Alternatives for large-scale production of cultured beef: A review
Matilda S M Moritz, Sanne E L Verbruggen, Mark J Post
1、Department of Physiology, Maastricht University, Maastricht 6229 ER, The Netherlands
2、Department of Physics, Chemistry and Biology, Linköping University, Linköping SE-581 83, Sweden
摘要 Cultured beef is a method where stem cells from skeletal muscle of cows are cultured in vitro to gain edible muscle tissue. For large-scale production of cultured beef, the culture technique needs to become more efficient than today’s 2-dimensional (2D) standard technique that was used to make the first cultured hamburger. Options for efficient large-scale production of stem cells are to culture cells on microcarriers, either in suspension or in a packed bed bioreactor, or to culture aggregated cells in suspension. We discuss the pros and cons of these systems as well as the possibilities to use the systems for tissue culture. Either of the production systems needs to be optimized to achieve an efficient production of cultured beef. It is anticipated that the optimization of large-scale cell culture as performed for other stem cells can be translated into successful protocols for bovine satellite cells resulting in resource and cost efficient cultured beef.
Abstract Cultured beef is a method where stem cells from skeletal muscle of cows are cultured in vitro to gain edible muscle tissue. For large-scale production of cultured beef, the culture technique needs to become more efficient than today’s 2-dimensional (2D) standard technique that was used to make the first cultured hamburger. Options for efficient large-scale production of stem cells are to culture cells on microcarriers, either in suspension or in a packed bed bioreactor, or to culture aggregated cells in suspension. We discuss the pros and cons of these systems as well as the possibilities to use the systems for tissue culture. Either of the production systems needs to be optimized to achieve an efficient production of cultured beef. It is anticipated that the optimization of large-scale cell culture as performed for other stem cells can be translated into successful protocols for bovine satellite cells resulting in resource and cost efficient cultured beef.
Matilda S M Moritz, Sanne E L Verbruggen, Mark J Post.
2015.
Alternatives for large-scale production of cultured beef: A review. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 14(2): 208-216.
Abbasalizadeh S, Larijani M R, Samadian A, Baharvand H.2012. Bioprocess development for mass production ofsize-controlled human pluripotent stem cell aggregates instirred suspension bioreactor. Tissue Engineering (Part C:Methods), 18, 831-851
Amit M, Chebath J, Margulets V, Laevsky I, Miropolsky Y,Shariki K, Peri M, Blais I, Slutsky G, Revel M. 2010.Suspension culture of undifferentiated human embryonicand induced pluripotent stem cells. Stem Cell Reviews andReports, 6, 248-259
Amit M, Laevsky I, Miropolsky Y, Shariki K, Peri M, Itskovitz-Eldor J. 2011. Dynamic suspension culture for scalableexpansion of undifferentiated human pluripotent stem cells.Nature Protocols, 6, 572-579
Bardouille C, Lehmann J, Heimann P, Jockusch H. 2001.Growth and differentiation of permanent and secondarymouse myogenic cell lines on microcarriers. AppliedMicrobiology and Biotechnology, 55, 556-562
Bashan N, Burdett E, Hundal H S, Klip A. 1992. Regulationof glucose transport and GLUT1 glucose transporterexpression by O2 in muscle cells in culture. AmericanJournal of Physiology (Cell Physiology), 262, C682-C690.
Bohmann A, Pörtner R, Schmieding J, Kasche V, Märkl H. 1992.The membrane dialysis bioreactor with integrated radialflowfixed bed—a new approach for continuous cultivationof animal cells. Cytotechnology, 9, 51-57
Boudreault P, Tremblay J P, Pépin M F, Garnier A. 2001. Scaleupof a myoblast culture process. Journal of Biotechnology,91, 63-74
Chakravarthy M, Spangenburg E, Booth F. 2001. Culture in lowlevels of oxygen enhances in vitro proliferation potentialof satellite cells from old skeletal muscles. Cellular andMolecular Life Sciences, 58, 1150-1158
Chen V C, Couture S M, Ye J, Lin Z, Hua G, Huang H I P, WuJ, Hsu D, Carpenter M K, Couture L A. 2012. Scalable GMPcompliant suspension culture system for human ES cells.Stem Cell Research, 8, 388-402
Chen X, Xu H, Wan C, Mccaigue M, Li G. 2006. Bioreactorexpansion of human adult bone marrow-derivedmesenchymal stem cells. Stem Cells, 24, 2052-2059
Chiou T W, Murakami S, Wang D I C. 1991. A fiber bedbioreactor for anchorage-dependent animal cell cultures:Part I. Bioreactor design and operations. Biotechnologyand Bioengineering, 37, 755-761
Collins C A, Olsen I, Zammit P S, Heslop L, Petrie A, PartridgeT A, Morgan J E. 2005. Stem cell function, self-renewal,and behavioral heterogeneity of cells from the adult musclesatellite cell niche. Cell, 122, 289-301
Cong C, Chang Y, Deng J, Xiao C, Su Z. 2001. A novel scaleupmethod for mammalian cell culture in packed-bedbioreactor. Biotechnology Letters, 23, 881-885
Cormier J T, Nieden N I Z, Rancourt D E, Kallos M S. 2006.Expansion of undifferentiated murine embryonic stem cellsas aggregates in suspension culture bioreactors. TissueEngineering, 12, 3233-3245
Csete M. 2005. Oxygen in the cultivation of stem cells. Annalsof the New York Academy of Sciences, 1049, 1-8
Egbert R, Borders C. 2006. Achieving success with meatanalogs. Food Technology, 60, 28.
Fluri D A, Tonge P D, Song H, Baptista R P, Shakiba N, Shukla S, Clarke G, Nagy A, Zandstra P W. 2012. Derivation,expansion and differentiation of induced pluripotent stemcells in continuous suspension cultures. Nature Methods,9, 509-516
Goh T, Zhang Z, Chen A, Reuveny S, Choolani M, Chan J K,Oh S K. 2013. Microcarrier culture for efficient expansionand osteogenic differentiation of human fetal mesenchymalstem cells. BioResearch Open Access, 2, 84-97
Grayson W L, Zhao F, Bunnell B, Ma T. 2007. Hypoxiaenhances proliferation and tissue formation of humanmesenchymal stem cells. Biochemical and BiophysicalResearch Communications, 358, 948-953
Grayson W L, Zhao F, Izadpanah R, Bunnell B, Ma T. 2006.Effects of hypoxia on human mesenchymal stem cellexpansion and plasticity in 3D constructs. Journal of CellularPhysiology, 207, 331-339
Greene E, Allen R. 1991. Growth factor regulation of bovinesatellite cell growth in vitro. Journal of Animal Science, 69,146-152
Krawetz R J, Taiani J, Greene A, Kelly G M, Rancourt D E.2011. Inhibition of Rho kinase regulates specification ofearly differentiation events in P19 embryonal carcinomastem cells. PLoS ONE, 6, e26484.
Larijani M R, Seifinejad A, Pournasr B, Hajihoseini V, HassaniS N, Totonchi M, Yousefi M, Shamsi F, Salekdeh GH, Baharvand H. 2011. Long-term maintenance ofundifferentiated human embryonic and induced pluripotentstem cells in suspension. Stem Cells and Development,20, 1911-1923
Luo F, Sun H, Geng T, Qi N. 2008. Application of Taguchi’smethod in the optimization of bridging efficiency betweenconfluent and fresh microcarriers in bead-to-bead transferof Vero cells. Biotechnology Letters, 30, 645-649
Marks D M. 2003. Equipment design considerations for largescale cell culture. Cytotechnology, 42, 21-33
Meuwly F, Ruffieux P A, Kadouri A, Von Stockar U. 2007.Packed-bed bioreactors for mammalian cell culture:Bioprocess and biomedical applications. BiotechnologyAdvances, 25, 45-56
Mitalipova M M, Rao R R, Hoyer D M, Johnson J A, MeisnerL F, Jones K L, Dalton S, Stice S L. 2005. Preserving thegenetic integrity of human embryonic stem cells. NatureBiotechnology, 23, 19-20
Molnar G, Schroedl N A, Gonda S R, Hartzell C R. 1997. Skeletalmuscle satellite cells cultured in simulated microgravity. InVitro Cellular Developmental Biology, 33, 386-391
Neumann T, Hauschka S D, Sanders J E. 2003. Tissueengineering of skeletal muscle using polymer fiber arrays.Tissue Engineering, 9, 995-1003
Ng Y C, Berry J, Butler M. 1996. Optimization of physicalparameters for cell attachment and growth on macroporousmicrocarriers. Biotechnology and Bioengineering, 50,627-635
Oh S K W, Chen A K, Mok Y, Chen X, Lim U M, Chin A,Choo A B H, Reuveny S. 2009. Long-term microcarriersuspension cultures of human embryonic stem cells. StemCell Research, 2, 219-230
Ozturk S, Thrift J, Blackie J, Naveh D. 1997. Real-timemonitoring and control of glucose and lactate concentrationsin a mammalian cell perfusion reactor. Biotechnology andBioengineering, 53, 372-378
Park S, Stephanopoulos G. 1993. Packed bed bioreactor withporous ceramic beads for animal cell culture. Biotechnologyand Bioengineering, 41, 25-34
Park Y, Chen Y, Ordovas L, Verfaillie C M. 2014. Hepaticdifferentiation of human embryonic stem cells onmicrocarriers. Journal of Biotechnology, 174, 39-48.
Persson K M, Karlsson R, Svennersten K, Löffler S, Jager EW, Richter-Dahlfors A, Konradsson P, Berggren M. 2011.Electronic control of cell detachment using a self-dopedconducting polymer. Advanced Materials, 23, 4403-4408
De Peppo G M, Sladkova M, Sjövall P, Palmquist A, Oudina K,Hyllner J, Thomsen P, Petite H, Karlsson C. 2013. Humanembryonic stem cell-derived mesodermal progenitorsdisplay substantially increased tissue formation comparedto human mesenchymal stem cells under dynamic cultureconditions in a packed Bed/Column bioreactor. TissueEngineering (Part A), 19, 175-187
Phillips B W, Horne R, Lay T S, Rust W L, Teck T T, CrookJ M. 2008. Attachment and growth of human embryonicstem cells on microcarriers. Journal of Biotechnology,138, 24-32
Pierce L N, Shabram P. 2004. Scalability of a disposablebioreactor from 25L-500L run in perfusion mode with a CHObasedcell line: A tech review. BioProcessing Journal, 3, 51.
Post M J, Van Der Weele C. 2014. Principles of tissueengineering for food. In: Lanza R, Langer R, Vacanti J P,eds., Principles of Tissue Engineering. 4th ed. Elsevier,Amsterdam.Reuveny S. 1990. Microcarrier culture systems. BioprocessTechnology, 10, 271-341
Rodolfi L, Zittelli G C, Barsanti L, Rosati G, Tredici M R. 2003.Growth medium recycling in Nannochloropsis sp. masscultivation. Biomolecular Engineering, 20, 243-248
Sart S, Agathos S N, Li Y. 2013. Engineering stem cell fate withbiochemical and biomechanical properties of microcarriers.Biotechnology Progress, 29, 1354-1366
Sart S, Schneider Y J, Agathos S N. 2009. Ear mesenchymalstem cells: An efficient adult multipotent cell population fitfor rapid and scalable expansion. Journal of Biotechnology,139, 291-299
Schop D, Janssen F, Borgart E, De Bruijn J, Van Dijkhuizen-Radersma R. 2008. Expansion of mesenchymal stemcells using a microcarrier-based cultivation system: growthand metabolism. Journal of Tissue Engineering andRegenerative Medicine, 2, 126-135
Singh H, Mok P, Balakrishnan T, Rahmat S N B, Zweigerdt R.2010. Up-scaling single cell-inoculated suspension cultureof human embryonic stem cells. Stem Cell Research, 4,165-179
Steiner D, Khaner H, Cohen M, Even-Ram S, Gil Y, ItsyksonP, Turetsky T, Idelson M, Aizenman E, Ram R, Berman Zaken Y, Reubinoff B. 2010. Derivation, propagation andcontrolled differentiation of human embryonic stem cells insuspension. Nature Biotechnology, 28, 361-364
Suemori H, Yasuchika K, Hasegawa K, Fujioka T, TsuneyoshiN, Nakatsuji N. 2006. Efficient establishment of humanembryonic stem cell lines and long-term maintenance withstable karyotype by enzymatic bulk passage. Biochemicaland Biophysical Research Communications, 345, 926-932
Tamura A, Kobayashi J, Yamato M, Okano T. 2012.Temperature-responsive poly(N-isopropylacrylamide)-grafted microcarriers for large-scale non-invasive harvest ofanchorage-dependent cells. Biomaterials, 33, 3803-3812
Tatsumi R, Anderson J E, Nevoret C J, Halevy O, Allen R E.1998. HGF/SF is present in normal adult skeletal muscleand is capable of activating satellite cells. DevelopmentalBiology, 194, 114-128
Torgan C, Burge S, Collinsworth A, Truskey G, Kraus W. 2000.Differentiation of mammalian skeletal muscle cells culturedon microcarrier beads in a rotating cell culture system.Medical and Biological Engineering and Computing, 38,583-590
Troy A, Cadwallader A B, Fedorov Y, Tyner K, Tanaka K K,Olwin B B. 2012. Coordination of satellite cell activationand self-renewal by Par-complex-dependent asymmetricactivation of p38α/β MAPK. Cell Stem Cell, 11, 541-553
Vandenburgh H, Shansky J, Del Tatto M, Chromiak J. 1999.Organogenesis of skeletal muscle in tissue culture. Methodsin Molecular Medicine, 18, 217-225
Wang Y, Ouyang F. 1999a. Bead-to-bead transfer of Verocells in microcarrier culture. Cytotechnology, 31, 221-224
Wang Y, Ouyang F. 1999b. Recycle of Cytodex-3 in Vero cellculture. Bioprocess Engineering, 21, 207-210
Watanabe K, Ueno M, Kamiya D, Nishiyama A, MatsumuraM, Wataya T, Takahashi J B, Nishikawa S, Nishikawa SI, Muguruma K. 2007. A ROCK inhibitor permits survivalof dissociated human embryonic stem cells. NatureBiotechnology, 25, 681-686
Zagari F, Jordan M, Stettler M, Broly H, Wurm F M. 2013.Lactate metabolism shift in CHO cell culture: The role ofmitochondrial oxidative activity. New Biotechnology, 30,238-245
Zhang X, Stettler M, De Sanctis D, Perrone M, Parolini N,Discacciati M, De Jesus M, Hacker D, Quarteroni A, WurmF. 2010. Use of Orbital Shaken Disposable Bioreactors forMammalian Cell Cultures from the Milliliter-Scale to the1,000-Liter Scale. Disposable Bioreactors, Springer.
Zhao F, Pathi P, Grayson W, Xing Q, Locke B R, Ma T. 2005.Effects of oxygen transport on 3-D human mesenchymalstem cell metabolic activity in perfusion and static cultures:Experiments and mathematical model. BiotechnologyProgress, 21, 1269-1280
Zweigerdt R, Olmer R, Singh H, Haverich A, Martin U. 2011.Scalable expansion of human pluripotent stem cells insuspension culture. Nature Protocols, 6, 689-700
