Pork Meat Quality of Preto Alentejano and Commercial Largewhite Landrace Cross

doi:10.1016/S2095-3119(13)60634-6

摘要/Abstract

摘要： This work aimed to evaluate the physical-chemical characteristics of pork from a local breed (Portuguese black pork called Preto Alentejano) and a commercial breed. Sixteen animals were used, 4 females and 4 males from each breed. Animals had 80-100 kg of live weight. The longissimus muscle between the 5th thoracic vertebra and the 10th lumbar vertebra was used in the analysis. Samples were analysed for protein, fat, pigments, ashes, dry mater, water-holding capacity, and texture. Results of fat and pigments contents indicate significant (P<0.05 and P<0.01) differences for all treatments. For protein, ashes, dry mater, water-holding capacity and texture, no significant differences were found for sex. In the analysis of fatty acids composition, ten were detected, being the main ones C16:0, C18:0, C16:1, C18:1, C18:2. There was a predominance of monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFA), followed by saturated (SFA) and polyunsaturated (PUFA). Differences were significant for sex (P<0.01) and breed (P<0.01). Preto Alentejano breed and females presented the higher percentages of SFA (P<0.01) and MUFA (P<0.001) fatty acids. Differences between breeds might be due to breed production system and feed differences.

关键词: breed , sex , pork , meat , quality

Abstract: This work aimed to evaluate the physical-chemical characteristics of pork from a local breed (Portuguese black pork called Preto Alentejano) and a commercial breed. Sixteen animals were used, 4 females and 4 males from each breed. Animals had 80-100 kg of live weight. The longissimus muscle between the 5th thoracic vertebra and the 10th lumbar vertebra was used in the analysis. Samples were analysed for protein, fat, pigments, ashes, dry mater, water-holding capacity, and texture. Results of fat and pigments contents indicate significant (P<0.05 and P<0.01) differences for all treatments. For protein, ashes, dry mater, water-holding capacity and texture, no significant differences were found for sex. In the analysis of fatty acids composition, ten were detected, being the main ones C16:0, C18:0, C16:1, C18:1, C18:2. There was a predominance of monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFA), followed by saturated (SFA) and polyunsaturated (PUFA). Differences were significant for sex (P<0.01) and breed (P<0.01). Preto Alentejano breed and females presented the higher percentages of SFA (P<0.01) and MUFA (P<0.001) fatty acids. Differences between breeds might be due to breed production system and feed differences.

Key words: breed , sex , pork , meat , quality

Alfredo Teixeira , S, ra Rodrigues. Pork Meat Quality of Preto Alentejano and Commercial Largewhite Landrace Cross[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2013, 12(11): 1961-1971.

Alfredo Teixeira , S , ra Rodrigues. Pork Meat Quality of Preto Alentejano and Commercial Largewhite Landrace Cross[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2013, 12(11): 1961-1971.

参考文献

[1]Alberti P, Panea B, Ripoll G, Sañudo C, Olleta J L,Hegueruela I, Campo M M, Serra X. 2005. Medición delcolor. In: Cañeque V, Sañudo C, eds., Estandarizaciónde las Metodologías Para Evaluar la Calidad delProducto (animal vivo, canal, carne y grasa). INIA,Spanish. pp. 216-225

[2](in Spanish)Alonso V, Campo M, Español S, Roncalés P, Beltrán J A.2008. Effect of crossbreeding and gender on meat qualityand fatty acid composition. Meat Science, 81, 209-217

[3]Asghar A, Lin C F, Gray J I, Buckley D J, Booren A,Flegal C J. 1990. Effect of dietary oils and tocopherolsupplementation on membranal lipid oxidation in broilermeat. Journal of Food Science, 55, 46-50

[4]Bañón S, Gil M D, Garrido M D. 2003. The effects of castration on the eating quality of dry-cured ham. MeatScience, 65, 1031-1037

[5]Bales C W, Moreno K L, Guyton J R, Yunker P A, McGeeM K, Currie K L, Brown S, Kuchibhatla M, DreznerM K. 1998. Comparison of proximate composition andfatty acid and cholesterol content of lean and typicalcommercial pork. Journal of the American DieteticAssociation, 98, 1328-1331

[6]Bendall J R. 1984. El estimulo elétrico de las canales de losanimales de abasto. In: Lawrie R A, ed., Avances de laCiência de la Carne. Acribia, Zaragoza. pp. 57-83

[7](inSpanish)Benito J, Vázquez C, Menaya C, Ferrera J L, García CascoJ M, Silió L, Rodrigañez J, Rodríguez M C. 1998.Evolución de los parámetros productivos en distintaslíneas de cerdo Ibérico. In: IV Simposio Internacional delCerdo Mediterráneo. Universidade de Évora, Portugal.(in Spanish)

[8]Batallé S, Reixach J, Gispert M, Tibau J. 1995. Estimacionde parametros geneticos de calidad de canal y grasaintramuscular en raza Duroc. International Test andEvaluation Association, 16, 354-356 (in Spanish)

[9]Bidanel J P, Bonneau M, Pointillart A, Gruand J, MourotJ, Demade I. 1991. Effects of exogenous porcinesomatotropin (pST) administrat ion on growthperformance, carcass and pork meat quality of Meishan,Pietrain, and crossbred gilts. Journal of Animal Science69, 3511-3522

[10]Bragagnolo N, Rodriguez-Amaya D B. 1995. Teores decolesterol em carne suína e bovina e efeito do cozimento.Ciência e Tecnologia de Alimentos, 15, 11-17

[11]Bragagnolo N, Rodriguez-Amaya D B. 2002a. Teores decolesterol, lipídeos totais e ácidos graxos em cortes decarne suína. Ciência e Tecnologia de Alimentos, 22, 98-104

[12](in Portuguese)Bragagnolo N, Rodriguez-Amaya D B. 2002b. Simultaneousdetermination of total lipid, cholesterol and fatty acidsin meat and backfat of sucking and adult pigs. FoodChemistry, 79, 255-260

[13]Bryhni E A, Kjos N P, Obstad R, Hunt M. 2002.Polyunsaturated and fish oil in diets for growingfinishingpigs: effects on fatty acid composition andmeat, fat and sausage quality. Meat Science, 62, 1-8

[14]Buege D R, Ingham B H, Henderson D W, Watters SH, Boerchert L L, Crump P M, Hentges E J. 1998.A nationwide audit of the composition of pork andpoultrycuts and retails of Wisconsin-Madison. Journal ofFood Composition and Analysis, 11, 249-261

[15]Cameron N D, Enser M B. 1991. Fatty acid composition oflipid in Longissimus dorsi muscle of Duroc and BritishLandrace pigs and its relationship with eating quality.Meat Science, 29, 295-307

[16]Cameron N D, Warris P D, Porter S J, Enser M B. 1990.Comparison of Duroc and British landrace pigs for meatand eating quality. Meat Science, 27, 227-247

[17]Cameron N D, Enser M, Nute G R, Whittngton F M,Penmann J C, Fisken A C, Perry A M, Wood J D.2000. Genotype with nutrition interaction on fatty acidcomposition of intramuscular fat and the relationshipwith flavour of pig meat. Meat Science, 55, 187-195

[18]Carvalho M. 2003. Influência do sexo e peso de abatena quantidade de carne e na composição lipídica emlinhagens comerciais de suíno. Dissertação apresentada àFaculdade de Engenharia de Alimentos da UniversidadeEstadual de Campinas para obtenção do título de Mestreem Alimentos e Nutrição. (in Portuguese)

[19]Cisneros F, Ellis M, McKeith F K, McCaw J, Fernando RL. 1996. Influence of slaughter weight on growth andcarcass characteristics, commercial cutting and curingyields, and meat quality of barrows and gilts from twogenotypes. Journal of Animal Science, 74, 925-933

[20]Danielsen V, Hansen L L, Moller F, Bejerholm C, Nielsen S.2000. Production results and sensory meat quality of pigsfeed different amounts of concentrate and ad libitum.Clover-grass or clover grass silage. In: Hermansen J E,Lund V, Thuen E, eds., Ecological Animal Husbandaryin the Nordic Countries. Darcof Report. vol. 2. pp. 79-86

[21]Edwards S A. 2005. Product quality attributes associatedwith outdoor pig production. Livestock ProductionScience, 94, 5-14

[22]Enfält A C, Lundström K, Hansson I, Lundeheim N,Nyström P E. 1997. Effects of outdoor rearing and sirebreed (Duroc or Yorkshire) on carcass composition andsensory and technological meat quality. Meat Science,45, 1-15

[23]Enser K H, Hallet B H, Fursey G A J, Wood J D. 1996.Fatty acid content and composition of english beef,lamb, and pork at retail. Meat Science, 42, 443-456

[24]Estévez M, Morcuende D, Cava R. 2006. Extensively rearedIberian pigs versus intensively reared white pigs for themanufacture of frankfurters. Meat Science, 72, 356-364

[25]Fernandez X, Monin G, Talman A, Mourot F, Lebret B.1999. Influence of intramuscular fat on the quality ofpig meat - 2. Consumer acceptability of m. longissimuslumborum. Meat Science, 53, 67-72

[26]Fischer K, Lindler J P, Judas M, Höreth R. 2006b.Schlachtkörperzusammensetzung und gewebebeschaffenheitvon schweren schweinen. II. mitteilung:merkmale der fleisch- und fettqualität. Archiv fürTierzucht, 49, 279-292 (in German)

[27]Franci O, Bozzi R, Pugliese C, Acciaioli A, Campodoni G,Gandini G. 2005. Performance of Cinta Senese pigs andtheir crosses with Large White. 1. Muscle and subcutaneousfat characteristics. Meat Science, 69, 545-550

[28]Galián M, Peinado B, Martínez C, Periago M J, Ros G, PotoA. 2005. Descripción de la composición mineral y otrosparámetros de calidad del músculo Longisimus dorsi delcerdo Chato Murciano en pureza y cruzado con cerdoLarge White, en condiciones de explotación outdoor.In: Anales de Veterinaria de Murcia 21. Ediciones de laUniversidad de Murcia, Spain. pp. 127-138 (in Spanish)

[29]Galián M, Peinado B, Martínez C, Periago M J, Ros G, PotoA. 2007. Comparative study of the characteristics of the carcass and the meat of the Chato Murciano pig and itscross with Iberian pig, reared indoors. Animal ScienceJournal, 78, 659-667

[30]Hansen L L, Claudi-Magnussen C, Jensen S K, AndersenH J. 2006. Effect of organic pig production system onperformance and meat quality. Meat Science, 74, 605-615

[31]Honikel K O. 1998. Reference methods for the assessmentof physical characteristics of meat. Meat Science, 49,447-457

[32]Hornsey H C. 1956. The colour of cooked cured pork.I-Estimation of the nitric oxide-haem pigments. Journalof the Science of Food and Agriculture, 7, 534-540

[33]Hovenier R, Kanis E, van Asseldonk T, Westerink N G.1992. Genetic parameters of pig meat quality traits ina halothane negative population. Livestock ProductionScience, 32, 309-321

[34]Jiménez G. 2007. Características de la canal y calidad de lacarne, composición mineral y lipídica del cerdo ChatoMurciano y su cruce con Ibérico. Efecto del sistema demanejo. PhD thesis, Universidad de Murcia, Spain. (inSpanish)Kim I S, Jin S K, Kim C W, Song Y M, Cho K K, ChungK H. 2008. The effects of pig breeds on proximate,physicochemical, cholesterol, amino acid, fatty acid andsensory properties of loins. Journal of Animal Scienceand Technology (Kor.), 50, 121-132

[35]Küchenmeister U, Kuhn G, Ender K. 2005. Preslaughterhandling of pigs and the effect on heart rate, meatquality, including tenderness, and sarcoplasmicreticulum Ca2+ transport. Meat Science, 71, 690-695

[36]Latorre M A, Lázaro R, Gracia M I, Nieto M, Mateos GG. 2003. Effect of sex and terminal sire genotype onperformance, carcass characteristics, and meat quality ofpigs slaughtered at 117 kg body weight. Meat Science,65, 1369-1377

[37]Lebret B, Massabie P, Granier R, Juin H, Mourot J,Chevillon P. 2002. Influence of outdoor rearing andindoor temperature on growth performance, carcass,adipose tissue and muscle traits in pigs, and on thetechnological and eating quality of dry-cured hams.Meat Science, 62, 447-455

[38]Lloveras M R, Goenaga P R, Irureta M, Carduza F, GrigioneG, Garcia P T, Amendola A. 2008. Meat quality traits ofcomercial hybrid pigs in Argentina. Meat Science, 79,458-462

[39]Lo L L, McLaren D G, McKeith F K, Fernando R L,Novakofsk J. 1992. Genetic analysis of growth, realtime ultrasound, carcass, and pork quality traits in Durocand Landrace pigs: I. breed effects. Journal of AnimalScience, 70, 2373-2386

[40]Magowan E, Moss B, Fearom A, Ball E. 2011. Effectof Breed, Finish Weight and Sex on Pork Meat andEating Quality and Fatty Acid Profile. Agri-Food andBioscience Institute, UK. p. 28.Matos C A P. 2000. Recursos genéticos animais e sistemasde exploração tradicionais em Portugal. Archivos deZootecnia, 49, 363-383

[41](in Portuguese)Mitchaothai J, Yuangklang C, Wittayakun S, Vasupen K,Wongsutthavas S, Srenanul P, Hovenier R, Everts H,Beynen A C. 2007. Effect of dietary fat type on meatquality and fatty acid composition of various tissues ingrowing-finishing swine. Meat Science, 76, 95-101

[42]Monin G, Hortós M, Diaz I, Rock E, Garcia-Regueiro JA. 2003. Lipolysis and lipid oxidation during chilledstorage of meat from Large White and Pietrain pigs.Meat Science, 64, 7-12

[43]Monroy M P. 2007. Pork meat quality evaluation fromhyperspectral evaluation. MSc thesis, McGill UniversityMontreal, Quebec, Canada.Monroy M, Prasher S, Ngadi M O, Wang N, Karimi Y.2010. Pork meat quality classification using visible/nearinfraredspectroscopic data. In: Biosystems Engineering.vol. 107, issue 3. pp. 271-276

[44]Monziols M, Bonneau M, Davenel A, Kouba M. 2007.Comparison of the lipid content and fatty acid compositionof intermuscular and subcutaneous adipose tissues in pigcarcasses. Meat Science, 76, 54-60

[45]Mörlein D. 2005. Bestimmung des intramuskulärenfettgehaltes (IMF) im M. longissimus von SchweinenMittels Ultraschalspektralanalyse. PhD thesis,Universität Göttingen. p. 113. (in German)

[46]Moss M, Hoelden J M, Ono K, Cross R, Slover H, BerryB, Lanza E, Thompson R, Wolf W, Vanderslice J, et al.1983. Nutrient composition of fresh retail pork. Journalof Food Science, 48, 1767-1771

[47]Moss B W, Millar S J, Kilpatrick D J. 2000. The use ofdiscriminant analysis for the interpretation of thereflectance spectra of irradiated porcine M. longissimusdorsi. Meat Science, 55, 337-348

[48]Muriel E, Ruiz J, Ventanas J, Antequera T. 2004. Freerangerearing increases (n-3) polyunsaturated fattyacids of neutral and polar lipids in swine muscles FoodChemistry, 78, 219-225

[49]Nilzén V, Babol J, Dutta P C, Lundeheim N, Enfalt AC, Lundstrom K. 2001. Free range rearing of pigswith access to pasture grazing - effect on fatty acidcomposition and lipid oxidation products. Meat Science,58, 267-275

[50]Norma Portuguesa da carne e derivados de produtos cárneosMP 1612/2002, do Instituto Português de Qualidade. (inPortuguese)Norma Portuguesa da carne e derivados de produtos cárneosMP 1615/2002, do Instituto Português de Qualidade. (inPortuguese)Norma Portuguesa da carne e derivados de produtos cárneosMP 1616/2002, do Instituto Português de Qualidade. (inPortuguese)Nuernberg K, Fischer K, Nuernberg G, Kuechenmeister U,Klosowska D, Eliminowska-Wenda G, Fiedler I, EnderK. 2005. Effects of dietary olive and linseed oil on lipidcomposition, meat quality, sensory characteristics andmuscle structure in pigs. Meat Science, 70, 63-74

[51]Offer G, Knight P. 1988. The structural basis of waterholdingin meat; part 2: drip losses. In: Lawrie R, ed.,Developments in Meat Science. vol. 4. Elsevier SciencePublishers, New York. pp. 173-241

[52]Olivares A, Daza A, Rey A I, Lopez-Bote C J. 2008.Interactions between genotype, dietary fat saturation andvitamin A concentration on intramuscular fat content andfatty acid composition in pigs. Meat Science, 82, 6-12

[53]Persson J, Stina F M. 1986. Carcass Properties as Relatedto Sensory Properties of Pork. Springer-Verlag Ibérica,Barcelona. p. 180.Poto A, Galián M, Peinado B. 2007. Chato murciano pigand its crosses with iberian and large white pigs, rearedoutdoors. Comparative study of the carcass and meatcharacteristics. Livestock Science, 111, 96-103

[54]Poto A. 2003. Estudio de la Calidad de la Canal Y de laCarne Del Cerdo Chato Murciano. PhD thesis, Facultadde Veterinaria, Universidad de Murcia, España. (inSpanish)

[55]Pugliese C, Bozzi R, Campodoni G, Acciaioli A, FranciO, Gandini G. 2004a. Performance of cinta senese pigsreared outdoors and indoors 1. Meat and subcutaneousfat characteristics. Meat Science, 69, 459-464

[56]Pugliese C, Calagna G, Chiofalo V, Moretti V M, MargiottaS, Franci O. 2004b. Comparison of the performancesof Nero Siciliano pigs reared indoors and outdoors: 2.Joints composition, meat and fat traits. Meat Science, 68,523-528

[57]Raimondi R, de María C, Auxilia M A, Masoero G. 1975.Effetto della grassatura dei mangini sulla produzionedella carne di comglio III. Contenuto in acidi grasdelle carni e del grasso perirenale. Annali dell InstitutoSperimentale per la Zootechnia, 8, 167-181

[58](in Italian)Ramírez R, Cava R. 2007. Carcass composition and meatquality of three different Iberian×Duroc genotype pigs.Meat Science, 75, 388-396

[59]Reixach J. 2004. TB-Duroc: La Calidad de la Carne. [2008-10-16] http://www.batalle.com (in Spanish)

[60]Renaudeau D, Mourot J. 2007. A comparison of carcass andmeat quality characteristics of Creole and Large Whitepigs slaughtered at 90 kg BW. Meat Science, 76, 165-171

[61]Rhee K S, Ziprin Y A, Ordenez G, Bohac C E. 1988.Fatty acid profiles of the total lipids oxidation in porkmuscles as affected by canola oil in the diet and musclelocalization. Meat Science, 23, 201-210

[62]Riëtte L J M, van Laack, Spencer E. 1999. Influenceof swine genotype on fatty acid composition ofphospholipids in longissimus muscle. Journal of AnimalScience, 77, 1742-1745

[63]Rosenvold K, Andersen H J. 2003. Factors of significancefor pork quality: a review. Meat Science, 64, 219-237

[64]Sather A P, Jones S D M, Schaefer A L, Colyn J, RobertsonW M. 1997. Feedlot performance, carcass compositionand meat quality of freerange reared pigs. CanadianJournal of Animal Science, 77, 225-232

[65]Serra X, Gil F, Pérez-Enciso J, Oliver M A, Vázquez JM, Gispert M, Díaz I, Moreno F, Latorre R, NogueraJ L. 1998. A comparison of carcass, meat quality andhistological characteristics of Iberian (Guadyerbas line)and Landrace pigs. Livestock Production Science, 56,215-223

[66]Seuss I. 1990 The nutritional value of meat and meatproducts. Fleischwirtsch, 70, 1444-1447

[67]Solis M, de Pedro E, Garrido A, García J, Silió L, RodríguezC, Rodrigáñez J. 2001. Evaluación de la composicióndel lomo del cerdo Ibérico mediante la tecnología NIRS.ITEA, Producción Animal, Extra(22 (II)), 613-615 (in Spanish)

[68]de Smet S, Raes K, Demeyer D. 2004. Meat fatty acidcomposition as affected by fatness and genetic factors: areview. Animal Research, 53, 81-98

[69]Tang Z, Peng Z, Liu B, Fan B, Zhao S, Li X, Xu S, Li K.2008. Effect of breed, sex and birth parity on growth,carcass and meat quality in pigs. Frontiers of Agriculturein China, 2, 331-337

[70]Teye G A, Sheard P R, Whittington F M, Nute G R, StewartA, Wood J D. 2006. Influence of dietary oils and proteinlevel on pork quality. 1. Effects on muscle fatty acidcomposition, carcass, meat and eating quality. MeatScience, 73, 157-165

[71]Warmants N, van Oeckel M J, Boucqué Ch V. 1996.Incorporation of dietary polyunsaturated fatty acidsin pork tissues and its implications for quality of endproducts. Meat Science, 44, 125-144

[72]Warner R D, Kauffman R G, Greaser M L. 1997. Muscleprotein changes post morten in relation to pork qualitytraits. Meat Science, 45, 339-352

[73]Wood J D, Enser M. 1997. Factors influencing fatty acidsin meat and the role of antioxidants in improving meatquality. British Journal of Nutrition, 78, S49-S60.

[74]Wood J D, Nute G R, Richardson R I, Whittington F M,Southwood O, Plastow G, Mansbridge R, da Costa N,Chang K C. 2004. Effects of breed, diet and muscle onfat deposition and eating quality in pigs. Meat Science,67, 651-667

[75]Wood J D, Richardson R I, Nute G R, Fisher A V, CampoM M, Kasapidou E, Sheard P R, Enser M. 2003. Effectsof fatty acids on meat quality: a review. Meat Science,66, 21-32

[76]Wood J D, Jones R C D, Francombe M A, Wheleham O P.1986. The effects of fat thickness and sex on pig meatquality with special reference to the problems associatedwith over-leanness. 2. Laboratory and trained taste panelresults. Animal Production, 43, 535-544

[77]Yu K, Shu G, yuan F, Zhu X, Gao P, Wang S, WangL, Xi Q, Zhang S, Zhang Y, et al. 2013. Fatty acidand transcriptome profiling of longissimus dorsimuscles between pig breeds differing in meat quality.International Journal of Biological Sciences, 9, 108-118

[78]Zhang S, Knight T J, Stalder K J, Goodwin R N, Lonergan SM, Beitz D C. 2007. Effects of breed, sex and halothanegenotype on fatty acid composition of pork longissimusmuscle. Journal of Animal Science, 85, 583-591