Triple bottom-line consideration of sustainable plant disease management: From economic, sociological and ecological perspectives

doi:10.1016/S2095-3119(21)63627-4

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

面对人类诸多困境，联合国提出了粮食安全、人类健康、社会经济发展、资源保护和生态恢复等可持续发展目标。植物病害防控对实现这些目标可发挥重要作用，但有些防控措施也无意识地带来了社会、生态和经济的负面结果，而这些后果并没有由相关责任人来承担，即产生了负外部性。同时，由于生产者及其他社会主体的利益诉求差异、防控经济阈值把握不到位以及未弄清防控效率、盈利性和生态功能性之间的复杂关系等原因，植物病害防控的策略选择和技术实施都受到了很大限制。在经济社会体系中，植物病害防控的可持续发展既受制于技术内在属性，也取决于社会经济因素（如利润、预期、沉默成本、机会成本、政策、偏好等）。可见，要引导和推动植物病害防控的可持续发展，既需弄清其经济、社会和生态效应，开展以生产能力、盈利性、生物进化等为主要内容的综合评价，揭示其短期效应（如成本、收益、便利性、有效性等）和长期效应（如病原生物进化、农业生产可恢复性、生物时空多样性等），也需明晰植物病害防控的正负外部性，为政府平衡植物病害防控的社会、生态和经济效益的决策提供理论和应用支撑。此外，考虑到未来植物病害防控策略和技术的可选择性以及效益溢出问题，除了优化技术、平衡技术和农产品供需市场外，政府、研究人员、生产者和消费者之间的信息对称性也应予更为充分的重视和研究。

Abstract:

Plant disease management plays an important role in achieving the sustainable development goals of the United Nations (UN) such as food security, human health, socio-economic improvement, resource conservation and ecological resilience. However, technologies available are often limited due to different interests between producers and society and lacks of proper understanding of economic thresholds and the complex interactions among ecology, productivity and profitability. A comprehensive synergy and conflict evaluation of economic, sociological and ecological effects with technologies, productions and evolutionary principles as main components should be used to guide sustainable disease management that aims to mitigate crop and economic losses in the short term while maintaining functional farm ecosystem in the long term. Consequently, there should be an increased emphasis on technology development, public education and information exchange among governments, researchers, producers and consumers to broaden the options for disease management in the future.

Key words: plant disease management , agricultural sustainability , disease economics , food security , resource conservation

. [J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2021, 20(10): 2581-2591.

HE Dun-chun, Jeremy J. BURDON, XIE Lian-hui, Jiasui ZHAN. Triple bottom-line consideration of sustainable plant disease management: From economic, sociological and ecological perspectives[J]. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 2021, 20(10): 2581-2591.

参考文献

Abboud T G, Zubaer A, Wai A, Hausner G. 2018. The complete mitochondrial genome of the Dutch elm disease fungus Ophiostoma novo-ulmi subsp. novo-ulmi. Canadian Journal of Microbiology, 64, 339–348.
Agost L, Velázquez G A. 2020. Peri-urban pesticide contamination risk index. Ecological Indicators, 114, 106338.
Almeida R P P. 2018. Emerging plant disease epidemics: Biological research is key but not enough, PLoS Biology, 16, e2007020.
Bak R O, Gomez-Ospina N, Porteus M H. 2018. Gene editing on center stage. Trends in Genetics, 34, 600–611.
Basso B, Antle J. 2020. Digital agriculture to design sustainable agricultural systems. Nature Sustainability, 3, 254–256.
Borsellino V, Schimmenti E, El Bilali H. 2020. Agri-food markets towards sustainable patterns. Sustainability, 12, 2193.
Burdon J J, Barrett L G, Rebetzke G, Thrall P H. 2014. Guiding deployment of resistance in cereals using evolutionary principle. Evolutionary Applications, 7, 609–624.
Burdon J J, Barrett L G, Yang L N, He D C, Zhan J. 2020. Maximizing world food production through disease control. BioScience, 70, 126–128.
Burdon J J, Thrall P H. 2014. What have we learned from studies of wild plant-pathogen associations? - The dynamic interplay of time, space and life-history. European Journal of Plant Pathology, 138, 417–429.
Carroll C L, Carter C A, Goodhue R E, Lawell C C L, Subbarao K V. 2018. A review of control options and externalities for verticillium wilts. Phytopathology, 108, 160–171.
Clark S L, Schlarbaum S E, Saxton A M, Baird R. 2019. Eight-year blight (Cryphonectria parasitica) resistance of backcross-generation American chestnuts (Castanea dentata) planted in the southeastern United States. Forest Ecology and Management, 433, 153–161.
Durán P, Thiergart T, Garrido-Oter R, Agler M, Kemen E, Schulze-Lefert P, Hacquard S. 2018. Microbial interkingdom interactions in roots promote Arabidopsis survival. Cell, 175, 973–983.
Echodu R, Edema H, Wokorach G, Zawedde C, Otim G, Luambano N, Ateka E M, Asiimwe T. 2019. Farmers’ practices and their knowledge of biotic constraints to sweetpotato production in East Africa. Physiological and Molecular Plant Pathology, 105, 3–16.
Eddleston M, Buckley N A, Eyer P, Dawson A H. 2008. Management of acute organophosphorus pesticide poisoning. Lancet, 371, 597–607.
Ficke A, Cowger C, Bergstrom G, Brodal G. 2018. Understanding yield loss and pathogen biology to improve disease management: Septoria Nodorum Blotch - A case study in wheat. Plant Disease, 102, 696–707.
Gossmann T I, Keightley P D, Eyre-Walker A. 2012. The effect of variation in the effective population size on the rate of adaptive molecular evolution in eukaryotes. Genome Biology and Evolution, 4, 658–667.
Gullino M L, Baribaldi A. 2006. Diseases of roses: Evolution of problems and new approaches for their control. Acta Horticulturae, 422, 195–201.
Ha T M, Shakur S, Pham Do K H. 2019. Rural–urban differences in willingness to pay for organic vegetables: Evidence from Vietnam. Appetite, 14, 104273.
Hatfield J L, McMullen L D, Jone C S. 2009. Nitrate-nitrogen patterns in the Raccoon River Basin related to agricultural practices. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 64, 190–199.
He D C, Zhan J, Xie L H. 2016. Problems, challenges and future of plant disease management: From an ecological point of view. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 15, 705–715.
Houbraken M, Bauweraerts I, Fevery D, Van Labeke M C, Spanoghe P. 2016. Pesticide knowledge and practice among horticultural workers in the Lâm ??ng region, Vietnam: A case study of chrysanthemum and strawberries. Science of the Total Environment, 550, 1001–1009.
Hruska Z, Yao H, Kincaid R, Tao F, Brown R L, Cleveland T E, Rajasekaran K, Bhatnagar D. 2020. Spectral-based screening approach evaluating two specific maize lines with divergent resistance to invasion by aflatoxigenic fungi. Frontiers in Microbiology, 10, 3152.
Landguth E L, Holden Z A, Mahalovich M F, Cushman S A. 2017. Using landscape genetics simulations for planting blister rust resistant whitebark pine in the US northern rocky mountains. Frontiers in Genetics, 8, 9.
Lee S H, Shin H, Kim J H, Ryu K Y, Kim H T, Cha B, Cha J S. 2019. Effect on colony growth inhibition of soil-borne fungal pathogens by available chlorine content in sodium hypochlorite. The Plant Pathology Journal, 35, 156–163.
Leong W H, Teh S Y, Hossain M M, Nadarajaw T, Zabidi-Hussin Z, Chin S Y, Lai K S, Erin Lim S H. 2020. Application, monitoring and adverse effects in pesticide use: The importance of reinforcement of Good Agricultural Practices (GAPs). Journal of Environmental Management, 260, 109987.
Li F, Upadhyaya N M, Sperschneider J, Matny O, Nguyen-Phuc H, Mago R, Raley C, Miller M E, Silverstein K A T, Henningsen E, Hirsch C D, Visser B, Pretorius Z A, Steffenson B J, Schwessinger B, Dodds P N, Figueroa M. 2019. Emergence of the Ug99 lineage of the wheat stem rust pathogen through somatic hybridisation. Nature Communications, 10, 5068.
Li S, Wu F, Duan Y P, Singerman A, Guan Z F. 2020. Citrus greening: Management strategies and their economic impact. HortScience, 55, 604–612.
Li Y, van der Lee T A, Evenhuis A, van den Bosch G B, van Bekkum P J, Förch M G, van Gent-Pelzer M P, van Raaij H M, Jacobsen E, Huang S W, Govers F, Vleeshouwers V G, Kessel G J. 2012. Population dynamics of Phytophthora infestans in the Netherlands reveals expansion and spread of dominant clonal lineages and virulence in sexual offspring. Genes, Genomes, Genetics, 2, 1529–1540.
Ma P, Xu H, Xu Y, Song L, Liang S, Sheng Y, Han G, Zhang X, An D. 2018. Characterization of a powdery mildew resistance gene in wheat breeding line 10v-2 and its application in marker-assisted selection. Plant Disease, 102, 925–931.
Mandalà G, Tundo S, Francesconi S, Gevi F, Zolla L, Ceoloni C, D’Ovidio R. 2019. Deoxynivalenol detoxification in transgenic wheat confers resistance to Fusarium head blight and crown rot diseases. Molecular Plant–Microbe Interactions, 32, 583–592.
Massey M, O’Cass A, Otahal P. 2018. A meta-analytic study of the factors driving the purchase of organic food. Appetite, 125, 418–427.
Mazigo H D, Massawe I S, Rumisha S F, Kweka E J, Mboera L E G. 2019. Rice farmers’ perceptions and acceptability in the use of a combination of biolarvicide (Bacillus thuringiensis var. israeliensis) and fertilizers application for malaria control and increase rice productivity in a rural district of central Tanzania. Malaria Journal, 18, 71.
Mesa J M, Scholes D R, Juvik J A, Paige K N. 2017. Molecular constraints on resistance-tolerance trade-offs. Ecology, 98, 2528–2537.
Mi J, Yang D, Chen Y, Jiang J, Mou H, Huang J, Ouyang Y, Mou T. 2018. Accelerated molecular breeding of a novel P/TGMS line with broad-spectrum resistance to rice blast and bacterial blight in two-line hybrid rice. Rice, 11, 11.
Mundt C C. 2002. Use of multiline cultivars and cultivar mixtures for disease management. Annual Review of Phytopathology, 40, 381–410.
Napier J A, Haslam R P, Tsalavouta M, Sayanova O. 2019. The challenges of delivering genetically modified crops with nutritional enhancement traits. Nature Plants, 5, 563–567.
Nogueira M S, Decundo J, Martinez M, Dieguez S N, Moreyra F, Moreno M V, Stenglein S A. 2018. Natural contamination with mycotoxins produced by Fusarium graminearum and Fusarium poae in malting barley in argentina. Toxins, 10, 78.
Papaïx J, Burdon J J, Zhan J, Thrall P H. 2015. Crop pathogen emergence and evolution in agro-ecological landscapes. Evolutionary Applications, 8, 385–402.
Paul R, Saville A C, Hansel J C, Ye Y, Ball C, Williams A, Chang X, Chen G, Gu Z, Ristaino J B, Wei Q. 2019. Extraction of plant dna by microneedle patch for rapid detection of plant diseases. ACS Nano, 13, 6540–6549.
Rajasekaran K, Sayler R J, Majumdar R, Sickler C M, Cary J W. 2019. Inhibition of Aspergillus flavus growth and aflatoxin production in transgenic maize expressing the α-amylase inhibitor from Lablab purpureus L. Journal of Visualized Experiments, 144, e59169.
Rimbaud L, Dallot S, Bruchou C, Thoyer S, Jacquot E, Soubeyrand S, Thébaud G. 2019. Improving management strategies of plant diseases using sequential sensitivity analyses. Phytopathology, 109, 1184–1197.
Rosenheim J A, Cass B N, Kahl H, Steinmann K P. 2020. Variation in pesticide use across crops in California agriculture: Economic and ecological drivers. Science of the Total Environment, 733, 138683.
Savary S, Willocquet L, Pethybridge S J, Esker P, McRoberts N, Nelson A. 2019. The global burden of pathogens and pests on major food crops. Nature Ecology & Evolution, 3, 430–439.
Scala V, Pucci N, Loreti S. 2018. The diagnosis of plant pathogenic bacteria: A state of art. Frontiers in Bioscience, 10, 449–460.
Sherman J, Burke J M, Gent D H. 2019. Cooperation and coordination in plant disease management. Phytopathology, 109,1720–1731.
Soares M P, Teixeira L, Moita L F. 2017. Disease tolerance and immunity in host protection against infection. Nature Reviews Immunology, 17, 83–96.
Sommerhalder R J, McDonald B A, Mascher F, Zhan J. 2011. Effect of hosts on competition among clones and evidence of differential selection between pathogenic and saprophytic phases in experimental populations of the wheat pathogen. BMC Evolutionary Biology, 11, 188.
Sponsler D B, Grozinger C M, Hitaj C, Rundlöf M, Botías C, Code A, Lonsdorf E V, Smith D J, Suryanarayanan S, Thogmartin W E, Williams N, Zhang M, Douglas M R. 2019. Pesticides and pollinators: A socioecological synthesis. Science of the Total Environment, 662, 1012–1027.
Springmann M, Clark M, Mason-D’Croz D, Wiebe K, Bodirsky B L, Lassaletta L, de Vries W, Vermeulen S J, Herrero M, CarlsonK M, Jonell M, Troell M, DeClerck F, Gordon L J, Zurayk R, Scarborough P, Rayner M, Loken B, Fanzo J, Godfray H C J, et al. 2018. Options for keeping the food system within environmental limits. Nature, 562, 519–525.
Subhalakshmi T. 2019. Integrated disease management in organic farming: A review. International Journal of Current Microbiology and Applied Sciences, 8, 2440–2449.
Tang X Y, Yang Y, Tam N F, Tao R, Dai Y N. 2019. Pesticides in three rural rivers in Guangzhou, China: Spatiotemporal distribution and ecological risk. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 26, 3569–3577.
Thompson N M, Epplin F M, Edwards J T, Hunger R M. 2014. Economics of foliar fungicides for hard red winter wheat in the USA southern Great Plains. Crop Protection, 59, 1–6.
Varah A, Ahodo K, Coutts S R, Hicks H L, Comont D, Crook L, Hull R, Neve P, Childs D Z, Freckleton R P, Norris K. 2020. The costs of human-induced evolution in an agricultural system. Nature Sustainability, 3, 63–71.
Verger P J, Boobis A R. 2013. Reevaluate pesticides for food security and safety. Science, 341, 717–718.
Wolfe M S. 1985. The current status and prospects of multiline cultivars and variety mixtures for disease resistance. Annual Review of Phytopathology, 23, 251–273.
Yang L N, Pan Z, Zhu W, Wu E, He D C, Yuan X, Qin Y, Wang Y, Chen R, Thrall P H, Burdon J J, Shang L P, Sui Q J, Zhan J. 2019. Enhanced agricultural sustainability through within-species diversification. Nature Sustainability, 2, 46–52.
Yang Y, Zhang J, Yao Y. 2017. Enantioselective effects of chiral pesticides on their primary targets and secondary targets. Current Protein & Peptide Science, 18, 22–32.
Zhan J, McDonald B A. 2013. Experimental measures of pathogen competition and relative fitness. Annual Review of Phytopathology, 51, 131–153.
Zhan J, Mundt C C, Hoffer M E, McDonald B A. 2002. Local adaptation and effect of host genotype on the rate of pathogen evolution: An experimental test in a plant pathosystem. Journal of Evolutionary Biology, 15, 634–647.
Zhan J, Thrall P H, Burdon J J. 2014. Achieving sustainable plant disease management through evolutionary principles. Trends in Plant Science, 19, 570–575.
Zhan J, Thrall P H, Papaïx J, Xie L, Burdon J J. 2015. Playing on a pathogen’s weakness: Using evolution to guide sustainable plant disease control strategies. Annual Review of Phytopathology, 53, 19–43.
Zheng F, Li Y, Zhang Z, Jia J, Hu P, Zhang C, Xu H. 2020. Novel strategy with an eco-friendly polyurethane system to improve rainfastness of tea saponin for highly efficient rice blast control. Journal of Cleaner Production, 264, 121685.
Zheng R R, Zhan J, Liu L X, Ma Y L, Wang Z S, Xie L H, He D C. 2019. Factors and minimal subsidy associated with tea farmers’ willingness to adopt ecological pest management. Sustainability, 11, 6190.