中国农业科学 ›› 2024, Vol. 57 ›› Issue (1): 142-158.doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2024.01.010

• 土壤肥料·节水灌溉·农业生态环境 • 上一篇    下一篇

硅氧烷类助剂的环境残留及其农用之环境安全风险

王小彬(), 闫湘, 李秀英(), 涂成   

  1. 中国农业科学院农业资源与农业区划研究所,北京 100081
  • 收稿日期:2023-01-10 接受日期:2023-02-27 出版日期:2024-01-01 发布日期:2024-01-10
  • 通信作者:
    李秀英,E-mail:
  • 联系方式: 王小彬,E-mail:wangxiaobin01@caas.cn。
  • 基金资助:
    农业农村部肥料登记专项(2130109)

Environmental Residues of Organosiloxane-Based Adjuvants and Its Environmental Risks for Use as Agrochemical Adjuvants

WANG XiaoBin(), YAN Xiang, LI XiuYing(), TU Cheng   

  1. Institute of Agricultural Resources and Regional Planning, Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Beijing 100081
  • Received:2023-01-10 Accepted:2023-02-27 Published:2024-01-01 Online:2024-01-10

摘要:

硅氧烷类助剂(或有机硅助剂)系硅油类有机硅产品,其结构是以硅氧键为骨架组成的聚硅氧烷,因其具有超强渗透和扩散性能而被广泛用于日化和工业产品等助剂,并作为农用助剂在农业上得到推广使用。当前,我国有机硅制品产销量约200万t,生产和消费量均占世界50%以上,已成为全球最大的有机硅生产、消费和原材料净出口国,聚硅氧烷产能占比已经达到全球60%以上。随着硅氧烷类助剂的广泛应用所导致的硅氧烷环境残留(尤其在水体、污泥/土壤等环境样本中、水生食物链以及人体组织中均被检出)及其对农业生态环境的影响日益暴露,硅氧烷类助剂农用的环境安全性(包括生态毒性及其环境安全风险)也引起诸多关注。近年来,挥发性环甲基环硅氧烷(如D4(八甲基环四硅氧烷)、D5(十甲基环五硅氧烷)和D6(十二甲基环六硅氧烷)等)因其具有环境持久性、生物积累性及潜在毒性等特性而被欧盟等国家认定为新兴有机污染物或被列入优先控制化学品。本文通过对1991年以来国内外公开发表的关于硅氧烷类助剂(包括农用助剂)应用的环境残留及其生态环境安全风险相关文献检索调研,从两个方面综述分析硅氧烷类助剂的环境残留去向及其农用对农业生态环境安全的直接或间接影响,主要包括:(1)硅氧烷的环境残留及其对农业生态环境安全的影响(包括污水处理过程中硅氧烷残留及去向,水体中硅氧烷残留及水生食物链污染风险,污泥中硅氧烷残留及土壤生态污染风险,以及食品中硅氧烷残留及人体健康风险等);(2)硅氧烷类助剂农用现状及环境安全风险(包括硅氧烷类助剂农用后残留及其毒性风险,以及硅氧烷类助剂农用的安全性管理问题)。本文并就国内外对环硅氧烷类产品管理现状及问题进行了探讨。对于硅氧烷类助剂农用,由于助剂成分多被视为“生物惰性”,通常硅氧烷类助剂农用无需毒理检测和环境监管等风险评估;此外,助剂成分往往被声称为“商业机密”而受到保护,其成分一般不会在产品标签上标明。目前,我国对硅氧烷类助剂作为农用助剂(如叶面肥添加剂等)添加使用尚无监管要求,农用助剂添加缺乏安全使用规范,存在环境安全风险。本文针对硅氧烷类农用助剂添加过量可能增加其在土壤-作物-水体中残留及其生态毒性风险,以及对食品安全和人类健康存在潜在威胁等问题,建议有关管理和研究单位进一步重视硅氧烷类助剂使用过程中的残留和去向的监测,尤其加强硅氧烷类农用助剂残留对水体、土壤、动植物生长发育和人体健康影响的研究工作。

关键词: 硅氧烷, 农用助剂, 叶面肥添加剂, 环境安全风险

Abstract:

Organosiloxane-based adjuvant (or organosilicon adjuvant), one of the silicone-fluide products, is polysiloxane, predominantly composed of covalently bonded silicon and oxygen atoms. Organosiloxane-based adjuvants are widely used as additives for daily chemicals and textile products, but also as agrochemical adjuvants in agriculture due to their super spreading and penetrating abilities. At present, China’s production and sales of silicone products have reached above 2 million tons, accounting for more than 50% of the world’s total amount. China has become the world’s largest producer, consumer and net exporter of raw materials of silicone, and the production capacity of polysiloxane has reached more than 60% of the world’s total. As organosiloxane residues detected in environment (especially in water, sludge/soil and other environmental samples, aquatic food chain, as well as human tissues), their impacts on agricultural ecological environment are increasingly exposed due to the widely application of organosiloxane-based adjuvants, while the environmental risks from silicone-based agrochemical adjuvants, including ecotoxicity and environmental safety risks, have also attracted great concern. In recent years, volatile cyclomethylcyclosiloxanes (such as D4 (octamethylcyclotetrasiloxane), D5 (decamethylcyclopentasiloxane) and D6 (dodecylcyclohexasiloxane)) have been recognized as emerging organic pollutants, or listed as priority controlled chemicals by EU and other countries, because of their environmental persistence, bioaccumulation and potential toxicity. Based on the relevant scientific research literatures published since 1991 on the environmental residues of organosiloxane-based adjuvants and the ecological environmental safety risks in the use of organosiloxane-based adjuvant (including organosiloxane-based agrochemical adjuvants), this paper reviewed and analyzed the environmental residues of organosiloxane-based adjuvants, and their impacts directly or indirectly on agricultural ecological environmental safety. This review mainly focused on the following two aspects: (1) the organosiloxane residues in environment and their impacts on the agricultural ecological environment safety, including organosiloxane residues and fates in the process of wastewater treatment, aquatic food chain pollution risks from organosiloxane residues in water, soil ecological pollution risks from organosiloxane residues in sludge, and human health risks from organosiloxane residues in food; (2) the current situation and environmental safety risks for the use of organosiloxane-based agrochemical adjuvants, including organosiloxane residues and ecotoxicity risks from siloxane-based agrochemical adjuvants, and the management for the use of organosiloxane-based agrochemical adjuvants. This paper also discussed the management status and problems associated with siloxane-based products. For organosiloxane as agrochemical adjuvants, organosiloxane-based adjuvants were largely assumed to be “biologically inert”, and usually no risk assessment (such as ecotoxicity test and environmental monitoring) was required. Also, the adjuvant inert ingredients were generally protected as “trade-secrets” or confidential business information, and the inert ingredients were rarely identified on product labels. At present, there are no regulatory requirements for the use of organosilicone-based adjuvants in fertilizer products as agrochemical adjuvants (such as foliar fertilizer additives) in China, posing potential environmental safety risks. This paper discussed that over-addition with organosiloxane-based agrochemical adjuvants might increase their residues in soil-crop-water systems, and their ecotoxicity risks, as well as potential threats to food safety and human health. It is suggested that relevant management and research units need to pay more attention to environmental monitoring for organosiloxane residues and fates in the application process of organosiloxane-based adjuvants, and especially strengthen the research on the impacts of organosiloxane residues from organosiloxane-based agrochemical adjuvants on water, soil, animal and plant growth, as well as human health.

Key words: organosiloxanes (silicones), agrochemical adjuvants, foliar fertilizer additives, environmental safety risks