中国农业科学 ›› 2015, Vol. 48 ›› Issue (13): 2622-2634.doi: 10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2015.13.014

• 畜牧·兽医·资源昆虫 • 上一篇    下一篇

基于文献计量的世界家畜种业科技创新研究态势分析

魏珣,贾敬敦,孙康泰,葛毅强   

  1. 中国农村技术开发中心,北京 100045
  • 收稿日期:2014-11-19 出版日期:2015-07-01 发布日期:2015-07-01
  • 通讯作者: 葛毅强,E-mail:68511009@163.com
  • 作者简介:魏珣,E-mail:weix@crtdc.org.cn
  • 基金资助:
    中国工程院咨询项目

A Bibliometric Analysis on Technology Innovation of Livestock Breeding

WEI Xun, JIA Jing-dun, SUN Kang-tai, GE Yi-qiang   

  1. China Rural Technology Development Centre, Beijing 100045
  • Received:2014-11-19 Online:2015-07-01 Published:2015-07-01

摘要: 【目的】通过文献和专利对比分析世界家畜种业科技创新态势,总结家畜种业领域的研究历史,挖掘研究热点和前沿,为家畜种业科技工作者和决策部门提供参考依据。【方法】基于Science Citation Index和Derwent Innovation Index数据库,采用文献计量学方法,采集整理了1964—2014年间的世界家畜遗传育种研究相关的文献和专利,借助Thomson Data Analyzer,Thomson Innovation,OSviewer等工具进行分析。【结果】从发文年代看,家畜育种研究经历了三个阶段:1960—1990年是研究起步和缓慢发展阶段,主要通过性能测定估值育种;1990—2000年研究进入快速增长期,最佳线性无偏预测(best linear unbiased prediction, BLUP)育种、人工受精、超数排卵和胚胎移植等技术得到推广应用;2000年至今,技术发展更为迅猛,性别控制、分子标记及基因组选择等技术为家畜种业发展注入了强劲动力。专利检索结果表明,1964—1997年专利申请量缓慢增长,1998年出现激增并将势头保持到2001年,但专利申请近10年来处于增长波动期。从国别和机构情况来看,美国在全球家畜育种技术研发方面始终占据绝对优势,无论是论文发文量、被引频次还是专利申请量均遥遥领先,欧洲发达国家和日本也长期占据领先地位;中国近些年来发展迅速,特别是在专利申请和获得方面逆势增长,但从篇均被引情况看,研究质量有待提高;美国有10家机构进入专利申请量前20位且都为企业;中国有4家机构进入前20位,全部为高校,在中国以企业为主体的创新体制还未建立。按照物种和技术领域分析,从20世纪90年代起,牛的研究发展迅速,并得到广泛重视;而猪的研究则在2000年之后赶超,成为研究进展最快的物种;羊的研究也发展迅速,呈现持续增长;马的研究进展略显缓慢,而驴和骆驼的研究则很少。繁育技术研究起步较早,发表论文数量最多,但其发展趋势波动较大,自20世纪90年代性别控制技术达到鼎盛时期后,近年来一直震荡下行;组学技术在2000年各物种基因草图相继完成后,研究文章迅速增加,并推动了蛋白组、转录组、甲基化组、代谢组等各组学研究快速发展;遗传操作技术从1991年后,单基因转移、基因敲除敲入和基因打靶等技术逐渐建立,生物反应器成为遗传操作技术的重要研发目标,2004年后TALEN、CRISPR/Cas9等基因组编辑新技术不断出现并逐渐发展成熟,使该领域发展速度明显加快;1991年后,遗传标记逐步由蛋白标记进入到DNA分子标记,2004年后由于标记类型的增加和SNP标记的推广应用,基于分子标记的标记辅助育种技术发展迅速,并逐渐向全基因组选择方向快速发展,把精准育种技术研究推向新的高潮,2008年后超过繁育技术成为本领域最集中的研究热点。【结论】猪和牛仍然是主要研究对象,以全基因组选择为代表的精准育种技术成为当前研究的焦点。美国在本领域有着突出的领先地位,德、英、法、日等发达国家也有着较好的研究基础和专利申请情况,中国的相关研究在近些年来发展迅猛,甚至有赶超之势,但研究质量仍需加强。

关键词: 家畜, 遗传育种, 文献计量分析, 研究态势

Abstract: 【Objective】In order to summarize the research history, understand the frontiers and focus and provide a sound foundation for researchers and policy-makers, the comparative analysis of world literature and patents about technology innovation of livestock was carried out. 【Method】Based on Science Citation Index and Derwent Innovation Index database, with bibliometric methods, relevant literature and patents on livestock breeding during the years of 1964 and 2014 were collected. Thomson Data Analyzer, Thomson Innovation, OSviewer and other tools were used. 【Result】Studies on livestock breeding technology have gone through three stages: the start-up and slowly developing phase lasted from 1960 to 1990, focusing on performance determination evaluation; the rapid growth phase lasted from 1990 to 2000, with the wide use of BLUP breeding, artificial insemination, superovulation and embryo transfer technology,the leaping forward phase began in 2000 till now, gender control technology; molecular markers and genomic selection technology boost the development of research, but the patent application experienced fluctuations in the past decade. The United States possesses the prominent capability in the field all over the world, reflected by the amount of paper issued, citations, and European developed countries and Japan have long occupied a leading position while research from China go through a rapid development in recent years, particularly in terms of patents, but the quality of Chinese research needs to be improved according to the average citation. Ten out of top 20 patent applicators are from US, all of which are enterprises while China has 4 universities and institutions in the top 20, indicating that innovation system with the enterprises as the mainstay has not been established in China. Cattle and pigs have been the focus in the field. Research on cattle developed in 1990’s, but was catch up by that on pig after 2000; and research on sheep has a rapid and consistent growth while that the development on horse was slow; finally, research on donkey and camel was always relatively rare. Research about propagation techniques started earlier, with the largest number of literature, but the trend showed greater volatility even in shock down in recent years after the heyday of sex control technology during 1990’s; research on genomics techniques increased rapidly after the completion of gene draft of certain species in 2000, promoting the development of proteome, transcriptome, methylation group and metabolomics group; genetic manipulation techniques transferred from the study of single gene transfer, gene knockout and knock-in, gene targeting technology to bioreactor technology since 1991, and transferred further to TALEN technology, genome editing technology after 2004. Genetic marker technology, as the key of precision breeding, developed from protein level to DNA molecular level since 1991, grew rapidly after 2004 due to the increasing of maker types and the application of SNP marker, and after 2008, the precision breeding technology became the most focused area instead of propagation techniques.【Conclusion】Pigs and cattle are still the main objects of study, precision breeding technique now has become the main method of current research represented by whole genome selection, and nucleic acid assay or test methods are the main directions of patent applications. The United States in this field has outstanding leadership, while Germany, Britain, France, Japan and other developed countries also have a good research base and patent applications situation. The research in China is developing rapidly in recent years, and even has the opportunity of catching up; however, the quality of research still needs to be strengthened.