Economic evaluation of agricultural pollution control options for China

doi:10.1016/S2095-3119(14)60988-6

摘要/Abstract

摘要： Environmental sustainability has become a policy priority in China. In agriculture, China has had major success in rehabilitating desertified lands through programs to convert steeply-sloped cropland to forest and limit grazing on sensitive grasslands. However, little has been done in terms of policies for agricultural nutrient management. Runoff and leaching of nutrients in chemical fertilizers and livestock manure are widely acknowledged as significant problems in China. This paper presents an evaluation of agricultural nonpoint pollution control options for China. Options analyzed include design standards (command & control), performance standards, and design and performance incentives. Evaluation criteria include economic efficiency and effectiveness, environmental impact and risk, and social criteria such as equity and food security. The evaluation indicates that the best options for China involve subsidies to farmers for changing production practices in order to reduce nonpoint emissions, combined with appropriate farmer education and technical assistance.

关键词: nonpoint pollution , agriculture , water quality , policy evaluation , China

Abstract: Environmental sustainability has become a policy priority in China. In agriculture, China has had major success in rehabilitating desertified lands through programs to convert steeply-sloped cropland to forest and limit grazing on sensitive grasslands. However, little has been done in terms of policies for agricultural nutrient management. Runoff and leaching of nutrients in chemical fertilizers and livestock manure are widely acknowledged as significant problems in China. This paper presents an evaluation of agricultural nonpoint pollution control options for China. Options analyzed include design standards (command & control), performance standards, and design and performance incentives. Evaluation criteria include economic efficiency and effectiveness, environmental impact and risk, and social criteria such as equity and food security. The evaluation indicates that the best options for China involve subsidies to farmers for changing production practices in order to reduce nonpoint emissions, combined with appropriate farmer education and technical assistance.

Key words: nonpoint pollution , agriculture , water quality , policy evaluation , China

David Abler. Economic evaluation of agricultural pollution control options for China[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2015, 14(6): 1045-1056.

参考文献

Abler D. 2004. Multifunctionality, agricultural policy, andenvironmental policy. Agricultural and Resource EconomicsReview, 33, 8-17

Borisova T, Shortle J, Horan R D, Abler D. 2005. Value ofinformation for water quality management. Water ResourcesResearch, 41. doi: 10.1029/2004WR003576.

Bouwman L, Goldewijk K K, Van der Hoek K W, Beusen A HW, Van Vuuren D P, Willems J, Rufino M C, Stehfest E.2013. Exploring global changes in nitrogen and phosphoruscycles in agriculture induced by livestock productionover the 1900-2050 period Proceedings of the NationalAcademy of Sciences of the United States of America,110, 20882-20887

Chen J, Huang Y, Tang Y. 2011. Quantifying economicallyand ecologically optimum nitrogen rates for rice productionin south-eastern China. Agriculture, Ecosystems andEnvironment, 142, 195-204

Chen Y, Shuai J, Zhang Z, Shia P, Tao F. 2014. Simulating theimpact of watershed management for surface water qualityprotection: a case study on reducing inorganic nitrogen loadat a watershed scale. Ecological Engineering, 62, 61-70

Cheng Z, Wang S, Fu X, Watson J G, Jiang J, Fu Q, Chen C,Xu B, Yu J, Chow J C, Hao J. 2014. Impact of biomassburning on haze pollution in the Yangtze River delta, China:a case study in summer 2011. Atmospheric Chemistry andPhysics, 14, 4573-4585

Cui Z, Dou Z, Chen X, Ju X, Zhang F. 2014. Managingagricultural nutrients for food security in China: past,present, and future. Agronomy Journal, 106, 191-198

Gale F. 2013. Growth and Evolution in China’s Agricultural Support Policies. Economic Research Report No. 153.US Department of Agriculture, Washington, D.C., UnitedStates. [2014-3-20]. http://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/err-economic-research-report/err153.aspx

Ge C, Gao S, Ren Y, Sun G, Long F. 2011. Study on the designof wastewater environmental tax in China: from wastewaterpollutant discharge fee to environmental tax. In: Ashiabor H,Kreiser L, Sirisom J, Milne J E, eds., Environmental Taxationin China and Asia-Pacific: Achieving EnvironmentalSustainability Through Fiscal Policy. Edward Elgar,Cheltenham, UK. pp. 66-86

Han D. 2013. An Analysis of Chinese Agricultural and RuralEnvironmental Policies. Research Center for RuralEconomy, Ministry of Agriculture, Beijing, China. (inChinese)

Horan R D, Shortle J S, Abler D G. 2002. Ambient taxes underm-dimensional choice sets, heterogeneous expectations,and risk-aversion. Environmental and Resource Economics,21, 189-202

Horan R D, Shortle J S, Abler D G. 1998. Ambient taxes whenpolluters have multiple choices. Journal of EnvironmentalEconomics and Management, 36, 186-199

Hu R, Huang J, Chen K Z. 2012. The public agriculturalextension system in China: Development and reform.Background paper for the Roundtable Consultation onAgricultural Extension, Beijing, China, March 15-17,2012. [2014-4-15]. http://www.syngentafoundation.org/__temp/HU_HUANG_CHEN_AG_EXTN_CHINA_DEVELOPMENT_REFORM_May_18_2012.pdf

Jiang J, Li S, Hu J, Huang J. 2014. A modeling approach toevaluating the impacts of policy-induced land managementpractices on non-point source pollution: a case studyof the Liuxi River watershed, China. Agricultural WaterManagement, 131, 1-16

Jin Y, Lin L. 2014. China’s provincial industrial pollution: the roleof technical efficiency, pollution levy and pollution quantitycontrol. Environment and Development Economics, 19,111-132

Johnes P J. 1996. Evaluation and management of the impactof land use change on the nitrogen and phosphorus loaddelivered to surface waters: the export coefficient modellingapproach. Journal of Hydrology, 183, 323-349

Ju X T, Xing G X, Chen X P, Zhang S L, Zhang L J, Liu XJ, Cui Z L, Yin B, Christie P, Zhu Z L, Zhang F S. 2009.Reducing environmental risk by improving N managementin intensive Chinese agricultural systems. Proceedings ofthe National Academy of Sciences of the United States ofAmerica, 106, 8077-8078

Kim C G, Banfill J. 2011. A Policy Evaluation of Environmental-Friendly Direct Payment Programme in Korea. OECD, Paris,France. [2014-3-20]. http://www.oecd.org/tad/sustainableagriculture/48170214.pdf

Lei X G, Weaver J D, Mullaney E, Ullah A H, Azain M J. 2013.Phytase, a new life for an “old” enzyme. Annual Review ofAnimal Biosciences, 1, 283-309

Li J, Pu L, Han M, Zhu M, Zhang R, Xiang Y. 2014. Soilsalinization research in China: advances and prospects.Journal of Geographical Sciences, 24, 943-960

Li L, Li Y, Biswas D K, Nian Y, Jiang G. 2008. Potential ofconstructed wetlands in treating the eutrophic water:evidence from Taihu Lake of China. Bioresource Technology,99, 1656-1663

Li Y, Zhang W, Ma L, Huang G, Oenema O, Zhang F, Dou Z.2013. An analysis of China’s fertilizer policies: impacts onthe industry, food security, and the environment. Journalof Environmental Quality, 42, 972-981

Liu B, Liu H, Zhang B, Bi J. 2013. Modeling nutrient release inthe Tai Lake Basin of China: source identification and policyimplications. Environmental Management, 51, 724-737

Liu K, Luan S. 2012. Analysis on the applicability of fertilizertax in China. Advanced Materials Research, 433-440,1346-1349

Liu N, Zhou L, Hauger J S 2013. How sustainable isgovernment-sponsored desertification rehabilitation inChina? Behavior of households to changes in environmentalpolicies. PLOS ONE, 8. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0077510.

Liu R, Zhang P, Wang X, Chen Y, Shen Z. 2013. Assessmentof effects of best management practices on agriculturalnon-point source pollution in Xiangxi River watershed.Agricultural Water Management, 117, 9-18

Lu W C, Ma Y X, Bergmann H. 2014. Technological options toameliorate waste treatment of intensive pig production inChina: an analysis based on bio-economic model. Journalof Integrative Agriculture, 13, 443-454

Luo L, Wang Y, Qin L. 2014. Incentives for promoting agriculturalclean production technologies in China. Journal of CleanerProduction, 74, 54-61

Ma L, Feng S, Reidsma P, Qu F, Heerink N. 2014. Identifyingentry points to improve fertilizer use efficiency in TaihuBasin, China. Land Use Policy, 37, 52-59

Ministry of Environmental Protection of China, National Bureauof Statistics of China, Ministry of Agriculture of China. 2010.First National Census of Pollution Sources. Beijing, China.(in Chinese)

OECD. 2007. Instrument Mixes for Environmental Policy. Paris,France.

OECD. 2010. OECD Environmental Performance Reviews:Japan 2010. Paris, France.

OECD. 2012. Water Quality and Agriculture: Meeting the PolicyChallenge. Paris, France.

Ongley E D, Xiaolan Z, Tao Y. 2010. Current status ofagricultural and rural non-point source pollution assessmentin China. Environmental Pollution, 158, 1159-1168

Ouyang W, Hao G, Wei X, Huang H. 2013. Spatial and temporaltrend of Chinese manure nutrient pollution and assimilationcapacity of cropland and grassland. Environmental Scienceand Pollution Research, 20, 5036-5046

Peng S Z, Yang S H, Xu J Z, Luo Y F, Hou H J. 2011. Nitrogenand phosphorus leaching losses from paddy fields withdifferent water and nitrogen managements. Paddy and Water Environment, 9, 333-342

Rico A, Satapornvanit K, Haque M M, Min J, Nguyen P T,Telfer T C, van den Brink P J. 2012. Use of chemicalsand biological products in Asian aquaculture and theirpotential environmental risks: a critical review. Reviews inAquaculture, 4, 75-93

Shen Z, Liao Q, Hong Q, Gong Y. 2012. An overview of researchon agricultural non-point source pollution modelling in China.Separation and Purification Technology, 84, 104-111

Shortle J. 2012. Water Quality Trading in Agriculture. OECD,Paris, France. [2014-3-20]. http://www.oecd.org/tad/sustainable-agriculture/49849817.pdf

Shortle J S, Abler D. 2001. Environmental Policies forAgricultural Pollution Control. CABI Publishing, Wallingford,UK.

Sun B, Zhang L, Yang L, Zhang F, Norse D, Zhu Z. 2012.Agricultural non-point source pollution in China: causes andmitigation measures. Ambio, 41, 370-379

Wang F, Pan X, Wang D, Shen C, Lu Q. 2013. Combatingdesertification in China: past, present and future. Land UsePolicy, 31, 311-313

Wang X Q, Wang S, Zhang J M, Yang J P. 2011. The effect ofdietary supplementation with phytase transgenic corn ongrowth performance, phosphorus utilization and excretionin growing pigs (Sus scrofa). Agricultural Sciences in China,10, 769-776

Wu Y. 2011. Chemical fertilizer use efficiency and itsdeterminants in China’s farming sector: implications forenvironmental protection. China Agricultural EconomicReview, 3, 117-130

Yin R, Liu C, Zhao M, Yao S, Liu H. 2014. The implementationand impacts of China’s largest payment for ecosystemservices program as revealed by longitudinal householddata. Land Use Policy, 40, 45-55

Yu X, Abler D. 2014. Where have all the pigs gone?Inconsistencies in pork statistics in China. China EconomicReview, 30, 469-484

Yu X, Gao Z, Zeng Y. 2014. Willingness to pay for the “GreenFood” in China. Food Policy, 45, 80-87

Zhang B, Zhang H, Liu B, Bi J. 2013. Policy interactionsand underperforming emission trading markets in China.Environmental Science & Technology, 47, 7077−7084.

[1]	WANG Na, Joost Wolf, ZHANG Fu-suo. Towards sustainable intensification of apple production in China—Yield gaps and nutrient use efficiency in apple farming systems[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2016, 15(4): 716-725.
[2]	LIU Jian, ZUO Qiang, ZHAI Li-mei, LUO Chun-yan, LIU Hong-bin, WANG Hong-yuan, LIU Shen, ZOU Guo-yuan, REN Tian-zhi. Phosphorus losses via surface runoff in rice-wheat cropping systems as impacted by rainfall regimes and fertilizer applications[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2016, 15(3): 667-677.
[3]	XI Bin, ZHAI Li-mei, LIU Jian, LIU Shen, WANG Hong-yuan, LUO Chun-yan, REN Tian-zhi, LIU Hong-bin. Long-term phosphorus accumulation and agronomic and environmtal critical phosphorus levels in Haplic Luvisol soil, northern China[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2016, 15(1): 200-208.
[4]	XU Shi-wei, LI Gan-qiong, LI Zhe-min. China agricultural outlook for 2015–2024 based on China Agricultural Monitoring and Early-warning System (CAMES)[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2015, 14(9): 1889-1902.
[5]	David Norman. Transitioning from paternalism to empowerment of farmers in lowincome countries: Farming components to systems[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2015, 14(8): 1490-1499.
[6]	Tek B Sapkota, M L Jat, Jeetendra P Aryal, R K Jat, Arun Khatri-Chhetri. Climate change adaptation, greenhouse gas mitigation and economic profitability of conservation agriculture: Some examples from cereal systems of Indo-Gangetic Plains[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2015, 14(8): 1524-1533.
[7]	ZHANG Li-wei, Til Feike, Jirko Holst, Christa Hoffmann, Reiner Doluschitz. Comparison of energy consumption and economic performance of organic and conventional soybean production - A case study from Jilin Province, China[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2015, 14(8): 1561-1572.
[8]	MIN Shi, BAI Jun-fei, James Seale Jr., Thomas Wahl. Demographics, societal aging, and meat consumption in China[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2015, 14(6): 995-1007.
[9]	Christine Burggraf, Lena Kuhn, ZHAO Qi-ran, Ramona Teuber, Thomas Glauben. Economic growth and nutrition transition: an empirical analysis comparing demand elasticities for foods in China and Russia[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2015, 14(6): 1008-1022.
[10]	Satoru Shimokawa. Sustainable meat consumption in China[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2015, 14(6): 1023-1032.
[11]	XIAO Hong-bo, CHEN Qiong, WANG Ji-min, Les Oxley, MA Heng-yun. The puzzle of the missing meat: Food away from home and China’s meat statistics[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2015, 14(6): 1033-1044.
[12]	TIAN Xu, SUN Fei-fei, ZHOU Ying-heng. Technical efficiency and its determinants in China’s hog production[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2015, 14(6): 1057-1068.
[13]	ZHOU Ying-heng, ZHANG Xiao-heng, TIAN Xu, GENG Xian-hui, ZHANG Peng, YAN Bin-jian. Technical and environmental efficiency of hog production in China -A stochastic frontier production function analysis[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2015, 14(6): 1069-1080.
[14]	CHENG Ya-hao, Zhifeng Gao, James Seale Jr.. Changing structure of China’s meat imports[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2015, 14(6): 1081-1091.
[15]	YU Wu-sheng, CAO Li-juan. China’s meat and grain imports during 2000–2012 and beyond: A comparative perspective[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2015, 14(6): 1101-1114.