|
|
|
|
|
| Food safety controls in different governance structures in China’s vegetable and fruit industry |
| ZHOU Jie-hong, LI Kai, LIANG Qiao |
| China Academy for Rural Development, School of Management, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310058, P.R.China |
|
|
|
摘要 Food safety issues constitute an international topic discussed by many scholars. Although there is an extensive body of literature on comparisons of food safety control practices across different governance structures, these studies have been conducted mainly in terms of qualitative and descriptive analysis. In addition, little attention has been given to family farms. This study addresses the food safety control practices adopted by firms with different governance structures in China. Food safety control is expressed by the following aspects, i.e., pollution-free, green, organic, and/or geographical indication products certification, establishment of production records, and pesticide residue testing. Three types of governance structures that engage in agricultural production are distinguished: farmer cooperatives, agricultural companies, and family farms. The food safety control practices of various governance structures are investigated based on a database that comprises 600 vegetable and fruit enterprises in Zhejiang, China. The results show that (1) pesticide residue testing is adopted by the most firms, followed by products certification, and production records are adopted by the fewest firms, and (2) agricultural companies adopt more food safety control practices than family farms, while farmer cooperatives adopt the fewest food safety control practices. Governance structure features of a cooperative in terms of ownership, decision-making, and income distribution are the main reasons for the low level of food safety control in the cooperative.
Abstract Food safety issues constitute an international topic discussed by many scholars. Although there is an extensive body of literature on comparisons of food safety control practices across different governance structures, these studies have been conducted mainly in terms of qualitative and descriptive analysis. In addition, little attention has been given to family farms. This study addresses the food safety control practices adopted by firms with different governance structures in China. Food safety control is expressed by the following aspects, i.e., pollution-free, green, organic, and/or geographical indication products certification, establishment of production records, and pesticide residue testing. Three types of governance structures that engage in agricultural production are distinguished: farmer cooperatives, agricultural companies, and family farms. The food safety control practices of various governance structures are investigated based on a database that comprises 600 vegetable and fruit enterprises in Zhejiang, China. The results show that (1) pesticide residue testing is adopted by the most firms, followed by products certification, and production records are adopted by the fewest firms, and (2) agricultural companies adopt more food safety control practices than family farms, while farmer cooperatives adopt the fewest food safety control practices. Governance structure features of a cooperative in terms of ownership, decision-making, and income distribution are the main reasons for the low level of food safety control in the cooperative.
|
|
Received: 10 February 2015
Accepted:
|
| Fund: This research is supported by the National Social Science Fund of China (13AZD079), the Zhejiang Provincial Natural Science Foundation of China (LQ14G030041 and LZ12G03003), and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (71333011 and 71273234). |
|
Corresponding Authors:
LIANG Qiao, Mobile: +86-13575736211,Fax: +86-571-88981522, E-mail: liangqiao2323@126.com
E-mail: liangqiao2323@126.com
|
| About author: ZHOU Jie-hong, E-mail: runzhou@zju.edu.cn; |
Cite this article:
ZHOU Jie-hong, LI Kai, LIANG Qiao.
2015.
Food safety controls in different governance structures in China’s vegetable and fruit industry. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 14(11): 2189-2202.
|
| Arora S, Cason T N. 1995. An experiment in voluntaryenvironmental regulation: Participation in EPA’s 35/50program. Journal of Environmental Economics andManagement, 28, 271-286Baker G, Gibbons R, Murphy K 2008 Strategic alliances:Bridges between “islands of conscious power”. Journal ofthe Japanese and International Economics, 22, 146-163Bijman J, Iliopoulos C, Poppe K J, Gijselinckx C, Hagendorn K,Hanisch M, Hendrikse G W J, Kühl R, Ollila P, PyykkonenP, van der Sangen G. 2012. Support for Farmers’Cooperatives. Wageningen UR, The Netherlands. Bowler I, Clark G, Crockett A, Llbery B, Shaw A. 1996. Thedevelopment of alternative farm enterprises: A study offamily labour farms in the Northern Pennines of England.Journal of Rural Studies, 12, 285-295Caswell J. 1998. How labeling of safety and process attributesaffects markets for food. Agricultural and ResourceEconomics Review, 27, 151-158Chen A, Scott S. 2014. Rural development strategiesand government roles in the development of farmers’cooperatives in China. Journal of Agricultural, FoodSystems, and Community Development, 4, 35-55Chen C, Luo B. 2011. An empirical study of relationalgovernance between Chinese leading agriculturalenterprises and their cooperative farmers. China RuralSurvey, 6, 46-57 (in Chinese)Chen K S, Babb E M, Schrader L F. 1985. Growth of largecooperative and proprietary firms in the US food sector.Agribusiness, 1, 201-210Chen X, Tan Y. 2013. Farmers’ professional cooperativesservices function and its influencing factors based onthe food security - Case of fruit production cooperativesin Guangdong. Journal of Agrotechnical Economics, 1,120-128Damianos D, Skuras D. 1996. Farm business and thedevelopment of alternative farm enterprises: An empiricalanalysis in Greece. Journal of Rural Studies, 12, 273-283Fulton M, Sanderson K. 2002. Co-operatives and farmers inthe new agriculture. Working Paper. Centre for the Studyof Co-operatives, University of Saskatchewan, Canada.Gao Q, Liu T, Kong X. 2013. Institutional analysis on familyfarms: Features, occurrence mechanism and effects.Economist, 6, 48-56Gasson R, Crow G, Errington A, Hutson J, Marsden T E R RY, Winter D M. 1988. The farm as a family business: Areview. Journal of Agricultural Economics, 39, 1-41Golan E, Roberts T, Ollinger M. 2004. Savvy buyers spur foodsafety innovations in meat processing. Amber Waves, 2,22-29Guo X, Liao Z, Fu R. 2007. Comparison of three agriculturalindustrialization models: An analysis based on the theoryof institutional economics. Chinese Rural Economy, 4,40-47 (in Chinese)Hansmann H. 1996. The Ownership of Enterprise. HarvardUniversity Press, Cambridge.Hendrikse G. 1998. Screening, competition and the choiceof the cooperative as an organisational form. Journal ofAgricultural Economics, 49, 202-217Hendrikse G. 2007. On the co-existence of spot and contractmarkets: The delivery requirement as contract externality.European Review of Agricultural Economics, 34, 257-282Hendrikse G. 2011. Pooling, access, and countervailingpower in channel governance. Management Science, 57,1692-2002Henriques I, Sadorsky P. 1996. The determinants of anenvironmental responsive firm: An empirical approach.Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,30, 381-395Henson S, Caswell J. 1999. Food safety regulation: An overviewof contemporary issues. Food Policy, 24, 589-603Henson S, Heasman M. 1998. Food safety regulation and thefirm: Understanding the compliance process. Food Policy,23, 9-23Henson S, Holt G. 2000. Exploring incentives for the adoption offood safety controls: HACCP implementation in the UK dairysector. Review of Agricultural Economics, 22, 407-420Henson S, Loader R, Traill B. 1995. Contemporary food policyissues and the food supply chain. European Review ofAgricultural Economics, 22, 271-281Henson S, Northen J. 1998. Economic determinants of foodsafety controls in supply of retailer own-branded productsin United Kingdom. Agribusiness, 14, 113-126Herath D, Hassan Z, Henson S. 2007. Adoption of foodsafety and quality controls: Do firm characteristics matter?Evidence from the Canadian food processing sector.Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics, 55, 299-314Hill B. 1993. The ‘myth’ of the family farm: Defining the familyfarm and assessing its importance in the EuropeanCommunity. Journal of Rural Studies, 9, 359-370Hoffmann R. 2005. Ownership structure and endogenous qualitychoice: Cooperatives versus investor-owned firms. Journalof Agricultural & Food Industrial Organization, 3, 1-24Holleran E, Bredahl M E, Zaibet L. 1999. Private incentives foradopting food safety and quality assurance. Food Policy,24, 669-683Hu D, Chen Z, Sun Q, Duo T. 2006. The impact of contractfarming models on farmers’ income and food safety: Basedon apple industry in Shandong. Chinese Rural Economy,11, 17-24, 41 (in Chinese)Hua H, Chang X. 2011. Impact of supply chain model onfarmer’s safety production behavior for food quality: Basedon a survey in Jiangsu Province’s main grape producingareas. Journal of Agrotechnical Economics, 9, 108-117Huang P. 2010. New small farm and vertical integration: Leadingcompanies or cooperatives? Rural China, 8, 11-30 (inChinese)Huang P. 2011. China’s new-age small farms and their verticalintegration: Agribusiness or co-ops? Modern China, 37,107-134 (in Chinese)Huang Z, Yu N. 2010. New type agricultural business entities:Current situation, constraints and ideas for the development- An analysis taking Zhejiang Province as an example.Chinese Rural Economy, 10, 16-26 (in Chinese)Jayasinghe-Mudalige U, Henson S. 2007. Identifying economicincentives for Canadian red meat and poultry processingenterprises to adopt enhanced food safety controls. FoodControl, 18, 1363-1371Jia X, Huang J, Xu Z. 2012. Marketing of farmer professionalcooperatives in the wave of transformed agrofood marketin China. China Economic Review, 23, 665-674Jiang K, Han S, Sha Z. 2003. Development of agriculturalcompanies and the effect on farmers’ income: A case studyof Yangzhou City in Jiangsu Province. Issues in Agricultural Economy, 3, 25-29 (in Chinese)Jin S, Zhou J. 2011. Adoption of food safety and qualitystandards by China’s agricultural cooperatives. FoodControl, 2, 204-208Jin S, Zhou J, Ye J. 2008. Adoption of HACCP system inthe Chinese food industry: A comparative analysis. FoodControl, 19, 823-828Karipidis P, Athanassiadis K, Aggelopoulos S, Giompliakis E.2009. Factors affecting the adoption of quality assurancesystems in small food enterprises. Food Control, 20, 93-98Kimhi A, Bollman R. 1999. Family farm dynamics in Canadaand Israel: The case of farm exits. Agricultural Economics,21, 69-79Kong X. 2014. Three problems need to be solved to developfamily farms. Financial Times, Mar. 31. (in Chinese)LeVay C. 1983. Agricultural cooperative theory: A review.Journal of Agricultural Economics, 34, 1-44Liang Q. 2011. The impact of cooperatives on farmers’production income and scale efficiency: Based ontheoretical model and empirical analyses. PhD thesis,Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, China. (in Chinese)Liang Q, Hendrikse W J G. 2013. Core and common membersin the genesis of farmer cooperatives in China. Managerialand Decision Economics, 34, 244-257Liu B. 2013. Study on agricultural products supply chainintegration based on the interests of the peasants andconsumers: Fresh fruits and vegetables in China as anexample. PhD thesis. Shenyang Agricultural University,Shenyang, China. (in Chinese)Liu C, Zhang H, An Y. 2011. Study on weaknesses, rootcauses and key issues of China’s food safety: Based on theempirical analysis of 1 460 food quality safety cases. Issuesin Agricultural Economy, 1, 24-31, 110-111 (in Chinese)Nakamura M, Takahashi T, Vertinsky I 2001. Why Japanesefirms choose to certify? A study of managerial responses toenvironmental issues. Journal of Environmental Economicsand Management, 42, 23-52Narrod C, Roy D, Okello J, Avendaño B, Rich K, Thorat A.2009. Public-private partnerships and collective action inhigh value fruit and vegetable supply chains. Food Policy,34, 8-15Nilsson J. 1998. The emergence of new organizational modelsfor agricultural cooperatives. Swedish Journal of AgriculturalResearch, 28, 39-47Ordóñez H A, Zuurbier P, Senesi S I, Palau H. 2006. Dofood quality assurance systems demand complexgovernance structures? In: The 7th International Conferenceon Management in AgriFood Chains and Networks.Wageningen University, The Netherlands.Peng J. 2011. A research on collaboration mechanism of thesupply of safe agricultural product under the supply chainenvironment - A symbiosis angle of the leading enterpriseand peasant household. Finance & Trade Economics, 3,89-95Peng Y, He P, Shao G. 2005. Construct agricultural companies:From the perspectives of development poles theory. Journalof Zhejiang University (Humanities and Social Sciences),6, 97-104 (in Chinese)Pennerstorfer D, Weiss C R. 2013. Product quality in theagri-food chain: Do cooperatives offer high-quality wine?European Review of Agricultural Economics, 40, 143-162Pollak T A. 1985. A transaction cost approach to families andhouseholds. Journal of Economic Literature, 23, 581-668Pouliot S, Sumner D A. 2008. Traceability, liability, andincentives for food safety and quality. American Journal ofAgricultural Economics, 90, 15-27Ren G, Ge Y. 2008. The mechanism of rural cooperativeorganizations’ affection on the quality and safety ofagricultural products - case of Jiaxing City in ZhejiangProvince. Issues in Agricultural Economy, 9, 61-64 (inChinese)Scott S, Si Z, Schumilas T, Chen A. 2014. Contradictions instate-and civil society-driven developments in China’secological agriculture sector. Food Policy, 45, 158-166Sexton R J. 1984. Perspectives on the development of theeconomic theory of co-operatives. Canadian Journal ofAgricultural Economics, 32, 423-436Sexton R J. 1990. Imperfect competition in agricultural marketsand the role of cooperatives: A spatial analysis. AmericanJournal of Agricultural Economics, 72, 709-720Shao F, Lou D, Kong X. 2012. Who shall serve as the bridgebetween farmers and market, agent, cooperatives, orleading enterprise-A study on the link between productionand sales of agricultural products. Journal of JiangxiAgricultural University Social Science Edition, 2, 1-6 (inChinese)Shavell S. 1987. Economic Analysis of Accident Law.Cambridge, Harvard University Press, MA.Starbird S A. 2000. Designing food safety regulations: The effectof inspection policy and penalties for noncompliance on foodprocessor behavior. Journal of Agricultural and ResourceEconomics, 25, 616-635Sultan T, Wolz A. 2012. Agricultural cooperative developmentin China and Vietnam since decollectivisation: A multistakeholderapproach. Journal of Rural Cooperation, 40,239-257Sun T, Wei J. 2000. An comparative analysis of market, quasienterprise, enterprise in agricultural industrialization:From the perspectives of the evolution of agriculturalorganizations. China Rural Survey, 2, 49-54 (in Chinese)Theodorakopoulou I, Iliopoulos C. 2012. Support for Farmers’Cooperatives: Sector Report Wine. Wageningen,Wageningen UR.Valentinov V. 2007. Why are cooperatives importanti n a g r i c u l t u r e ? A n o r g a n i z a t i o n a l e c o n o m i c sperspective. Journal of Institutional Economics, 3, 55-69Vitaliano P. 1983. Cooperative enterprise: An alternativeconceptual basis for analyzing a complex institution.American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 65, 1078-1083Wang S, Yan C, Li P, Zhang M. 2009. An empirical analysison the behavior of aquatic farming safety: A case study of aquatic corporations in Guangdong Province. Issues inAgricultural Economy, 3, 21-27, 110 (in Chinese)Wei L, Lu G. 2004. The mechanism of food safety controls incooperative: Based on an empirical study of cases fromZhejiang Province. Chinese Rural Economy, 7, 36-40 (inChinese)Xu J, Wang Z, Jiang H. 2013. The operating mechanismanalysis of the quality and safety management of livestockin cooperatives. Chinese Journal of Animal Science, 10,29-32 (in Chinese)Xu X. 2005. Institutional Analysis on Farmer Cooperative inChina. Zhejiang University Press, Hangzhou. (in Chinese)Xu X, Shao K, Liang Q, Guo H, Lu J, Huang Z. 2013. Entry ofChinese small farmers into big markets: From enterpriseledstructures to farmer cooperatives. Chinese Economy,46, 7-19Ye J. 2012. A research of traceability behavior and performanceof quality and safety of pork processing plant: An empiricalanalysis from Zhejiang Province and Jiangxi Province. PhDthesis, Zhejiang University, China. (in Chinese)Zhou J, Hu J. 2009. Food safety controls behavior of vegetableprocessing factories and analysis of the causal factors.Chinese Rural Economy, 3, 45-56 (in Chinese)Zhou J, Jin S. 2009. Safety of vegetables and the use ofpesticides by farmers in China: Evidence from ZhejiangProvince. Food Control, 20, 1043-1048Zhou J, Yan Z. 2014. Understanding farmer cooperatives’ selfinspectionbehavior on guarantee agri-food quality/safety inChina. Paper presented at the 13th Eurasia Business andEconomics Society (EBES) Conference. Istanbul, Turkey. |
| No Suggested Reading articles found! |
|
|
Viewed |
|
|
|
Full text
|
|
|
|
|
Abstract
|
|
|
|
|
Cited |
|
|
|
|
| |
Shared |
|
|
|
|
| |
Discussed |
|
|
|
|
