bee bread collected in spring. Journal of Hygienic Engineering and Design, 2012,1:275-277.
[3]	张少斌 . 分合式巢房巢脾: CN99222971.5[P]. ( 1999-03-02) [2019- 04-08].
	ZHANG S B . Split type of comb: CN99222971.5[P]. ( 1999-03-02) [2019-04-08]. (in Chinese)
[4]	张少斌, 张明海 . 开合式巢脾: CN200520020078.6[P]. (2005-01-17) [2019-04-08].
	ZHANG S B, ZHANG M H . Retractable comb: CN200520020078. 6[P]. (2005-01-17) [2019-04-08]. (in Chinese)
[5]	张少斌, 张石胜 . KF-1、2型塑料巢脾在养蜂生产上的应用. 中国养蜂, 1999,50(4):17.
	ZHANG S B, ZHANG S S . The application in the production of plastic comb bee of KF-1 or KF-2. Apiculture of China, 1999,50(4):17. (in Chinese)
[6]	苏松坤, 陈盛禄 . 天然蜂粮的生产方法及器具: CN200410073451. 4[P]. ( 2004-12-16) [2019-04-08].
	SU S K, CHEN S L . Method and apparatus for producing natural bee bread: CN200410073451.4[P]. ( 2004-12-16) [2019-04-08]. (in Chinese)
[7]	苏松坤, 陈盛禄, 刘华, 林雪珍 . 天然蜂粮生产方法. 养蜂科技, 2006(6):32-33.
	SU S K, CHEN S L, LIU H, LIN X Z . Method for producing natural bee bread. Apicultural Science and Technology, 2006(6):32-33. (in Chinese)
[8]	AKHMETOVA R, SIBGATULLIN J, GARMONOV S, AKHMETOVA L . Technology for extraction of bee-bread from the honeycomb. Procedia Engineering, 2012,42:1822-1825.
[9]	江武军, 何旭江, 吴小波, 席芳贵, 曾志将 . 天然蜂粮生产技术及贮存规律研究. 江西农业大学学报, 2018,40(6):1293-1298.
	JIANG W J, HE X J, WU X B, XI F G, ZENG Z J . Study on production technology and storage regular analysis of natural honeybee bread. Acta Agriculturae Universitatis Jiangxiensis, 2018,40(6):1293-1298. (in Chinese)
[10]	江武军, 吴小波, 刘光楠, 何旭江, 颜伟玉, 曾志将 . 天然蜂粮生产技术研究与应用. 中国农业科学, 2017,50(19):3828-3836. doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2017.19.019
	JIANG W J, WU X B, LIU G N, HE X J, YAN W Y, ZENG Z J . Research and application of production technology of natural honeybee bread. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2017,50(19):3828-3836. (in Chinese) doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2017.19.019
[11]	费起充 . 蜂粮的制作. 蜜蜂杂志, 1998(7):15.
	FEI Q C . Bee bread production. Journal of Bee, 1998(7):15. (in Chinese)
[12]	苏松坤 . 蜂粮(bee bread)的酿制机理和营养价值的研究[D]. 杭州: 浙江大学, 2000.
	SU S K . Studies on brew mechanism and nutritive value of bee bread[D]. Hangzhou: Zhejiang University, 2000. (in Chinese)
[13]	苏松坤, 陈盛禄, 林雪珍, 胡福良, 余旭平, 汪礼国, 王正二 . 茶(Camellia sinensis)蜂花粉与蜂粮中花粉形态和营养成分的比较. 中国养蜂, 2000,51(6):3-6.
	SU S K, CHEN S L, LIN X Z, HU F L, YU X P, WANG L G, WANG Z E . The comparison of pollen morpha and nutrient components between corbicular tea (Camellia sinensis) pollen and bee bread. Apiculture of China, 2000,51(6):3-6. (in Chinese)
[14]	苏松坤, 陈盛禄 . 茶(Camellia sinensis)蜂花粉及其蜂粮的营养成分研究. 上海交通大学学报 (农业科学版), 2002,20(2):95-99.
	SU S K, CHEN S L . The research of nutrient compositions of tea (Camellia sinensis) corbicular pollen and tea bee bread. Journal of Shanghai Jiao Tong University (Agricultural Science), 2002,20(2):95-99. (in Chinese)
[15]	苏松坤, 陈盛禄, 李言清 . 人工蜂粮的制备方法: CN03150405.1[P]. ( 2003-08-15) [2019-04-08].
	SU S K, CHEN S L, LI Y Q . The preparation method of artificial bee bread: CN03150405.1[P]. ( 2003-08-15) [2019-04-08]. (in Chinese)
[16]	VÁSQUEZ A, OLOFSSON T C . The lactic acid bacteria involved in the production of bee pollen and bee bread. Journal of Apicultural Research, 2009,48(3):189-195.
[17]	DUAN C R, FENG Y F, ZHOU H, XIA X H, SHANG Y N, CUI Y M . Optimization of fermentation condition of man-made bee-bread by response surface methodology//ZHANG T C, NAKAJIMA M. Advances in Applied Biotechnology. Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2015: 353-363.
[18]	崔学沛 . 意大利蜜蜂天然成熟蜂粮菌种鉴定及人工蜂粮发酵影响因素的探究[D]. 泰安: 山东农业大学, 2015.
	CUI X P . The identification of strains in natural mature bee bread of honey bee (A. mellifera L.) and study on the fermentation conditions of artificial bee bread[D]. Taian: Shandong Agricultural University, 2015. (in Chinese)
[19]	石憬林 . 蜂粮营养并不高于蜂花粉. 养蜂科技, 1994(3):20-21.
	SHI J L . Bee bread nutrition is not higher than bee pollen. Apicultural Science and Technology, 1994(3):20-21. (in Chinese)
[20]	袁耀东 . 蜂粮的成分和作用. 中国养蜂, 1991(6):36-37.
	YUAN Y D . Composition and function of bee food. Apiculture of China, 1991(6):36-37. (in Chinese)
[21]	BALTRUŠAITYTE V, VENSKUTONIS P R, CEKSTERYTE V . Antibacterial activity of honey and beebread of different origin against S. aureus and S. epidermidis. Food Technology and Biotechnology, 2007,45(2):201-208.
[22]	DEGRANDI-HOFFMAN G, ECKHOLM B J, HUANG M H . Concentrations of nutrients in pollen can change after conversion to bee bread. American Bee Journal, 2013,153(11):1195-1198.
[23]	曾志将 . 养蜂学. 3版. 北京: 中国农业出版社, 2017.
	ZENG Z J. Apiculture. 3rd ed. Beijing: China Agriculture Press, 2017. (in Chinese)
[24]	李楠, 赵静, 吴茹, 王文君 . 青钱柳多糖对高脂血症小鼠脂代谢及PPARγ、ATGL基因mRNA表达的影响. 中国食品学报, 2015,15(9):9-14.
	LI N, ZHAO J, WU R, WANG W J . Research on the influence of Cyclocarya paliurus(Batal.) Iljinskaja polysaccharide on PPARγ and ATGL gene expression in hyperlipoidemia mice. Journal of Chinese Institute of Food Science and Technology, 2015,15(9):9-14. (in Chinese)
[25]	包国良, 傅颖 . 卵磷脂花粉对实验性高血脂大鼠的降血脂效应及其机制研究. 医学研究杂志, 2008,37(8):99-102.
	BAO G L, FU Y . Study of the effect and function mechanism of pine pollen on reducing the blood-level of the experimental mice. Journal of Medical Research, 2008,37(8):99-102. (in Chinese)
[26]	王开发, 王隆华, 支崇远, 陈素英, 邹军 . 玉米花粉黄酮类物质对SD大鼠降血脂作用的研究. 放射免疫学杂志, 2002,15(6):368-370.
	WANG K F, WANG L H, ZHI C Y, CHEN S Y, ZOU J . Effect of flavone material in maize pollen on reducing blood fat of SD rats. Journal of Radioimmunology, 2002,15(6):368-370. (in Chinese)
[27]	樊柏林, 刘烈刚 . 破壁松花粉对大鼠降血脂效应及作用机制研究. 职业与健康, 2005,21(6):809-811.
	FAN B L, LIU L G . Study on the effect and functional mechanism of pine pollen on reducing the blood-fat level of the experimental mice. Occupation and Health, 2005,21(6):809-811. (in Chinese)
[28]	杜孟浩, 王敬文, 张金萍, 汪永义, 高华 . 松花粉超临界二氧化碳萃取物降血脂功能实验研究. 中国现代医学杂志, 2008,18(21):3171-3173, 3176.
	DU M H, WANG J W, ZHANG J P, WANG Y Y, GAO H . Effects of oil extracted with supercritical CO₂ fluid from pine pollen (Pinus massoniana) on the regulation of blood lipid. China Journal of Modern Medicine, 2008,18(21):3171-3173, 3176. (in Chinese)
[29]	曾志将, 汪礼国, 饶波, 樊兆斌, 谢国秀 . 蜂花粉多糖对大鼠降血脂效果研究. 江西农业大学学报, 2004,26(3):406-408.
	ZENG Z J, WANG L G, RAO B, FAN Z B, XIE G X . A study on the effect of honeybee pollen polysaccharide on decreasing lipoidemia in rat. Acta Agriculturae Universitis Jiangxiensis, 2004,26(3):406-408. (in Chinese)
[30]	SOBRAL F, CALHELHA R C, BARROS L, DUENAS M, TOMAS A, SANTOS-BUELGA C, VILAS-BOAS M, FERREIRA I C . Flavonoid composition and antitumor activity of bee bread collected in Northeast Portugal. Molecules, 2017,22:248.
[31]	韩敏 . 黄酮类化合物降血脂作用研究进展. 西安文理学院学报 (自然科学版), 2013,16(4):11-15.
	HAN M . Recent studies on flavonoids in lowering blood lipid. Journal of Xi’an University of Arts and Science (Natural Science Edition), 2013,16(4):11-15. (in Chinese)
[32]	梁伟伟, 严瑾, 吴利花, 范春雷 . 山楂叶总黄酮对高脂血症大鼠脂代谢的影响. 健康研究, 2010,30(1):8-11.
	LIANG W W, YAN J, WU L H, FAN C L . Effect of hawthorn leaf flavonoids on lipid metabolism in hyperlipidemia rats. Health Research, 2010,30(1):8-11. (in Chinese)
[33]	李家富, 何涛, 李刚, 罗兴林, 魏宗德 . 醋柳黄酮单体对高密度脂蛋白氧化修饰的影响. 现代中西医结合杂志, 2004,13(24):3234-3235.
	LI J F, HE T, LI G, LUO X L, WEI Z D . Effect of Hippophae rhamnoides flavonoid monomers on oxidative modification of high density lipoprotein. Modern Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine, 2004,13(24):3234-3235. (in Chinese)
[34]	夏广英 . 蜂花粉中总黄酮的提取研究[D]. 福州: 福建农林大学, 2008.
	XIA G Y . Study on the extraction of the total flavonoids in bee-pollen[D]. Fuzhou: Fujian Agriculture and Forestry University, 2008. (in Chinese)
[35]	IVANIŠOVÁ E, KAČÁNIOVÁ M, FRANČÁKOVÁ H, PETROVÁ J, HUTKOVÁ J, BROVARSKYI V, VELYCHKO S, ADAMCHUK L, SCHUBERTOVÁ Z, MUSILOVÁ J . Bee bread-perspective source of bioactive compounds for future. Potravinarstvo, 2015,9(1):592-298.
[36]	KAPLAN M, KARAOGLU Ö, EROGLU N, SILICI S . Fatty acid and proximate composition of bee bread. Food Technology and Biotechnology, 2016,54(4):497-504.
[37]	孙远东, 唐新科, 刘丽莉 . 线粒体氧自由基和衰老的研究进展. 湘潭师范学院学报 (自然科学版), 2008,30(3):36-38.
	SUN Y D, TANG X K, LIU L L . Advances in mitochondrial oxygen free radicals and aging. Journal of Xiangtan Normal University (Natural Science Edition), 2008,30(3):36-38. (in Chinese)
[38]	赵凤奎, 胥保华 . 蜂花粉的抗氧化作用. 中国蜂业, 2013,64(Z2):38-43.
	ZHAO F K, XU B H . The antioxidant effect in bee pollen. Apiculture of China, 2013,64(Z2):38-43. (in Chinese)
[39]	孙丽萍, 杜夏, 徐响, 董捷, 安仲姚, 杨佳林 . 薄层层析-生物自显影法筛选油菜蜂花粉中活性成分. 食品科学, 2010,31(21):69-71. doi: 10.7506/spkx1002-6630-201021015
	SUN L P, DU X, XU X, DONG J, AN Z Y, YANG J L . Using TLC-bioautography to screen active compounds in rape bee pollen. Food Science, 2010,31(21):69-71. (in Chinese) doi: 10.7506/spkx1002-6630-201021015
[40]	石玉平, 卢挺, 王永宁 . 油菜蜂花粉中黄酮类物质清除羟基自由基的研究. 食品科学, 2004,25(11):300-302.
	SHI Y P, LU T, WANG Y N . Studies on the hydroxy-group free radical eliminated of flavonoids of Elaeagnus angustifolia L. Flowrse. Food Science, 2004,25(11):300-302. (in Chinese)
[41]	彭国霞, 赵浩安, 刘清清, 张颖, 程妮, 曹炜 . 茶花粉的抗氧化活性及其对急性酒精肝损伤的保护作用. 食品科学, 2018,39(17):127-133.
	PENG G X, ZHAO H A, LIU Q Q, ZHANG Y, CHENG N, CAO W . Antioxidant and hepatoprotective effects of Camellia japonica bee pollen on acute alcohol-induced liver damage in mice. Food Science, 2018,39(17):127-133. (in Chinese)
[42]	ROSE-JOHN S, SCHELLER J, SCHAPER F . “Family reunion”-A structured view on the composition of the receptor complexes of interleukin-6-type and interleukin-12-type cytokines. Cytokine and Growth Factor Reviews, 2015,26(5):471-474.
[43]	HUNTER C A, JONES S A . IL-6 as a keystone cytokine in health and disease. Nature Immunology, 2015,16(5):448-457.
[44]	冯馨锐, 崔雨舒, 何志涛, 崔小鹏, 王路, 潘巧燕, 齐玲 . 肿瘤坏死因子-α的生物学功能研究进展. 吉林医药学院学报, 2019,40(1):66-68.
	FENG X R, CUI Y S, HE Z T, CUI X P, WANG L, PAN Q Y, QI L . Advances in biological functions of tumor necrosis factor-alpha. Journal of Jilin Medical University, 2019,40(1):66-68. (in Chinese)
[45]	LIU H, WANG Z L, TIAN L Q, QIN Q H, WU X B, YAN W Y, ZENG Z J . Transcriptome difference in hypopharyngeal gland between western honeybees (Apis mellifera) and eastern honeybees(Apis cerana). BMC Genomics, 2014,15:744.
[46]	李爽, 李建科 . 蜂王浆高产蜜蜂与意大利蜜蜂工蜂上颚腺磷酸化蛋白质组分析. 中国农业科学, 2017,50(23):4656-4670. doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2017.23.018
	LI S, LI J K . Comparative analysis of phosphoproteome between mandibular glands of high royal jelly producing bees and Italian bees. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2017,50(23):4656-4670. (in Chinese) doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2017.23.018
[47]	张波, 吴小波, 廖春华, 何旭江, 颜伟玉, 曾志将 . 蜜蜂免移虫技术研究与应用. 中国农业科学, 2018,51(22):4387-4394. doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2018.22.016
	ZHANG B, WU X B, LIAO C H, HE X J, YAN W Y, ZENG Z J . Research and application of honeybee non-grafting larvae technology. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2018,51(22):4387-4394. (in Chinese) doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2018.22.016

试验分组 Experimental grouping	甘油三酯 Triglyceride (mmol?L^-1)
C	0.839±0.086b
HM	2.899±0.199a
HB-L	2.991±0.150a
HB-M	2.987±0.165a
HB-H	2.964±0.134a
HP-L	2.981±0.197a
HP-M	2.942±0.140a
HP-H	2.951±0.106a

试验分组 Experimental grouping	甘油三酯 Triglyceride (mmol?L^-1)	总胆固醇 Total cholesterol (mmol?L^-1)	低密度脂蛋白 Low density lipoprotein (mmol?L^-1)	高密度脂蛋白 High density lipoprotein (mmol?L^-1)
C	0.98±0.11b	2.16±0.28b	0.43±0.04b	0.32±0.04a
HM	1.65±0.24a	3.24±0.44a	0.77±0.09a	0.21±0.03c
HB-L	1.01±0.16b	2.09±0.22b	0.49±0.07b	0.23±0.03bc
HB-M	1.11±0.19b	2.51±1.20ab	0.61±0.09ab	0.30±0.04ab
HB-H	1.28±0.18ab	2.38±0.32b	0.61±0.08ab	0.26±0.03abc
HP-L	0.97±0.10b	2.34±0.12b	0.64±0.05ab	0.21±0.02c
HP-M	1.28±0.17ab	2.20±0.20b	0.60±0.09ab	0.21±0.02c
HP-H	1.23±0.12ab	2.12±0.20b	0.58±0.16ab	0.28±0.03abc

试验分组Experimental grouping	超氧化物歧化酶 Superoxide dismutase (U?mL^-1)	谷胱甘肽过氧化物酶 Glutathione peroxidase (U?mL^-1)	总抗氧化活力 Total antioxidation capacity (U?mL^-1)	丙二醛 Malondialdehyde (nmol?L^-1)
C	301.26±31.10a	177.78±30.52a	143.43±4.32a	7.60±0.35a
HM	279.94±23.74a	155.20±18.97a	117.58±6.01bcd	8.05±0.38ab
HB-L	250.19±29.09a	157.41±16.23a	122.43±2.23b	9.15±0.28b
HB-M	257.71±13.85a	161.73±27.77a	108.76±3.20d	8.93±0.58b
HB-H	274.34±17.28a	156.79±25.79a	121.99±2.85bd	8.75±0.42b
HP-L	316.89±31.89ab	128.40±16.61a	113.92±2.49cd	8.47±0.22ab
HP-M	255.57±25.38a	151.23±26.13a	125.02±2.53b	8.37±0.55ab
HP-H	390.74±16.40b	183.75±10.05a	122.92±3.24bc	8.71±0.22ab

试验分组 Experimental grouping	白细胞介素-6 Interleukin 6 (pg?mL^-1)	肿瘤坏死因子-α Tumor necrosis factor α (pg?mL^-1)
C	301.24±12.13a	252.07±9.128a
HM	285.71±9.49ab	129.34±5.87d
HB-L	287.07±11.53ab	207.05±11.28b
HB-M	312.75±8.58a	248.03±17.07a
HB-H	258.51±13.25b	188.43±21.00bc
HP-L	279.81±5.12bc	193.34±13.92bc
HP-M	255.16±16.20c	187.26±15.16bc
HP-H	257.69±8.62bc	150.66±16.56cd